Skip to main content
Inspiring
May 15, 2017
Answered

Roman Hanging Punctuation greyed out

  • May 15, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 10027 views

I've got a paragraph in AE with some punctuation that i'd like to hang.

I found this option in the paragraph panel called "Roman Hanging Punctuation" and got all excited, but it's greyed out.

Am i missing something? Does this only work with certain typefaces? To test, I tried switching to several different typefaces to no avail.

I feel like there's probably an obvious step i'm missing here.

Any ideas?

Correct answer leather.bird

Are there actually any special characters?

Yes. I'm trying to hang quotation marks.

What font?

I've tried dozens.

What text?

Should that even matter?

Did you paste it from somewhere else?

Yes. I used a TextEdit document that i made "Plain Text" (no formatting).

You know what though? Thank you for asking this last one because i went back and tried pasting and not pasting to see what would happen and ended up discovering that this only works if I create a text box.

If I just click and type with the type tool the option is greyed out. But if I click and drag to create a text box, and then enter (or paste) my text, the hanging punctuation option is available. Like i suspected, an obvious solution that i completely missed.

Thank you for your help, Mylenium​. You got me part of the way there!

2 replies

Participant
July 11, 2023

It will only work if your text is in a Paragraph Text Box (Type tool > drag rectangular area). If you just select the Type tool, then click the image and type some text, the "Roman hanging punctuation" selection will be greyed out (as it's a Point Text Box). Alternatively, you can convert your Point Text box to a Paragraph Text box as follows: Click on text box > Type > Convert to Paragraph Text.

Participant
October 24, 2023

Amazing - this worked! Thank you!!!

Mylenium
Legend
May 15, 2017

Are there actually any special characters? What font? What text? Also, if you paste the text from elsewhere the source program may matter...

Mylenium

leather.birdAuthorCorrect answer
Inspiring
May 15, 2017

Are there actually any special characters?

Yes. I'm trying to hang quotation marks.

What font?

I've tried dozens.

What text?

Should that even matter?

Did you paste it from somewhere else?

Yes. I used a TextEdit document that i made "Plain Text" (no formatting).

You know what though? Thank you for asking this last one because i went back and tried pasting and not pasting to see what would happen and ended up discovering that this only works if I create a text box.

If I just click and type with the type tool the option is greyed out. But if I click and drag to create a text box, and then enter (or paste) my text, the hanging punctuation option is available. Like i suspected, an obvious solution that i completely missed.

Thank you for your help, Mylenium​. You got me part of the way there!

Kevin-Monahan
Community Manager
Community Manager
July 20, 2017

Hi leather.bird,

Are you still facing this problem? If not, let us know how you solved it. If so, please let us know so we can assist you further.

Thanks,

Kevin

Kevin Monahan - Sr. Community and Engagement Strategist – Adobe Pro Video and Audio