As per your screenshot, your file is being opened in the 2024 version. Do you have multiple versions of After Effects installed? Are you able to open the project by going to File > Open or drag and drop in the 25.0.1 version? If you can, it could be a file association-related issue. Here's how you can change the file association to the latest version of After Effects: https://www.windowscentral.com/software-apps/windows-11/how-to-change-default-apps-for-files-on-windows-11