Skip to main content
Inspiring
June 20, 2019
Question

HARMAN pricing. Is it realistic?

  • June 20, 2019
  • 32 replies
  • 25567 views

HARMAN pricing has been announced and is not cheap. I said in a few posts it will likely be low and I was simply wrong. My company already said NO (I asked) and we are now leaving AIR for good.

I sure do understand the need for HARMAN to profit but it seems to me that pricing is too high. As a result maybe some people are going to pay while actively seeking alternative solution and quickly leaving the tech afterward.

What do you guys think of that pricing? Good for the future of AIR or not good?

This topic has been closed for replies.

32 replies

Known Participant
October 11, 2019

I totally agree

nmecodes
New Participant
October 17, 2019

Harman wanting to put a splash screen in, is akin to the old days of the flash link on the right click menu.  It's a pain in the ass, and it doesn't look professional.

Inspiring
July 15, 2019

You had to do it, didn't you

ASWCAuthor
Inspiring
July 15, 2019

He fought us so hard for saying exactly what he said 3 weeks earlier .... Amazing. You know I had to post this.

Inspiring
July 15, 2019

Lol, I know. But in science terms, this is a stage of acceptance you know. First there is denial, then it starts to break in, then you accept it.

Flipline
Inspiring
July 8, 2019

Harman released updated pricing details this morning by email along with some roadmap items, the full text was posted on the Starling forum here:

https://forum.starling-framework.org/d/21728-the-future-of-adobe-air/199

The main changes from the previous pricing plan are that the subscription fee is now only for using the tools and isn't required for the duration of an app being available in app stores, the revenue caps for each tier have been adjusted and are now based on overall income so you don't have to determine your "AIR-specific" income, the subscription fees are now billed annually instead of monthly, and the top-tier prices were lowered as well.

Personally I'm happy with all of these changes, and for anyone stressing about diving into this and updating their apps on a tight deadline before August 1st, Google just granted a 12-month extension for existing AIR app updates until they'll need to support 64-bit (though it seems new AIR apps will still need to be 64-bit).

ASWCAuthor
Inspiring
July 8, 2019

Yikes, the long term goals (the most important for me) are very few and not very exciting and on top of that they will depend on funding. What this tells me is that the new AIR team is small, probably 5 to 10 developers (but more likely close to 5), and goals must be kept realistic but at least for me this is just not ambitious enough. For me it's simple, no web target, no need for that tech.

Inspiring
July 9, 2019

ASWC  wrote

For me it's simple, no web target, no need for that tech.

Then you never needed that tech because a web target was never planed

I get it, you wish the "magic button" solution, I just click there and voila it publish in whatever it needs so it works inside the web browser, but that's a fantasy, that's very very unlikely to happen.

so if that you're only argument against AIR, it is pretty thin.

AIR was designed as an outside of the browser experience, as a runtime that can reuse the Flash technology (SWF, ActionScript, AVM2, etc.) but without the limitations of the browser (file access, socket, GUI, etc.).

And even if such thing were existing it would have a lot of limitations

simply because a web browser has a lot of limitations as a "runtime"

in fact I could argue that AIR with the way it can be extended with ANE
is the complete opposite of what a web browser can do (as it can not be extended at all)

so ultimately you will never be happy with AIR because you ask for something close to impossible

Participating Frequently
July 1, 2019

I will gladly pay these prices if it means that they are actively developing and making the platform better.  However... if support to work with Animate goes away ... so do I.

ASWCAuthor
Inspiring
July 1, 2019

I think we will all have a clearer picture of what we can expect from HARMAN in the next 6 months/12 months.

1. If HARMAN has not much to show for in term of innovation for the tech then people are just paying for maintenance and privilege to publish and this won't go very far unfortunately.

2. If HARMAN blows our mind with tons of update and innovation and exciting new stuff then AIR might be coming back with a vengeance.

2 would be pretty awesome, 1 would mean AIR will finish its career by blackmailing its most fervent defenders ....

Inspiring
June 27, 2019

Seems like good news

Come on it's also fun to **** *** each other sometimes, it is important not to take it personally. In front of a glass of wine communication would be much different, but on forums when emotions are involved it's easy to get carried away (personally, I do love AIR, therefore I tend to get emotional on the topic, especially now that I see hope).

Kudos to everybody.

Inspiring
June 27, 2019

I bet people would through wine glasses to each other and cheese cubes

On a related note, it is good tha the resource compression is fixed.

Inspiring
June 26, 2019

I kindly invite everybody to keep the discussion in topic:

Alternatives to AIR - suggestions, experiences and thoughts

ASWCAuthor
Inspiring
June 26, 2019

The topic of this particular thread is the pricing of AIR 33 by HARMAN (I should know I started it). An acceptable and related side topic is AIR 32 since it remains free but of course can't publish for Android after August 2019.

Inspiring
June 26, 2019

This is getting really annoying.

If I were admin of this forum I would have banned all disturbers.

Looking forward to a moderated harman forum, to abandon this in the hands of those bloating egos roaming around who kidnapped those discussions. F*** off and get a life, leave us happily discussing how we like AIR, and go to become a millionaire with your new techs somewhere else.

I hope my thought is clear enough.

ASWCAuthor
Inspiring
June 26, 2019

So the guys giving their opinions should be banned and the guy using the F word should be in charge, got it.

Inspiring
June 26, 2019
So the guys giving their opinions should be banned and the guy using the F word should be in charge

Nah, I am too latin and impulsive to be in charge of any public space. But thanks for the endorsement

Inspiring
June 26, 2019

Extreme thought leads to war.

Fortunately, someone took AIR to do a fresh restart. This is the best thing that could happen to a maintenance mode software (please, don't even try to convince me on the contrary), specially with the state in which it was left (the very worst).

It's more than natural that the new company wants to build a business around AIR and this more than natural (at lease in 2019) that this business is SaaS. A lot of people screamed asking for that, now you got it !

We, as humans also work as a service, at the end of the month you get your salary.

Yes, the price is high (for a "simple" or not so simple maintenance mode) and it's OK for a maintenance mode + performance improvements, when possible + new features/targets like Linux when the time allow it but that, we don't know iet.

And we can't compare any price from Harman to the free solution from Adobe (nothing beats free), however we can and we should demand quality as we will be paying (that's the beauty of SaaS, it serves both sides).

Yes, the could start with a lower price for a maintenance mode then raise the price when they add new features but do you would agree with that, I mean, when try raise de price ?

There is also another possibility and I risk to repeat my self, change tech.

Inspiring
June 25, 2019

Since several years I see in the forum people saying that Air is dead. I have even see some declaring that they leave Air several time since then. Leaving the first time should be enough if you ask me.

It sounds to me that, convinced that Air is dead, they want to be sure that they have done the right choice by coming here saying Air dead ad nauseum. Sure if you want to kill Air continue that way.

But be conscient that there are people that don't have the choice because they simply don't have the means to remake an app that they have build during several years.

So it seems a bit egoist to try to destroy something a lot of people are living on.

So if those guys who want to leave Air or pray that Air is dead could give a break to others who want to move along with Air...

A lot of people here just want to have the pertinent information on how to make Air live.

For me Harman is a very good news. Sure the roadmap is short but very clear: Android 64. And personalty I think it's fine. If they can be focused on it it's a good thing. They will have a lot of work in the future so give them some time to set up the new Air and fill up the roadmap.

Regarding the price I'm sure there will have some adjustment, but I'm happy to pay Harman if they can help make Air live. If I'm not happy with the new Air, I will stop using it and stop paying for it... and I won't come here crying that Air is dead

Anyway Air is alive!

dolldivine
Inspiring
June 25, 2019

Listen to me, I would give my first born child to be able to continue working in Flash (yes, I still call it Flash).  So $199/month is not that bad, in comparison.  Take my money lol!

Btw, people are mentioning AIR for Desktop.. I recently started porting some old Flash games to AIR for Desktop and surprisingly the user feedback has been overwhelmingly positive!  They say it's more stable than Flash and they love having access to the games without internet access.  I love that it installs the little icon.