P: Generative Remove Feedback (Lr Classic & Lr Eco)

Since the last Lightroom update, the three AI suggestions constantly show a black spot instead of an AI edit. It's awful. Instead of getting better, it gets worse with every update!

​@vincentr36861937, see this previous reply:

Note that no one has upvoted or added their details to the bug report about this, making it less likely Adobe will prioritize a fix.

I’m getting black spots instead of AI remove...why for??

​@thePhilograph, see this previous reply:

Note that no one has upvoted or added their details to the bug report about this, making it less likely Adobe will prioritize a fix.

that happens so often…. why 

Apple Tahoe 

latest 15.11

sony Raw 

​@michaelw47857878: When applying Generative Remove  w/Detect Objects the highlighted area (a stick) turns completely black. 

A number of people have reported this, and Adobe acknowledged the bug a couple months ago:

Please add your details to that bug report, attaching the original unedited image, the screenshot, and the output from the menu command Help > System Info. If the forum won't let you attach the file here, upload it to Wetransfer, Dropbox, Google Drive or similar free service and post the sharing link here. 

The more people adding details, the more likely Adobe will prioritize a fix.

Using MacOS 14.5, LR Classic 15.1.  When applying Generative Remove  w/Detect Objects the highlighted area (a stick) turns completely black.  Continues with the same black when viewing different Versions.  Redid the selected area with the same results.  A closeup of the area is attached.  This is the first time this has happened after using the same tool many times during this same session.

​@raissajardimc, 

Your symptoms indicate there’s a problem with the .lrcat-data file in the catalog folder that’s used to store the results of AI commands (like Remove). Follow Adobe’s recommended next steps precisely:

hola gente! uso mucho lightroom cada dia, y aun estando actualizado version 15.1.1 , en el modo de borrar con IA generativa, nunca me aparece el cuadro de dialogo para dar alguna informacion. El caso puntual es que trabajo con vestuarios grandes que vuela, y nunca me “extiende” el vestido, la tela digamos, siempre me la corta ampliando mas fondo. Se entiende el ejemplo? la ia me dijo que actualizando la app me apareceria el cuadro para poner por ejemplo “estender la tela” o “continuar cola del vestido”. Alguna recomendacion? ya se que migrando a photoshop se puede realizar, pero tengo bastante caudal de trabajo y prefiero optimizarlo resolviendo todo en lightroom. Alguna solucion o sugerencia para que aparezca el cuadro de dialogo? pueden ver el tipo de trabajo que hago en @lauraporporatto.artphotos … ahi lo entenderan todo. muchas gracias!!!!!!

Hello everyone, been having issues with generative removal. I remove objects from the photo, then I edit other photos, and when I export is like I havent removed anything. If I remove and imediately export, then the AI removal is correct, but if I take some time to export the AI goes back to original, without being removed. 

When I go back to the image the erasers have this orange symbol, but it only allows me to update without actually removing. So this orange symbol does nothing. 

I’ve already searched this problem and they say to update catalog, its already updated, to remove its place, I've done that, but nothing works.