Skip to main content
@MNiessenPhoto
@MNiessenPhoto
Braniac
April 9, 2018
Question

3D issue - mesh visible in thin objects when texture is semi-transparent

  • April 9, 2018
  • 1 reply
  • 776 views

Hi,

I have an issue with thin 3D objects that have a semi-transparent texture. The underlying mesh is visible, mixed with the texture, both in the normal workspace or after rendering. I've noticed this is the case only with very thin objects. I want to make a photography film look (with a twist) and so I create an extrusion from a 1px thin rectangle path/shape. Everyhting's fine up until I apply less than 100% opacity, whether directly in the material panel or with some transparency when I edit the texture.

See the images below so it's clear what is my issue:

1st image: in the workspace

2nd image: texture rendering (copper colored with some transparency)

3rd image: acrylic texture (from the included default textures)

This happens in the latest Photoshop update (19.1.3 from April 2018), but I haven't tried that effect in earlier versions.

After much head scratching, I've checked with different thicknesses and the problem gradually disappears the thicker it gets, depending on the twist and bending. With the image below, the mesh completely disappears at around 5px thick for 100px wide, but then my object is too thick for the intended use. Actually, even when I leave the extrusion completely flat, the mesh is somewhat visible (a big triangle across the whole extrusion); in that case, I could use a post card to avoid the issue, but once again, it's not what I want to do, as I want the twist.

Is there anything I can do to resolve that problem? It doesn't seem normal that this kind of stuff happens, is it?

At this point, I'd even settle for a tricky way to create that same effect, as long as it looks good with only my semi-transparent texture visible.

Any help will be greatly appreciated.

Michael

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

davescm
davescm
Braniac
April 9, 2018

Without seeing the details of the settings, mesh and textures it is almost impossible to answer this.

It could be that the twist is putting two surfaces (front and back ) at the same location. A big no-no in 3D, and in real life, but one which Photoshop does not have the tools to resolve.

Can you post a link to the actual file that we can take a look at?

Dave

@MNiessenPhoto
@MNiessenPhotoAuthor
Braniac
April 9, 2018

Thanks for your quick answer, Dave!

I just made it again and you can get the PSD at https://adobe.ly/2GOY07O

Nothing fancy there: I created a rectangular path (100x5 pixels), extruded, twisted and applied the 'Plastic Acrylic' texture. Then again with a 100x1 pixels path (the one failing).

What I fail to understand is that, even if the two surface were messed up, the "mesh" itself shouldn't be shown. A distorted shape would be more likely, no?

Anyway... I hope there's a way to correct that or, at least, go around it and create the desired shape with some kind of magic trick

Michael

Photo-editing (Ps/Lr/LrC) and photography workshops & one-on-one training (off- and online)
davescm
davescm
Braniac
April 9, 2018

Hi

I took a look at the file in Photoshop then in Blender. The issue is with the mesh geometry in that the extreme twist on the very thin cross section is causing the faces of the mesh to cross each other i.e. a front face is crossing the back. That can't hap[pen in real life and causes the ray tracing to go awry.

Your choices are :

a. Increase the thickness

b. Reduce the twist

c. Make the mesh in a proper 3D programme where you have control of the number of faces and can prevent the cross over

Dave

Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices