Skip to main content
Ibrahim29985365wk0y
Participating Frequently
May 21, 2023
Answered

applying effect issue

  • May 21, 2023
  • 4 replies
  • 1254 views

I give an elemet (object,text,..)an RGB color and when I want to apply an effect like shadow or opacity to another element(seperate) it changes the other RGB colors to CMYK .

 

help please

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Brad @ Roaring Mouse

You need to first ask yourself, what is the ultimate goal with this document? If you are going to print it, you need to know it's not the best to be building your document in RGB colours that are wildly out of gamut (i.e. out of the printer's ability to reproduce.). If you DO use RGB colours, it's good to know what your colours will look like based on your potential output device, say a CMYK printer. This is actually a good thing so you can predict what will happen in print.

As mentioned, the Transparency Blend Space will determine how your effects are rendered. If it's set to CMYK, all your objects on the page will be converted to CMYK based on your CMYK output profile in your Color settings.

Even if you leave Transparency Blend space set as RGB, if you have Proof Colors turned on (under View), your colours will change according to what your Proof Setup is set, typically a CMYK output profile. Again, this is a good thing and necessary proofing step.

If you are intending to export your document in only RGB colours for, say, screen use, you could chnage your Proof Setup to, say, sRGB, so even if Proof Colours is turned on, it should show you your intended appearance in RGB.

4 replies

Brad @ Roaring Mouse
Community Expert
Brad @ Roaring MouseCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
May 23, 2023

You need to first ask yourself, what is the ultimate goal with this document? If you are going to print it, you need to know it's not the best to be building your document in RGB colours that are wildly out of gamut (i.e. out of the printer's ability to reproduce.). If you DO use RGB colours, it's good to know what your colours will look like based on your potential output device, say a CMYK printer. This is actually a good thing so you can predict what will happen in print.

As mentioned, the Transparency Blend Space will determine how your effects are rendered. If it's set to CMYK, all your objects on the page will be converted to CMYK based on your CMYK output profile in your Color settings.

Even if you leave Transparency Blend space set as RGB, if you have Proof Colors turned on (under View), your colours will change according to what your Proof Setup is set, typically a CMYK output profile. Again, this is a good thing and necessary proofing step.

If you are intending to export your document in only RGB colours for, say, screen use, you could chnage your Proof Setup to, say, sRGB, so even if Proof Colours is turned on, it should show you your intended appearance in RGB.

Ibrahim29985365wk0y
Participating Frequently
May 30, 2023

thanks sir🫡, appearently i wasn't aware of that 👍

Brad @ Roaring Mouse
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 30, 2023

No worries. Color Management of different Color spaces is a big one to wrap one's head around! Even professionals can get caught up by it. Good luck!

rob day
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 21, 2023

Hi @Ibrahim29985365wk0y , It‘s possible you were mislead by Eugene’s link if you did not read the entire thread—the marked correct answer was not directly about the Transparency Blend Space.

 

CheckEdit>Transparency Blend Space. If your’s is set to CMYK, any transparent object on the spread will force a CMYK preview of RGB colors:

 

 

This document’s Transparency Blend Space is set to Document CMYK, so when I add a Drop Shadow to any page item on the spread, the spread’s RGB colors are previewed in the document’s assigned CMYK space:

 

 

If I set the blend space to RGB, the spread’s preview is in the document’s assigned RGB space (See Edit>Assign Profiles)

 

 

 

If the above does not help post some screen captures.

Community Expert
May 22, 2023

I was hoping the entire thread would be read.

davecourtemanche
Inspiring
May 22, 2023

I was hoping my entire email would be read. 😄

Willi Adelberger
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 21, 2023

To transfer an effect you should create an object style (with the important parameters) and apply to the other object. Have you tried this way?

Ibrahim29985365wk0y
Participating Frequently
May 30, 2023

sorry but it is not clear .I am curious  if you understand my problem sir .

Community Expert
May 21, 2023
Ibrahim29985365wk0y
Participating Frequently
May 21, 2023

that didn't help, i don't know if you understand me well.😕😕

Community Expert
May 21, 2023

Hard to know what's going on with very little information and no screenshots/test files.