Skip to main content

70 replies

Known Participant
May 14, 2025

There are genuinely enough forum posts about this topic going back maybe a decade? I can find them with upvotes, and huge comment chains as far back as 2012 at the earliest.

 

Why is this still an ongoing issue? Why is this difficult to create? Why does CapCut or DaVinci (Free, or one-time payment structured apps) have this capability?

There are no posts regarding this in 2025 so I'd love to bring this back up into Adobe attention since apparently we're still pushing way beyond AI usage when basic things like beat detection and ACCESIBLE COLOR THEORY are STILL not utilized by the developers. Good job Adobe here's another $600!

Translate
Paul Styler
Known Participant
May 4, 2025

Dear Adobe Team,

I’d like to propose a native feature in Premiere Pro: automatic beat detection with marker placement directly on the audio clip or timeline.

Currently, many editors rely on third-party tools like BeatEdit to analyze audio tracks and generate beat markers.

This feature is essential for anyone editing music-driven content — such as trailers, music videos, reels, or commercial teasers — where rhythm and visual pacing must align with audio beats.

 

Why this is valuable:
Saves time: No need for manual tapping or syncing markers to the beat by hand.

Increases precision: Algorithms can detect subtle beats more consistently than humans.

Improves workflow: Built-in tools mean less dependency on external plugins and fewer compatibility issues.

Perfect for AI-driven editing: Future auto-editing features could use these beat markers for automated cut points.

 

Suggested Implementation:
Add a "Detect Beats" option in the right-click context menu on audio clips or in the timeline panel.

Allow customization: detect every beat, every second beat, or only strong beats.

Option to place markers on the clip or on the sequence timeline.

Ideally, integrate this feature into the Essential Sound panel or as part of the Audio Analysis tools.

Given how rhythmically timed editing is a massive part of modern video production, this feature would be a game-changer — and it feels like a natural next step for Premiere Pro.

Thank you for considering!

Translate
aayushnevatia
Participating Frequently
April 25, 2025

Oh great, while Adobe keeps blessing us with groundbreaking features like making the cursor blink differently or adding another shade of grey to the interface — how about we get something editors actually want? Like AI Beat Detect that automatically places markers on music. You know, a feature that would actually save hours instead of just looking cool in the update log. But yeah, let’s keep pretending rounded buttons were the real priority.

Translate
Ann Bens
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

Just drop a adjustment layer over the footage > select adjustment layer > hit Play  > hit M for marker.

Translate
MyerPj
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

Heading towards a year for this thread, despite the 'game changer' pontifications there are only 10 upvotes, about 1 per month. Most of the posters here are certain they don't want (to spend on) a 3rd party app, as they think beat detection is a universally desired feature. I think it's a specialty, because I for one, would just listen to the built in beat detector in my head. Otherwise, there are good ones around, like this: https://aescripts.com/beatedit-for-premiere-pro/ for a reasonable price for this specialty application.

 

Translate
R Neil Haugen
Legend
March 26, 2025

Most of the professional long-time users would strongly disagree with your thoughts. Which is fine. we are all different.

 

But as an example, another commonly stated complaint is that with each major version, Adobe is rushing to "dumb down" Premiere Pro for YouTubers. With the new "AI" ... really machine learning ... tools and all.

 

Rather an opposite, and as firmly held view, as yours.

 

Of the same program. 

Translate
Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Known Participant
March 26, 2025

Professional apps should have the capabilities and features of all prosumer apps, and then the customizable and technical power of their professional framework. The fact that a consumer app like CapCut can manage to implement, bulldoze, update and grow with feedback is not a drawback on its software but rather should be a stark and truthfully brutal wake up call to Adobe software engineers. This is not a prosumer application feature, this is a paying customer base demanding basic and fundamental functions from an extremely arrogant software company.

Translate
R Neil Haugen
Legend
March 25, 2025

I'm not at all surprised that you are suprised. Been there myself, of course, if a few years back now.

 

Most everyone coming from the prosumer apps to the full-on professional video post apps gets a huge shock. Because they are used to apps that are designed to do things for the user, with the user getting some partial contol over the effect or process.

 

The professional apps have all been built assuming the professional user wants absolute, total control over every aspect and detail of everything. And so details, processes, and options have tons of sub-options and choices ... and ... you must have a basic familiarity of that effect/process before you can sort out which options you probably want.

 

The recent addition of some things that are automated has actually been rather controversial among a lot of the users ... scared that they are dumbing down the apps to a prosumer level. Along with capabilities and controls by the user.

Translate
Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Participant
March 25, 2025

Even c*pc*t has this!! I'm switching from that software to premiere pro and this is such a major shock to me! i wish that adobe had automatic beat generator as well</3

Translate
R Neil Haugen
Legend
March 15, 2025

Ae basically terrifies me at first glance, every time. But then, I only go into it a few times a year, right?

 

And after a few minutes, I get back into the working pattern of that app, which is so different, and it just ... works. And does amazing stuff for short bits.

Translate
Everyone's mileage always varies ...