Known Participant

Answered

Question about quality

22 replies
1956 views
Translate

I am not entierly sure what do they mean by quality. Are they against surrealistic transformation of the doctor, or disliking the chaotic visual style of the villain?

Contributor critique

This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.

AbamboCorrect answer

Community Expert

If they do that for surrealistic art depicting clearly mutating person, then they are just being ridiculous.

By @Andrew28402168wx0r

You have enough problems with that picture. One of those is enough to earn you a refusal for quality issues.

You really need to understand, that even for the most outlandish claims, you need to keep it logical. Even if you argue that you have a transformation of the person, and that therefore that person can be deformed at will (a claim that I would contest strongly), simple accessories still have to be well-designed.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer

Nancy OShea

Community Expert

OK. First image. How many fingers and thumbs do human's have? I know you know this...

And while you're at it, check if the right and left hands are on the correct arms.

Rinse, lather & repeat with all other elements in your AI generated designs.

As you can see, AI is very stupid with details. It's incumbent upon you to take make sense out of AI's nonsense & blunders. If you can't fix it, discard the image. It's probably more trouble to fix than it's worth in royalty fees anyway.

That's the cost of generative AI. You win some, you lose a lot more. And Adobe Stock doesn't give out free passes for quality errors. Too many customers would complain.

Translate

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert

PaintedKitty

Community Expert

Over all these would be considered fine art and not clip art. In my opinion I wold not do fine art for clip art places. People need clip art for their own put together projects such as advertising some event or product. Maybe these would be good as posters and tea shirts. Possibly to go in a on line medical magazine article.

Translate

Abambo

Community Expert

Over all these would be considered fine art and not clip art. In my opinion I wold not do fine art for clip art places. People need clip art for their own put together projects such as advertising some event or product. Maybe these would be good as posters and tea shirts. Possibly to go in a on line medical magazine article.

By @PaintedKitty

Aren't you answering the wrong thread here? There are no clip arts, and nobody here claims this to be clip art. 🙂

Translate

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer

Jill_C

Community Expert

Count the fingers.... I'm sure it's something the Moderators have been trained to do...

Translate

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

A

Andrew28402168wx0rAuthor

Known Participant

If they do that for surrealistic art depicting clearly mutating person, then they are just being ridiculous.

Translate

Jill_C

Community Expert

Or maybe that's not the kind of "art" that they consider saleable on their platform?

Translate

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

Ricky336

Community Expert

Hello,

The problem is that the overall quality begins to fall when it is examined more closely:

Just a few things that look odd, even though it is an AI illustration.

You should look at these links about AI:

https://www.behance.net/videos/d5886b09-7fa7-4c0e-8a27-0d4b9451884a/Submitting-and-selling-generative-AI-images-on-Adobe-Stock-with-Mat-Hayward-and-Shea-Molloy
https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/help/generative-ai-faq.html
https://community.adobe.com/t5/stock-contributors-discussions/announcing-the-adobe-stock-policy-on-generative-ai-content/td-p/13395888
https://community.adobe.com/t5/stock-contributors-discussions/generative-ai-submission-guidelines/td-p/13549435

There are enough potential problems in quality for it to be rejected I think.

Translate

A

Andrew28402168wx0rAuthor

Known Participant

What exactly is wrong with deformed body parts of a mutated person? It's by design, not an error.

Translate

George_F

Community Expert

Anatomy is specifically mentioned in the Generative AI submission guidelines. The fingers aren't the only thing that's off, the stethoscope doesn't have any earpieces and tubes that lead to no where.

It's important to realize we don't know the exact reasons and can only speculate, but there is enough here along with the combination of the noise and artefacts in shadow areas that the rejection seems justified to me.

Translate

Fabiobtex

Participating Frequently

Art is hard to judge, the deformed hands could be explained by the transformation but not the glasses, not the badge and that kind of blots:

The second one has color problem probably caused by upscaling:

Translate

A

Andrew28402168wx0rAuthor

Known Participant

What is the color problem, exactly? Your screenshot is just black page.

Translate

Fabiobtex

Participating Frequently

If you can't see it even when you maximize it, it could be your monitor configuration, try some brightness/contrast adjusts.

All these red spots where it should be uniform are caused by some transformation, probably upscaling, they are discreet but visible.

Translate

Henrik Heigl

Community Expert

Hi,

is this AI Art and is it all the Release Forms handeled? I assume that it is because of the very blurry Images, the right ear is cut off, dark Bottom half, etc. Hope that helps.

Translate

regards,Henrik

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.