png illustrations rejected for quality reasons whereas similar ones were accepted

I have made quite a few rubber stamp text effect illustrations (png), all of them made from the same pattern, high resolution (6 900 X 3 400 px, 300 ppi).

 

By @nathalie4541

The PPI value is irrelevant.

---

@nathalie4541 wrote:

I made some in english and in french. (these are in french (officiel)). The ones in french have been rejected whereas they are of the same quality as all the accepted ones (many of them), even better because I vectorized them before saving them, like I did with servral accepted ones.

I do not get it. Why would the other ones be accepted and these two not ? I made them a second time from scratch to be sure they were OK.  Some of the accepted ones are even of slightly lower quality.

???

---

Were the refusals “Quality Issues” or “Similar Image(s) Already Submitted”?

I suppose you deleted the attached asset. If you did so, it would be great to mark your modified post, so that the historic can be understood.

Something like: “I deleted the originally attached file to protect my IP.” would be great.

Hi @nathalie4541 

There are areas outside the scope of the characters and border that need cleaning up. The same is true for the second image.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

Probably reviewed by different Moderators. I suppose that they're trained to evaluate the edge cutout quality of transparent PNG's. If they did so with these images, without regard to the fact that the images are emulating an old worn rubber stamp, they would reject. 

The resolution does not matter. I think the rough edges are the problem with transparent backgrounds.