Participant

Open for Voting

Bring back the old mask system.

Forum|Forum|4 months ago
May 8, 2026
7 replies
131 views

I recently updated to Premiere Pro 2026 and went to create a mask. To my surprise and confusion, there was no option to do so in the Effect Controls. So, after being forced to research it online, I finally found that masks were inexplicably moved to the toolbar. Annoying and unnecessary, but whatever.

I went to try keyframing the mask path… and nothing happened. I then had to conduct further research online to find out that, for some reason, I have to right-click on the mask and assign it to “Opacity.” Another extra step that makes no sense.

So, I figured that it should finally work. Spoiler: it did not. At this point, I was enraged. Ready to punch my monitor, throw my PC out the window, mere seconds from a crashout. What else could I possibly need to do to create something so simple as an opacity mask? After consulting the internet for the THIRD time, I found that I’m supposed to switch the mask from “Frame” mode to “Clip” mode. Unbelievable.

What is it with Adobe and fixing stuff that isn’t broken?! Why did you think anyone wanted this?!? Now I have to do 35 extra clicks to achieve something that took me two seconds before. I honestly think I’m going to roll back to the 2025 version because of this, and that’s because I know this post is pointless and no one at Adobe will actually listen to what their customers want. But this made me so furious that I had to unleash it upon you somehow. All I can hope is that other people like me will see this and find solace in the fact that they’re not alone.

And for the love of god, stop forcing AI down our throats.

J

john96134624

Participant

I am experiencing exactly the same issue in Premiere Pro 26.x.

I am NOT using automatic mask tracking. I am manually animating a mask.

The mask is set to Frame mode, and I move the playhead to another frame and reposition the mask manually in the Program Monitor. Sometimes a Position keyframe is created automatically, but sometimes no keyframe is created at all.

This behavior is inconsistent and makes manual mask animation unreliable.

I would also strongly prefer the previous masking workflow, where masks could be created directly from individual effects and animated intuitively with Mask Path keyframes.

Please investigate the inconsistent keyframe behavior in Frame mode.

L

lacey_5212

Participant

Amen! It can work pretty good, but when it doesn’t work, i mean it REALLY doesn’t work. My current project i need several masks, and am resorting to a bunch of adjustment layers. Epic Fail, Adobe!

M

Matt296074007fj8

Participant

If they aren’t going to bring back the other system, which really wasn’t broken, they could at least make a keyboard shortcut to snap your next mask point to a XY axis. Making vertical / horizontal points is basically guesswork.

K

Kevin-Monahan

Community Manager

Hello @shanesmallshaw,
Thanks for the feature request. While the team considers your request, feel free to check out the FAQ on the new masking system, which contains links to helpful articles and user guide information. I hope it is helpful: Premiere 2026: Masking FAQs & Links

For quick references, here are links to the help pages on masking:

Rectangle, Ellipse and Pen Tool Help X: https://helpx.adobe.com/premiere/desktop/add-video-effects/work-with-masks/rectangle-ellipse-and-pen-masks.html
Difference between Clip Mode & Frame Mode in Program Monitor Help X: https://helpx.adobe.com/premiere/desktop/add-video-effects/work-with-masks/adjust-masks-at-the-clip-or-frame-level.html
Adobe Care Object Mask Guide: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2P3ln2tx-U
Adobe Care Vector Masking Guide: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-kZ-cITWLCk

I hope this helps!

Thanks,
Kevin

R Neil Haugen

Legend

The new masking system can be frustrating as it is so different than before. Which is why they have a dialog box that pops up on the screen anytime you hover over the new Masking tool icon ... with the link to the documentation given in that tool tip.

Click the link, you go right to the specific instructions on how to use the new system. It takes maybe 10-15 mintues to really start learning it, and that’s of course annoyning mid-job.

However ... the entire tool is a vast improvement, and after you get past the annoyance, I’ve talked with a lot of users ... and none who’ve learned the new tool want the old limited piece of crud back. I certainly don’t.

Everyone's mileage always varies ...

MuvStudio Studio

Participant

A adobe tentou um sistema de rotoscopia direta no Premiere e retirou o sistema antigo de máscara, a decisão mais burra e inútil dos últimos tempos. Desenvolvedores devem ver esta minha mensagem e me chamar de burro por simplesmente não entender como aquilo funciona, absolutamente todas as vezes que consegui utilizar eu simplesmente não sei como fiz funcionar. São 02:31 da madrugada aqui no Brasil e eu fiz questão de parar tudo que estava fazendo e procurar alguma forma de comunicar isso num meio oficial para que fiquem cientes e mais pessoas possam expressar a insatisfação, afim de quem mudem ou retornem como era antes. SISTEMA HORRIVEL, NÃO É INTUITIVO, NINGUEM GOSTOU, NINGUEM PEDIU PRA MUDAR O MODELO DE ANTES, APENAS MELHOREM ISTO PORFAVOR.

R Neil Haugen

Legend

Understand, please, that we are all simply one user. You didn’t ask for the change, but you should realize many others have been pleading for this exact change. I know, I’ve talked with a lot of them.

As said over and again, it is far more powerful, but very different, and it does take a few minutes going through all the Help articles on it to get a decent idea of how it works. And … all the options including keyboard shorts for doing things. And then for most of us, a half hour or more of simply doing things so we remember how to do them next time.

For probably 85% of jobs, it’s either faster or at least no slower. For 10% of that other 15%, it can work once you know how to make it work, but may involve an extra click or keyboard tap.

And … there is that 5% or so that is simply harder to do this way.

I can guarantee, if they reverted the complete system at this time, the howls here and elsewhere would be legendary. This has made tons of editors so pleased.

That said, not all users, unfortunately. And I so get the 2 am “what the HADES is this mess?” thing. Been there done that.

Everyone's mileage always varies ...

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.