Button Editor resets whenever I exit out of Premiere/Button Editor won't save custom settings

I have never had this issue before but I just switched computers and now everytime I go to set up the Button Editor how I'd like it, if I exit it completely resets it. I tried saving it as a workspace but that doesn't work. I'm not sure if it's a bug or just a setting I don't have enabled. 

Any help is appriciated thanks!