P: Problem when using copy and paste or sync in develop module with WB changed

[idahochukar]

My operating system is MacOS Catalina 10.15.7. With the new LRClassic update 10.0. When I change the WB from As Shot to Daylight in the Develop module with the Profile at Camera Standard (Nikon D500 and D850 user) whether I have made other changes to other sections of the basic panel or not and then copy and past to another photo or sync to other photos (same sequence and same camera WB settings) the WB label changes to Daylight in the photos copied to or synched but the sliders (and the setting) do not change. I then have to go to each individual photo copied to or synched to and change wb back to as shot and then to Daylight and then it works although then the preveviews in the thumbnails in the film strip below are erractically slow to resolve. This does not happen if I have just changed the Temp or Tint slider or both but only if I have clicked on the Daylight option. I have tried disabling all plug ins and no change, I have turned of the computer completely and turned it back on etc.. .  

[Todd Shaner]

I can confirm the same behavior on my Windows 10 system using LrC 10.0.

[Todd Shaner]

I tested LrC 9.4 (previous version) and it does NOT exhibit this issue so the bug was introduced in LrC 10.0. Just a confirmation for Adobe Engineering.

[BPC Photo]

I can confirm that this is happening on Catalina 10.15.7 on a MacBook Pro and Lightroom Classic 10.0 using Sony .awr files that have been converted to .dng files upon import. 

[Conrad_C]

Observed this yesterday. Good to see it already reported.

[John R Ellis]

A workaround: In Library loupe or grid view, select the photos, and in the Quick Develop panel, change White Balance to Daylight.

I haven't extensively tested it, but it worked on the few test cases I tried.

[Todd Shaner]

John, on my Windows 10 system that only works in the Library Grid view, which I believe is normal behavior.

[Rick Spaulding -]

I see this behavior as well and will write a bug for it. It seems to happen whenever a WB setting is changed from the drop down menu in the white balance edit panel. It behaves this way for all drop downs except Custom. Perhaps because you have to actually move a slider to make a custom setting.

[Rick Spaulding -]

Another work around is to turn on Auto Sync in the Develop module. Good catch on this by the way. I normally work in Auto Sync mode and would never have noticed this. 

[idahochukar]

Thank you ... I find that most of the time my D850 does great with auto wb but my D500 frequently is a bit off from where it should be in full daylight using auto wb so that is the most frequent drop down menu I use so had not noticed the others yet.

[Todd Shaner]

Thanks Rikk. I also tested ACR 13.0 and it does not exhibit the issue.

[John R Ellis]

"[It] only works in the Library Grid view"

Right. 10 years on and I stil get confused about selections and Loupe.

[Rikk Flohr: Photography]

Other Rick.... 

[Todd Shaner]

I knew that! Thanks Rick........just a senior moment!

[KR Seals]

Win 10 Pro - LrC V10

I see the same behavior. In develop, changing the white balance on the main image, then selecting another image or images the Sync function does not work on the adjacent image or non-contiguous ones.  If I adjust esposure and WB, then sync, both values get synched.

In the Library module, Grid view, change the white balance in quick develop and use the Sync Settings button results in no sync of the WB. But, the WB field in quick develop does show that the value "tungsten" in this case has changed. When I try to sync the change in two values, WB and exposure, the exposure syncs, but the WB does not. 

I tried just changing the WB in Grid View on an image and nothing else. Then the sync with the adjacent image worked ok if I also had Basic Tone checked, even though I had not made any changes to those items.

[arjunhaarith]

Thanks a lot Ken, for reporting this, and others for confirming.

We are able to reproduce and are investigating the issue.

Thanks,

Arjun

[idahochukar]

@arjun_haarith You'r welcome and thank you

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

If you select one of the standard present white balance settings (example: Daylight) and copy settings, when pasting to another photo the white balance is not applied.  If you copy a custom white balance then this is applied.

Lightroom Classic 10.0

In previous versions this worked as expected

[TheDigitalDog]

Yeah, something isn't right on this end either (Mac OS). 

I DO see the WB label change from say As Shot to Fluorescent but I don't see the color appearance update. I'll file a bug report. 

[TheDigitalDog]

What's happening with a paste is the actual WB menu gets updated but not the image. If you actually select the WB from said menu, it works. So yes, it's a bug and Adobe is now aware of it. Good catch! 

[arjunhaarith]

Hi Michael,

Yes, we are aware of this issue, and it will be addressed in the future release.

As a workaround you can use 'Auto Sync'

Thanks a lot. 

Thanks,

Arjun

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

The new Lightroom Classic 10.0 Mac wont sync the whitebalance settings in the develope module. The checkbox is on for syncing whitebalance, but nothing happens with the rest of the selected images when applying the settings. This is quite annoying …

[arjunhaarith]

Hi Kenn,

We are aware of this and are working on fixing it.

It'll be addressed in the future release.

Thanks,
Arjun

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Hey there, just letting you know this isn't limited to the Mac version, getting the same thing here on Windows, just updated last night, regretting it right now...

It updates the WB name to whatever you copied, Daylight, Custom etc but doesn't change the values Temp and Tint thus no change to the image itself.

[arjunhaarith]

Hi Jason,

Yes, we are aware of that.

As a workaround you can use 'Auto Sync' 

Thanks,

Arjun

[kenh26104938]

@Rick  

I am experiencing a similar problem with Copy and Paste. When I Check All in the copy function and then uncheck Color Grading, Color Grading is always copied anyway.  If I uncheck everything and then individually check each box except for Color Grading it works as it should.