P: Generative Remove Feedback (Lr Classic & Lr Eco)

I join the other voices—this tool does whatever it wants. It struggles to recreate anything useful when it removes people.

this tool is always a huge hit or miss, it either amazes me in the fact it got something right for once or amazes me because how is the @#$@#$ it  it add a faucet and handles that don’t do anything to an image that already had some and I didn’t want it to edit them anyways… I can dump this in to any other AI tool and it fix what I need no issues but some how the leader in graphic arts tools can’t manage to get this right. now I will say this… if I export it from light room to photoshop it does a better job overall but still not great.

I never use the LR generative remove tool, even the heal tool isn’t working properly. I have to open everything in PS and edit there. I have a white background with one minor smudge, I click remove and it is still there. The remove tool doesn’t remove anything, it only re-shapes it. The heal tool does not recognize that all the space around it is also white, it chooses instead to sample from the subject, so I get a random eye or nose on the white backdrop. 

So, I’ve come to notice. 

Generative Remove needs to work on improving its ‘correction ability’ AI software on identifying fabrics. The texture isn’t consistent and doesn’t match with the original fabric. 

Generative Remove still doesn’t work reliably.

After years of feedback from users here and across the forums, I expected this to be resolved by now - especially since it worked back in 2024.

Please, take a look at that. I’d really appreciate it if this could finally be addressed, as it has a major impact on everyday workflow.

I am in desperate need of help! I edited 20-30 images in a larger set and used generative ai to remove trash and a few people in the background. The edits won’t “Stay” no matter what I do! I have hit update on each individual one etc… how can I fix this?!

Hi guys, I’m new here and don’t know if someone posted it already, bu please include a button to tell the AI engine what you are trying to remove. Like for example the most common element I try to erase is women hair like, static, wind, puffed up by moisture. Also the AI engine need to know the hair growth direction to avoid floating hair strands etc. Also, feet tracks in the sand too. Thnx

I am getting quite frustrated with both masking and remove.   It is now impossible to work on a photo that has lots of masking changes. For a while remove was working pretty good.   And masking too.