Can't get color back to how I used to print

I am so frustrated right now. I used to be able to open my file, print 500 envelopes, and DONE!! Ever since I played with my color settings to make them match where I worked, I can't figure out how to get back to where I was with my printing. I haven't changed my links in my documents, the only thing I have changes is color settings through Bridge so that everything would sync. I can't remember what the setting was before. I have tried so many different things, but I'm not 100% sure of what I'm doing. I did try changing the color setting back to North America General Purpose 2, and the color is closer, but still muddy looking. For example, the color in Photoshop is 100% yellow, but when it prints, it looks like dull mustard.  When I look in the linked palette, it says the links are document cmyk.

I also have another job with the same problem. I have a nice bright, green that now prints dull moss green. All this because I thought I would get consistency between all the Adobe Apps. Maybe it is consistent, but it's consistently ugly colors. I just want it to print the colors that I made in my files. I've tried changing a gazillion settings in my print menus, etc. to no avail.

I'm running MacOS Big Sur, latest InDesign, printing to an HP Officejet Pro 8620 (I know it's RGB, but it used to print the colors just fine).

I do NOT want to change my linked image colors because they printed correctly before, I should be able to get them to print correctly again, with the right settings, of course.

Thanks in advance for any help.