Firefly is terrible

[OhJakie]

Not really a bug, but I dont know what else to put it under. Firefly ignores most of my prompt and gives me simple low quality images that dont even make sense. I describe what I want with great detail and its frustrating that it ignores what I want and gives me random stuff. I heard great things about Firefly but so far it has beyond disappointing.

[dpick2]

I used a reference photo of myself, wife, brother, and his wife (all white).   The prompt was, "use this image to create an illustration with dramatic realistic colors using the people in the image. Have the people standing in front of a neon sign in red and green spelling out "Merry Christmas". The people are waving, hello. There are colorful Christmas trees in and around the scene in slightly dimmed lighting. A dusting of snow covers the trees and the sign. Use the actual faces of the people in the reference photo."

This is the best of the eight results.  You're almost there, Adobe. (sure)

 This is from Co-Pilot using the exact same prompt/reference image.  This is pretty darn close to what I wanted to see.

[Skylyn]

Oh my! LOL 

C'mon Adobe get it together!!

[dwaynes77477988]

I creayed a 5 second video. The faces were distorted, the movement of a font character was awful compared to other AI's. It dressed a man in a woman's outfit. Neck's were elongated... Just bad. 

[Lilachan]

Oof. cmon Adobe, get to work!

[AB_OS_c]

If you heard great things it's because those people are probably paid members of the marketing team 😄

[g2fx]

I WANT MY CREDITS BACK! OUT OF 9 ATTEMPTS...ONLY 1 IS BARELY USABLE

[Kartika Rawat]

I'm really sorry about the trouble. Could you share more info on what's happening with quality? Currently, we aren't able to give a credit refund.  

Let us know. 

Thanks, 
^KR

[g2fx]

You only get a set amount to use to make a render. I was looking for something simple. A woman walking across the screen. I tried 9 times. 4500 credits.

None of them any useful. 1 result was middling at best. There’s something janky about each render. Either weird distortions or hands flapping about.

There needs to be a way to only use credits if you download the clip. Otherwise…I’m spending money on faulty results. IF I’m going to have to use my money/credits on something that just doesn’t work, why bother?

[Kartika Rawat]

Thanks for writing back. Please give feedback by clicking on the thumb icon. Also, you can add an upvote on this thread for visibility: https://adobe.ly/46Q8d2k

^KR

[Amberg Art]

When you ask for ....
A homemade, open treasure chest. View of the chest from above. Inside are a Polaroid photo of two parents holding their child, a small teddy bear, a pacifier, a few glass marbles, a dried leaf, and an old photo album. View from above. A child is sitting on the floor next to the box. And puts another bird feather in the box. Style: mixed media, collage, photo.
You'll get that... and other anomalies. 

[ruggero5E4A]

Firefly is still completely unusable for any serious work. Honestly, Adobe should just take it down and relaunch it only when it’s at least on par with tools like Sora v1 or even the early versions of ChatGPT. Right now, the output is consistently poor and feels ridiculous — and it’s embarrassing for Adobe as a whole to have something this weak under its name.

[dpick2]

Did you mention anything in your prompt about the the people having been dipped in acid for a day or two?

[Amberg Art]

Come on, Adobe. Please fix it!

[droopydog500]

The best way to communicate to Adobe specifics about poor quality generations is to thumbs down a generation and provide as specific of information as possible.

This feedback goes to the engineers working on the models. Those engineers do not see all of the feedback in these user forums.

Thanks,

    droopy

[Amberg Art]

I always do. And I really hope that there will be a progress in the near future.

[Haggi Hug]

I wish they would hire an intern to do this for them for two weeks. They don't seem to have any interest whatsoever in seriously testing the rubbish they program. If I just enter ‘make a fairytale picture with an illustrative effect’ every time, I shouldn't be surprised when the tool fails in the harsh reality of everyday life.

[Anita_DaVinci]

The video generated from an image, using Firefly video generator, is terrible. 
The image gets horribly distorted, some parts of the image get duplicated with no reason. 
How come you're charging 500 credits for such terrible quality?

[more than happy]

Yes. The images are highly inappropriate and the AI has a stupid understanding of the prompts.