Skip to main content
Ed.Macke
Inspiring
March 12, 2013
Question

Discussion / Comment View Styles

  • March 12, 2013
  • 1 reply
  • 2494 views

Not sure if this is the correct place for this question - please feel free to redirect if needed...

When I go to Your Stuff > Preferences > General Preferences, there is an option under General Settings for Discussion View Style and Comment View Style.

It has a dropdown to let me choose whether I want Flat, or... well, Flat. There is only one choice.

Why is there no "Hierarchical"?

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

mytaxsite
Inspiring
March 12, 2013

Why is there no "Hierarchical"?

Because Adobe wants you to have flat style on their forums.  There is no hierarchical view on my profile either.

good luck.

Ed.Macke
Ed.MackeAuthor
Inspiring
March 12, 2013

Because Adobe wants you to have flat style on their forums.

Adobe sounds like Henry Ford: "You can have your Model T in any color you like as long as it's black".

the_wine_snob
Inspiring
March 15, 2013

...flat and threaded. The latter doesn't fit in the fixed-column page layout used on this site...

Unfortunately, the former doesn't fit with my brain's layout when trying to follow a thread!


Ed,

I totally agree with you, and before Threaded was disabled, would switch back and forth. I also filed requests to allow the view to be easily toggled, rather than a global setting in Preferences - a "big-button" switch, if you will.

I spend time on several other forums, and most offer a useful version of a Threaded view. I would love to see Jive go to something similar.

On the Adobe Forums, there are extra features, available with Flattened View, like Reply #'s, which are very important when pointing a poster to the exact Reply, that addressed their question. In the old Threaded View, there were no Reply #'s, but at least one could easily see to whom the Reply was being made - though one CAN look at the header of a Reply to find out that info. Unfortunately, one often has to do some major scrolling, to see which of that person's Replies was being Replied to.

I have come to accept the Flattened only View, and just scroll about, to find the real context. A single toggle button would be better (or a really good Threaded View to begin with), but that seems to be out of the question now.

Hunt