P: Library zoomed view shows wrong color

[astrosven]

When zooming into an image in library mode, the color changes suddenly and differs from all the consistent colours shown in develop mode or library mode (fit image). I just updated to LR10.1 and appreciated other fixed bugs. I am using an external BenQ display calibrated to AdobeRGB profile using xrite. The images have Adobe profiles (AdobeVivid) applied.

[COBill]

katrin_serova

Oh yea, Apple makes perfect software. There is a memory leak in MacOS that is causing failures for a wide range of software including Apple's. 

[Rikk Flohr: Photography]

Thanks for the updates everyone!

[mark00673]

I've just noticed 100% view in Library mode shows a flat version of edit, I don't remember this happening before... When I toggle between 100% and 'fit' the contrast/saturation are considerably more blah.  I've done some diagnostics and I believe the histogram is not being applied at 100% view.

I'm using smart previews and all previews are built to 1:1.

I'm currently using LR Classic release 10.1.1, Camera raw 13.1, on an iMac running Big Sur 11.2. and GPU AMD Radeon Pro 580 - 8gb.

[Omar Alamoudi]

Same issue occurs with me!

[TheDigitalDog]

Known bug. Stay tuned. 

[Arcterex]

Adding my voice here.  This wasn't an issue using the same version of the software on the same os (macos 11.2.1 and Lightroom Classic 10.1.1) until I did a full wipe and re-install of my entire computer everything (but moved my library, previews, etc files over from a backup of course).  The loupe 100% version isn't a completely flat 'before', as it does show edits, but it's a flatter version of the edits.  Some screenshots here:

Files in case anyone cares:

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/83h8a6ypzm8ixze/AAC4cEXjQX3zCfefJYIZm-gRa?dl=0

[TheDigitalDog]

Again: known bug, fix coming.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Thank you for reporting this. Thought there's something wrong with my laptop or monitor. 

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Same issue on Imac Pro and on 2 MacBook Pros. Library and Filmstrip colors are rendered green (similar to assigning an Adobe RGB color space to a ProPhoto raw in Photoshop). This wasn't an issue a year ago, but came with one of the more recent LR updates.

Absolutely annoying, hinders workflow. Being a pro this is making life a lot harder.

[Omar Alamoudi]

@andrew_rodney,

Do you know where we should follow up on the status of this known bug?

That will help people not post additional comments and simply go to the follow up link.

Thanks 

[TheDigitalDog]

Follow up here on this thread.

[jeremysfoster]

@andrew_rodney Do you have more information about when it's coming, what's causing it, etc.? This is the most ridiculous bug for a piece of photo editing software.

[TheDigitalDog]

Do you have more information about when it's coming

I can't say publicly. 

[jeremysfoster]

@andrew_rodney Do you know what's causing it and if there's a setting we can change to fix this? Because Lightroom is literally unusable for professionals like this.

[jeremysfoster]

*Brigitte I feel your pain. This is terrible, Lightroom is basically unusable, and we get nothing but vague answers about "fix coming soon."

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Oh, the answers have been way worse than vague, @Jeremy Foster. Scroll up a little and you'll find the "powers" here insisting that nobody here *actually* sees this problem--or that if a tiny few of us do, it's so "slight" that we shouldn't really notice it.

And that was said *after* people posted videos and screenshots demonstrating it.

Despite reports of this problem reaching back to mid-December, the only official word from someone who actually works at Adobe is that it's noted and that, by the way, we really shouldn't be making decisions or evaluating color in the library module. Apparently we need to be culling, somehow, with the Develop module. Which makes one wonder what Adobe imagines the Library module is actually for?

In other words: nobody will establish a chain of responsibility, nobody's here to account, and nobody will offer a fix date. Complete breakdown of ownership.

You know, failure to provide any actual customer service is one thing; but the aggressive negging of customer concerns, the kinda-sorta-gaslighting, and the serial avoidance of responsibility takes the now three-month "experience" of this issue to a nadir I would never have imagined an actual customer service business might fall.

But perhaps I can thank the "official" response in this thread for finally pushing me to take a serious look at Capture One. 

[AlanA]

[EDIT]

Good news,

The latest Big Sur Update (11.2.2) has solved the problem.

The colours are now matching at any zoom %.

What about you ?

Well it's better than it was but there is still a problem

[andix.bx]

@alan_aubry no, not for me. Just tried.

Please check again, for some pictures it's not so bad. Especially vibrant colors seem to be affected heavily, b/w not at all;

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

@alan_aubry Unfortunately no difference. I didn't expect Big Sur to solve Adobe problems 😉

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

@alan_aubry still broken for me, too, with 11.2.2.

[Ash Mills Photography]

Andrew cannot reproduce the bug I believe.

[AlanA]

Back to my Mac and took more time to look at the pictures.

You're right, there's still a problem, it's not as extrem as it was, but there’s still a color change, in both color and b&w.

I'll edit my post

[AlanA]

Here is a GIF of the same picture in the two modes (I know gif Colors aren't great but it gives an idea of the issue)

[Arcterex]

Doesn't seem to be fixed for me, maybe not as extreme, but I'd have to compare to my previous images exactly. Color shift is still there with 11.2.2 though.

[Katrinochka]

@alan_aubry why do you try to bring in the Big Sur updates to the issue? This is 100% Adobe bug, and until they fix it no OS update is gonna help