Skip to main content
Participant
Dec 15, 2023 8:43 PM UTC
Answered

P: Detail Panel adjustments preview differently at 200% between Momentary and Panel Switch

Hello Adobe…

One of my go to workflows in LRC is broken.  It was broken in 12.4 and still appears to be broken in 13.1 as I updated today.

 

To get some dramatic skies on landscapes, I usually go the Dehaze adjustment and crank it up a bit.  This typically adds a bit of grain noise in to nice smooth blue skys. One way to combat that was to use the masking tool, and use a linier, sky, or paintbrush to mask over the sky and cloud areas, then in that mask turn up the “Noise” setting which appeared to be a noise reduction setting for the mask controls.  This used to work great and punched up some drama in the sky with Dehaze, then Mask + noise reduction turned the sky back into a smooth blue sky without grain noise.

Now something as changed and is behaving illogically in LRC

 

 

 

Here is my default develop windows with base processing cranking up the Dehaze setting.  Please note the “Details” setting on the base process, all the slider are set to 0.

 

Here is the masked area I want to apply mask noise reduction on

 

 

 

This is the masked results, it’s a very minor visible improvement, not as good as it used to be, and my masking layer noise reduction is set way too high not to see a smoother image.  See the results circled here in green.  The left circle is no layer mask NR, the right circle is inside the layer mask with NR

 



If I use the Eye icon (red circle) and toggle off the Details section, the marked areas with NR get many times better results from NR, here almost too much.  In the Right circle, nice and smooth.  In the left top circle, also part of the mask with NR, nice and smooth, the bottom center circle not part of the Mask you can see the original noisy base processing from the Dehaze.

Please note the “Details” setting on the base process, all the sliders are set to 0.

 

 

 

 

If I Option+Left Click on the on/off toggle (red circle) for the Details in the base processing, I expected to get the same smooth results as above, but it does nothing, the masking with NR are still not as good as when the Details section is momentary toggled off using the Eye button.

 

 

 

 

What the heck is going on?  Can the these noisy details still be seen in the uploaded images to this fourm?


I have tried this with both graphics card acceleration on/off and got the same results.

 

 

Here is my computer configuration:

Model Name:                         MacBook Pro

Model Identifier:                     MacBookPro16,2

Processor Name:                   Quad-Core Intel Core i7

Processor Speed:                  2.3 GHz

Number of Processors:          1

Total Number of Cores:          4

L2 Cache (per Core):              512 KB

L3 Cache:                             8 MB

Hyper-Threading Technology: Enabled

Memory:                               32 GB

System Firmware Version:      2020.41.1.0.0 (iBridge: 21.16.1069.0.0,0)

OS Loader Version:       577.140.2~15

 

 

This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.
Rikk Flohr-Retired
Rikk Flohr-RetiredCorrect answer
Apr 3, 2024 5:26 PM UTC

Note: 

This has been moved from Bugs back to Discussions due to the expected behavior.  Please see engineering's comments:

"The eye icon and panel switch work in different ways.
The Eye icon compares the current setting (which has been modified from the state it was by default), vs the imported settings (in raw defaults).

 

In the case of this example, the default slider values were :
NR - Luminance 0, but Colour noise was 25.
Sharpening - 40

 

Now, if I change the default value of color noise from 25 to 0, and use the eye icon, we will see the noise appear on the image. However, if the switch is used, there won't be any change in the image (except for sharpening. Changing Sharpening is set to 0 will ensure there's no difference at all).

 

Hence, this is not a bug and is the intended behavior, and this is the reason we have both the eye icon and the switch. "



Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org

23 replies

Legend
Nov 15, 2026 5:00 AM UTC

​@gcnp2008 

Please provide more information.

 

What is the problem photo; is it a RAW and from which camera? 

If the photo is RAW, have you configured the Preset settings in Preferences for Raw Defaults?

Can you provide a full screen shot showing all the Detail panel settings?

 

Translate
Per Berntsen
Community Expert
Community Expert
Nov 14, 2026 8:05 PM UTC

I’m using version 15.6 on Windows 11, and see the same thing.
I believe that what happens when you click the eye icon is that the LrC default sharpening (40-1-25-0) is applied, which really makes no sense. It should disable sharpening altogether.

​@Sameer K 
Please consider moving this thread to Bugs.

Translate
Inspiring
Nov 14, 2026 8:22 PM UTC

I just tried what you explained. When I toggle the eyeball off, it actually applies the default sharpening values above. Interesting. If I set the values to the defaults, nothing changes when I toggle the eyeball off.

Translate
Inspiring
Nov 14, 2026 7:37 PM UTC

I noticed something today for the first time. I was checking out one of the features of the latest LrC update that shows the focus points in a raw image. I noticed that the area around the focus point was soft and not really what I expected. I then noticed the eyeball for the Detail panel was lit indicating that it had settings that were being used. I opened the panel and there were no indications that it was being used; no values other than “0” for any of the settings. When I toggle the panel off, the images lose their softness and appear as I would expect them to. I have looked at the same images in PS (Camera Raw) and Lr, all have the same appearance. I can’t find anything that would let me view the images without the Detail panel and cannot turn it off all together.

 

Any ideas for this situation? 

Translate
Rikk Flohr-Retired
Adobe Employee
Rikk Flohr-RetiredCorrect answer
Apr 3, 2024 5:26 PM UTC

Note: 

This has been moved from Bugs back to Discussions due to the expected behavior.  Please see engineering's comments:

"The eye icon and panel switch work in different ways.
The Eye icon compares the current setting (which has been modified from the state it was by default), vs the imported settings (in raw defaults).

 

In the case of this example, the default slider values were :
NR - Luminance 0, but Colour noise was 25.
Sharpening - 40

 

Now, if I change the default value of color noise from 25 to 0, and use the eye icon, we will see the noise appear on the image. However, if the switch is used, there won't be any change in the image (except for sharpening. Changing Sharpening is set to 0 will ensure there's no difference at all).

 

Hence, this is not a bug and is the intended behavior, and this is the reason we have both the eye icon and the switch. "



Translate
Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org
Participant
Dec 19, 2023 9:52 PM UTC

@Rikk Flohr: Photography 
@Bob Somrak 

Thank you for looking at this!
Comming from an audio engineering background with DSP processing, Preview / On\Off / Bypass buttons are important tools and my perception on how they should work might be diffrent that the Lightroom software engineers are thinking.

I'll be stuck in a corner... "gyrating"...  In full confusion that Adobe has invented a better On\Off switch and I must relearn 35 years of signal processing engineering and user interface design.  🙂

Thank you again and hopfully this makes it into a tune up fix for some future version.  Knowing what I am seeing now, I can work around this a bit.

Translate
Bob Somrak
Legend
Dec 18, 2023 10:04 PM UTC

Thanks @Rikk Flohr: Photography 

 

 

Translate
M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
Rikk Flohr-Retired
Adobe Employee
Dec 18, 2023 10:03 PM UTC

A Ticket has been opened for investigation. 

Translate
Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org
Bob Somrak
Legend
Dec 18, 2023 8:39 PM UTC

@Rikk Flohr: Photography 

 

As per the OPs last post, there does appear to be a bug/issue when using the Global Detail panel Eyeball vs the ON/OFF switch.  The attached video shows a Local Brush with the Noise set at 100.  The Global Detail Panel is at default except the Color Noise is at 0.  The only other edit is the Global Dehaze is at 100.  These are the OPs settings from the original post.  You will notice in the attached video I clicked the EyeBall 3 times and the Local Brush area AND Global area changed .  I then clicked the ON/OFF 3 times and there was no change or insignificant.  Shouldn't the EyeBall and ON/OFF switch show the same thing.  It seems the ON/OFF is not working in the Global Detail Panel.  The view is at 200% zoom.

Translate
M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
Rikk Flohr-Retired
Adobe Employee
Dec 18, 2023 8:53 PM UTC

The Eyeball and the Panel Switch produce identical behavior when I attempt the same test here. They both behave as your 'eye ball' behavior from the video.

I do not see the same behavior in my test. image as shown in your video when using a panel switch [Alt+Click].  

Translate
Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org
Bob Somrak
Legend
Dec 18, 2023 9:12 PM UTC

@Rikk Flohr: Photography 

 

The affect is ONLY noticable in the Local Mask brush area I show in my video.  Notice the area around the brush indicator.

Translate
M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
Bob Somrak
Legend
Dec 17, 2023 6:22 PM UTC

@TechnicalCreative 

 

This is not a bug.  You have changed the DEFAULT setting for Color Noise in the Global Detail Panel.  This is why Adobe has rules for what goes into the Bug Forum.  

Translate
M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
Participant
Dec 18, 2023 5:18 PM UTC

@Bob Somrak -

Thanks for the video capture that is a neat idea to show my perceived issue

 

I still see it as a BUG, however considering perspective for the default settings of base Details_NoiseReduction_Color defaults... this is one BUG I might be able to work around...

 

However, why does using the Eye / Bypass Off on the base "Detail" give one visible result that is different from using the On/Off option on the base "Detail"?

 

My idea was to set both luma / chroma noise reduction to 0.. then show the results were different in each mode, Detail Eye Bypassed, Detail Off. I can only now assume that regardless if the luma and chroma are both set to 0... the Detail section is still applying some level of NR unless the Detail Off switch is selected.

 

Why the other masking tool's Noise Reduction better when the Detail section is in Eye Bypass/Off mode, regardless of the settings in Detail.

 

The LR application is "assuming" if you use the Eye Bypass for the Details section, the user would prefer to see bypass preview with the base Detail section ON with the default NR settings?

 

That assumption seams incorrect to me
Lightroom: “Here is a bypass Off preview with default settings turned back On and applied."

Translate
Bob Somrak
Legend
Dec 17, 2023 5:22 PM UTC

@Rikk Flohr: Photography 

 

Update:  I could finally edit my post

Translate
M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB