Updates to issues encountered while generating images (User Guidelines Violations)

[Pete.Green]

Hello Photoshop community!

If you've used Generative Fill and Generative Expand, it's possible you've seen this dialog:

On November 7th 2023, the filters were adjusted to be less overly-sensitive, and we're still working to find the right balance here. If you continue to encounter issues after 11/7, please let us know in this thread!

Also, within this notice dialog, there is an opportunity to provide feedback to the team and request a review of the content. Please continue to use the feedback option to help us make improvements to this experience.

Thank you!

[alinic24]

OMG it's terrible since the latest update anything with too much leg showing gets stopped. I just want to fill int he background around her legs! She's wearing clothes what gives? I've tried several images from this session and another works fine with the second set, but the white backdrop and bare legs gets the flag everytime. 

[CSI Productions]

We in this community have been haggling over this since FireFly started. Everyone understands there are countries that have VERY strict rules on what can be seen and what can't. Heck, I used to work as a news graphic artist for the Christian Science Monitor (Boston) and got reprimanded for using a stock photo of a guy on the beach picking up his girlfriend in a two piece bathing suit (not a string bikini, a two piece). This was for an over the shoulder news graphic about vacationing. Oops, who knew. I thought it was rediculous. The point is, some people don't get art. This is real stringent in some countries. Can't Adobe make the rules different based on the country you're in? If you live in a country that's really strict (ni hao) then you get the tight restrictions if you don't they get a less overbearing.

As mentioned before, bottom line, Adobe is a private company and as such can do whatever they like. You have the option of using other software for Ai generation. There are a ton out there (with zero restrictions) so if Adobe won't let you add a background to a girl wearing a dress because (ITO) it's just too risque - use another companies software.

[Isha38535316e8r3]

Adobe, PLEASE stop this insanity! I cannot generate ANYTHING on pictures that I have taken of any models. WHY? Is this violating the guidlines?? CAn my models only be fully clothed? Please answer because this drives me crazy!

[Z3ROCOOL22]

When i use GF in the Normal/Live PS client it works like should, but in PS Beta i get it goes against the terms, bla, bla...

I hope you don't push it on the Normal client, because it will become unusable.

[Z3ROCOOL22]

Yes, it's extremely censored on the PS Beta.

They need to turn down a little the SAFETY switch, because it will make it unusable:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/photoshop-beta-discussions/generative-fill-ps-beta-overcensored-compa...

[R Huber]

I thought it might be improved with the new release. Nope. I'm working with images of classical stone statuary. I even spent the time to digitally apply bikinis to the sculptures so that Adobe's algorithm doesn't assume I'm creating pornography. That didn't work either. I can't tell you how many hours I've wasted with this. I guess I'm just a dirty minded sham of an artist who doesn't deserve to get my money's worth for a product I've been paying for for almost 30 years.

[R Huber]

I finally got generative fill to create ancient chest plate armor for my stone sculpture by finding an image of a woman in exercise clothing in a similar position and camera angle. Tons of extra work, but whatever. The hilarious thing is, after all its fussiness about my partially nude stone statues, half the chest plates ended up having huge (like weirdly huge) metallic *nip-ples* on them ("The message body contains n*****s, which is not permitted in this community). Please remove this content before sending your post").

What exactly is going on over there at Adobe? 

[jill_4156]

Hi there, It still keeps saying the same thing. I just wanted to add a sixpack in a picture and it says "We encountered an issue with your results. Please view our guidelines and try again. How can I solve that issue?