Skip to main content
A
Anonymous
December 10, 2009
Question

Thanks from Q

  • December 10, 2009
  • 1 reply
  • 3348 views

I am now allowed to post as my ban has been lifted.  To those that took a stand in my favor I am truly grateful.  Your support and kind words I will always treasure.  I must also acknowledge my appreciation to two of the people that oversee these forums.  I believe it is John and Rick.  It appears that these individuals decided to review my ban and found it not warranted.  I sincerely thank both of you.  I

I do, however, want it known that I am not celebrating a PARDON, as that would indicate that I have been guilty of some offense but was forgiven.  I still maintain that I did nothing wrong and that I was unfairly banned without any warning.

Although I could not log-in I did read the posts every day.  I grew angry over some of the comments made by a VERY FEW moderators.  Such as; "People are only banned after repeatedly not obeying the rules of the forums."  Or that "People receive warnings before being banned."  And my favorite,  "Send an e-mail, apologize and ask to have ban lifted."  Paraphrasing, not exact quotes.

In my case I made ONE post critical of the forums and how they are being moderated.

Please note I was not rude, did not make fun of anyone and I most certainly did not use profanity.  I received an e-mail informing me that I had been banned.  It did not inform me what I did to bring this about.  It did say to e-mail back with any questions.  I did so twice and never got a reply.  My e-mail did not contain an apology but it was respectful.

After my experience, I can only conclude that all bans should be voided.  Start over and use some common sense.  Moderators should moderate, not dictate.  Having the attitude that one is always right and never wrong leads nowhere and certainly doesn't gain respect.  I'm aware of only one moderator that fits this description.  The rest, I believe, are doing the best they can with what they have.

Q

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    1 reply

    Captiv8r
    Captiv8r
    Legend
    December 10, 2009

    Hi Q

    For what it's worth, I had never heard of your forum identity until Linda (LRK 2) posted to ask why you had been banned. I'm pleased to have helped in some small way but by no means am I directly responsible other than asking around to see if Adobe would take a second look.

    Linda deserves all the credit for the polite and mature way she handled presenting your case here.

    It seems most unfortunate that you apparently were simply banned without warning. I still can't help but to wonder if your ban was some odd mistake. Perhaps a mistyped letter or whatever.

    At any rate, nice to meet you! Rick

    A
    Anonymous
    December 10, 2009

    and Linda, I, too, thank you for getting the actions done that led to the removal of the ban for Q.

    Rick, for the record, others had asked why the bans, why no explanations, etc, including the ban on Q.  Those questions fell on deaf ears.  I am very happy that Linda was able to break the silence.

    I agree with Q, the bans should be lifted and clearly thought out before banning anyone from the forums.

    Adobe MUST realize that these folks are the people who purchase their software and keep their company in business.  To ban, without properly informing and without sound judgement only harms the reputation of the company.  I am sure that is not what the company shareholders want to see  happen.

    S
    shunithD
    Inspiring
    December 12, 2009

    Hi Paz

    While I'm aware that the fora where I participate are but a small segment of the Adobe spectrum, I'd like to point out that we suffered no discernable casualties of knowledgeable folks walking away as a result of the forum changeover. Our communities are just as strong as they were prior to Jive. So it's not really fair to claim or suggest that things are falling apart for Adobe as a whole, based totally on the fora where you participate.

    Cheers... Rick


    Captiv8r wrote:

    While I'm aware that the fora where I participate are but a small segment of the Adobe spectrum, I'd like to point out that we suffered no discernable casualties of knowledgeable folks walking away as a result of the forum changeover.

    Perhaps in the forum, or forums, you frequent. But Dreamweaver has taken a huge beating... all the truly good ones have left... from the old lot, i think just Murray and David Powers are left. Photoshop has taken an equal beating. Regarding the others i cannot say. New contributors may be coming along... but they can in no way make up for the loss of the old.

    Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
    Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices