Inspiring

Question

V2 verses V3 quality

Forum|Forum|1 year ago
April 25, 2024
22 replies
11217 views

I have extreme respect, admiration for the Firefly team and engineers, but something has gone off the rails concerning the V3 preview. This isn't a question, so I placed it in this section of bugs. If I didn't care about Firefly I wouldn't be here showing examples.

These are direct renders of "multiple generations" using V3 preview off the original V2 file. I will show the V2 first, then V3 will follow each image. I kept trying to get a good image from V3, yes it's a preview, but it needs to be addressed. These are the best of the best V3 images. And with that said I'll shut up lol and let you judge.

V2

V3

V2

V3

V2

V3

V2

V3

This topic has been closed for replies.

A

Amy27298162kmmg

Participating Frequently

Is it just me, or does Image 2 even seem worse than it used to be?

Mark DeMent

Participant

It's not just you. Version 2 results recently have been much worse. But still better than 3. I can't use anything I've generated from 3. Everything looks like a bad Disney animation cell. I hope they return 2 to it's original state, and keep it.

B

BlueJeanBaby

Participating Frequently

. . . Then this (see prior reply). Version 3. I wonder if anyone has a worse example than this? Adobe - are you going to continue to allow this 'quality' with Model 3? Please keep V2 up!

droopydog500

Community Manager

These strengthen my belief that from a realism perspective, 3>2 and from an artistic perspective 2>3...

droopy

Adobe Community Expert (not an Adobe employee)

B

BlueJeanBaby

Participating Frequently

Agreed...somewhat. What realism though do those represent? lol - But yes, in general, you're correct.

B

BlueJeanBaby

Participating Frequently

Another example (please see this, and the following reply). Version 2 - cute little dragon on a skateboard...

B

BlueJeanBaby

Participating Frequently

What 3 generated is laughable and amateurish at best!

B

BlueJeanBaby

Participating Frequently

Version 2 and 3 here, respectively. Same exact styles/prompts, etc.

Kartika Rawat

Community Manager

Moving from bugs to discussions.

@mj

Community Expert

Oh curious @droopydog500 ,

Could the Adobe folks on this forum say why?

Best

mj

iMSD

droopydog500

Community Manager

@Amy27298162kmmg, Adobe Express appears to still use model 1.

Adobe Community Expert (not an Adobe employee)

A

Amy27298162kmmg

Participating Frequently

Thank you droopydog500. Are you finding that on the online page? I just tried it last night and I didn't see where I had an option. What am I missing? The result I got for flowers was basicallly a blob.

droopydog500

Community Manager

@Amy27298162kmmg, There is not a clear published table, but what we constructed on the Adobe Firefly Discord is:

	Model
	1	2	3
Firefly Text to Image (web)		X	X
Firefly Generative Fill (web)			X
Adobe Express	X
Photoshop General Release	X
Photoshop Beta			X
Illustrator	X
InDesign			X
API (enterprise only)*	X	X

*information from API changelog

Adobe Community Expert (not an Adobe employee)

A

Amy27298162kmmg

Participating Frequently

Sorry, my images came in huge and without the captions. The first picture is the Image 3 model, and the other two are the Image 2 model.

A

Amy27298162kmmg

Participating Frequently

Yes, I had issues also. I tried the same prompt in both Image 2 and Image 3 models. The image 3 model gave me clay-like looking flowers. The image 2 model gave me beautiful, frilly flowers. An unbelieveable difference! I don't seem to have access to Image 1 model any more. Please Adobe, Keep the Image 2 model as well... please don't ever get rid of it like it seems has happened with Image 1 model.