Skip to main content
Known Participant
October 26, 2019
Answered

Prevent Maxon Cinema 4D Force Install

  • October 26, 2019
  • 12 replies
  • 95442 views

Why Adobe is force installing it with no option to prevent the installation at first place?

 

Each platform has standards, Microsoft has some guidelines!

Adobe should provide an option during setup, instead they just fill up our PCs with bloatware!

Don't believe me? Check after Adobe products' install how many services and processes are always running!

 

Solution is simple: Place a CheckBox on initial setup window: "Install C4D"!

Uninstall PS/AE/PR/ME and you'll see many of app files/folders/registry entries are not removed afterwards!

I'm truely appalled...

Correct answer JohnColombo17100380

Hi all,

As noted here, installing C4D is now optional when installing After Effects 2023 and later. More details on how to choose whether or not to install C4D are available here: https://helpx.adobe.com/after-effects/using/whats-new/2023.html#C4D-optional-installer 

 

- John, After Effects Engineering Team 

12 replies

JohnColombo17100380
Community Manager
JohnColombo17100380Community ManagerCorrect answer
Community Manager
October 19, 2022

Hi all,

As noted here, installing C4D is now optional when installing After Effects 2023 and later. More details on how to choose whether or not to install C4D are available here: https://helpx.adobe.com/after-effects/using/whats-new/2023.html#C4D-optional-installer 

 

- John, After Effects Engineering Team 

Known Participant
June 22, 2020

I only just realised this had been happening and I'm EXTREMELY pissed off.  I had two copies of Cinema 4D clogging up my backup machine and had no idea they were there. It takes me all day to update just a subset of CC apps with my pathetic shared internet connection, and having disk space and internet bandwidth wasted on an installation I did NOT ASK FOR is an invasion of privacy and an act of utter disrespect. I already have 3DS MAX and Blender and have no need for C4D. I have to fork out a good sum of money for Adobe's rental software every year, so the least they can do is show a bit of courtesy and consideration and not force-bundle bloatware. 

Participating Frequently
June 19, 2020

A crummy practice Adobe is engaged in with this.  I shouldn't have to go research online just to figure out what is happening when Adobe suddenly installs a bunch of unsolicited and unheard of software on my computer.  And I don't need a response to this from that rep.

Participant
June 19, 2020

My biggest question is why is Maxon the only vendor that gets this sort of treatment? I don't see Maya LT or Houdini Core or even Blender being so "seamlessly" integrated with After Effects? I would love to have Eevee integrated into AE, but I assume that'll never happen.

Community Expert
June 19, 2020

Maxon supplies the 3D rendering engine. Would you like to see this go too? I use the C4D lite integration all the time. It is a very useful tool, more so than the Ray-Traced Rendering engine ever was. I've never seen so much complaining about free software that can help you deliver a better product. 

rtijn
Known Participant
June 19, 2020

However great it is, it should be a separate installer. Since it is a separate program. That people have to Google why C4D is suddenly on their system is plain wrong.

ben_worldcoppersmith
Participant
June 18, 2020

I wholeheartedly agree, this is rediculous...get C4D out of this package unless you are going to include it in my subscription. 

June 18, 2020
June 16, 2020

Hey, so this just installed itself today out of nowhere along with some other dodgy looking lårt I've never heard off. I have the Adobe CC student edition for classes, but never ever installed this or even heard of it. I exclusively do video editing and graphics design, never any 3D design, ever. Why did it randomly install itself today? How do I uninstall it? Is it safe to be here? I have a lot of questions about this dodgy fårking practice. Is it even legal? I know that TOS/EULA is not a legal contract in the eyes of the law.

Nevermind, this wont go anywhere. Seeing as I don't plan on ever coming back to this forum anyway I'll do you a favour and tell you that you, Warren, are out of touch with reality. Your arrogance (stupidity? Hanlon's Razor here) is laughable and disgusting.

Participating Frequently
June 18, 2020

Yeah, Warren, you're insane, please just get out of this discussion.

Yeap, TOS and EULA are not enforceable and are totally pointless, but unless someone can cough up the money and time to sue them we're out of luck.

To add to this, I am not opposed to C4D integration, but I am opposed to the standalone software being installed (which apparently is not required for the C4D integration to even work in the first place, so why is it even there?

Even though I know that C4D is, having it randomly appear in my computer is still worrying because I don't even know who installed it - I had to google this to find out adobe was installing it on my computer. This is an insane practice that can't be justified at all, if they decided to install other things, how will we be informed? What are our options?

I went to vote for the linked topic up top, but I'd be surprised if that goes anywhere anyway. This isn't about just C4D but adobe's practice as a whole. I don't trust them anymore. I used to just have problems with specific updates but this is a much bigger problem that I really struggle to ignore. My career is built on AE animation and premiere, but this is getting me to consider completely dropping the software and trying to figure something else out of nowhere now, even though there aren't any proper alternatives either.

Participant
June 18, 2020

Not requried?  How would you open C4D project files without at least Cinema 4D Lite?

 

 

Community Expert
June 9, 2020

Circling back to this post.  Who went to the User-Voice Page for AE about this?

rtijn
Known Participant
June 16, 2020

Thanks for pointing it out. Just a link for voting convenience: Opt-out of the installation of Cinema 4D R21 when installing After Effects

 

My 2 cents:

C4D is third party software that I didn't ask for, is forced onto my pc and requires a separate license to fully function. That smells of some shady business deal that we've seen a lot of in the 90's. I am surprised that anyone can consider this anything other than bloatware because this is probably the very definition of it.


I'm a 2d animator, I don't need 3d software. And if I would consider going that route, I would probably go for Blender since that has improved significantly in the past few updates and is free. If Adobe would integrate Blender, it would be a different story, but I still think it would require a seperate installer.


I really do appreciate your effort with your community support, but since you're defending Adobe's choices here, you can also expect some arguments against it. I'd like to address some of your reasoning, because I think there are some misconceptions. Although you're right that plugins are third party software, you would probably agree that C4D is a different scale, since it is it's own seperate program and plugins included in AE are permanently fully licensed.

 

Another thing you seem to like to mention is that 'industry professionals asked for it'. This really bothers me because you are assuming 2 things: the first being that ALL professionals want this, the second being that they wanted it in this way. Yes it's a nice integration, but everyone would probably agree that C4D needs it's own seperate installer from the CC application. If Media Encoder has it, then C4D should definitely have it. On top of these assumptions, saying that 'professionals want it' also implies that I may not be a professional, since I don't want it. That's not very kind.

ben_worldcoppersmith
Participant
June 18, 2020

Only industry casuals have time for the BS that are the adobe forums..We come here for answers and we get evangelists

Participant
May 22, 2020

Just discovered Cinema 4D on my new laptop. I know exactly what programs I have installed, because I just got this computer. Finding Cinema 4D gave me an intital scare. I really really hate software installing without my knowledge and I am not amused. I quick Google search brought me to this discussion. Glad to know it's not (really) malware, but I will take this up with Adobe.

1. If this is part of other Adobe software, please rename it. Integrete it in your products or rebrand it as an Adobe product.

2. If this is bundled third party software, please stop it. Just STOP. Adobe software is not some free tool where we can expect this sort of behavior, you should respect your paying customers more. This feels like some Internet Explorer toolbar from decades ago.

Community Expert
May 22, 2020

For professionals who use After Effects, this is much wanted integration.

 

 

May 27, 2020

I 100% WANT this integration Warren, but I sure would have liked to know that I was getting it. Then maybe I might've actually booted it up and played around with it instead of stumbling over it perfectly installed as a separate app on my new machine. You'd do better to acknowledge the hipocrisy in your responses.

Participant
March 29, 2020

I agree with you. Its a lack of respect to not inform or give a option to not install Cinema 4D. In some coutries this is a crime...

Community Expert
March 29, 2020

In most cases, making something up in a support forum does nothing to help resolve an issue.

 

 Again, Adode user-voice is the the place to raise a concern about any component of Adobe software as well as anything integrated into Adobe software.

 

 

 

May 27, 2020

They are called Personal Computers for a reason, Warren. Ergo if you put something in someone's pocket without asking them, they'll naturally have words to mince, be it a golden nugget or the exact opposite.

Community Expert
February 24, 2020

As Cinema 4D is integrated into After Effects, there is no way to prevent its installation; however, Cinema 4D Lite can be uninstalled.

 

For more on Cinema 4D (as well as instructions on how to uninstall Cinema 4D Lite), read this page:

CINEMA 4D and Cineware

https://helpx.adobe.com/after-effects/using/c4d.html

 

Using the CINEMA 4D 3D Renderer in the Composition Settings enables the following features in After Effects: 

  • extruded and beveled text and shapes
  • reflections
  • curved footage layers
  • material overrides on text/shape bevels and sides
  • environment layers (in reflections only)
  • pre-comp depth pass with channel effects

 

The inclusion of Cinema 4D Lite allows you to round-trip your edits using a Live 3D Pipeline.

 

The Cineware effect enables rendering of layers based on CINEMA 4D files directly in After Effects.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

jeva72
Known Participant
March 1, 2020

C4D does not appear in the CC Desktop app, can't install or uninstall it wher a user is supposed to manage his/her adobe apps. . Let me decide what I want to install, what I need for my work. I am keeping my workstation as clean as possible by only installing apps that I use so my pc runs as smooth as possible.

Adobe, please respect your costumers. 

jeva
Community Expert
March 1, 2020

That wold would be a great place for at least the Cinema 4D Lite.  (Again, Adobe User-Voice pages for such feedback).

 

Of course, the CINEMA 4D Renderer and the Cineware plug-in should remain exactly where they are.