Skip to main content
Participant
April 8, 2021
Answered

working spaces - gray gamma 1.8 or 2.2 in Rob Adobe RGB (1998)

  • April 8, 2021
  • 3 replies
  • 15122 views

Hi, 

In color settings, I'm using ADOBE RGB (1998) mode.

I'm using Mac and I don't Know what gray to use - GRAG GAMMA 2.2 or 1.8 and why.

 

may you help me to undstnad?

Thanks,

Correct answer D Fosse

Proper grayscale support is mostly non-existent anywhere outside Photoshop. The best advice is probably to avoid it if you can.

 

But if you have to, you should use a grayscale profile that closely matches the intended output. For anything screen-based, gray gamma 2.2 should be reasonably close. An alternative is sGray, which uses the tone response curve of sRGB (which is not a regular gamma function).

 

In offset print, grayscale has a special use, as it prints on the black plate only. If, for instance, you place grayscale in InDesign, it will output as 0-0-0-K. The best way to deal with this is to use the K component in the appropriate CMYK profile as working gray.

 

In color settings, open the working gray rolldown, and click "load gray". Navigate to the CMYK profile you use. It will come up as Black Ink - <CMYK profile>. Once set up as working gray, it also becomes selectable in Convert to Profile.

 

3 replies

gener7
Community Expert
Community Expert
April 18, 2021

This article advises that your gray gamma should match your RGB gamma in Adobe RGB or 2.2

That's for Photography and screen as pointed out correctly in the above post. Go with D.Fosse's advice for print.

https://gregbenzphotography.com/luminosity-masking/how-to-optimize-your-gray-working-space-for-better-luminosity-masks

 

 

D Fosse
Community Expert
D FosseCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
April 18, 2021

Proper grayscale support is mostly non-existent anywhere outside Photoshop. The best advice is probably to avoid it if you can.

 

But if you have to, you should use a grayscale profile that closely matches the intended output. For anything screen-based, gray gamma 2.2 should be reasonably close. An alternative is sGray, which uses the tone response curve of sRGB (which is not a regular gamma function).

 

In offset print, grayscale has a special use, as it prints on the black plate only. If, for instance, you place grayscale in InDesign, it will output as 0-0-0-K. The best way to deal with this is to use the K component in the appropriate CMYK profile as working gray.

 

In color settings, open the working gray rolldown, and click "load gray". Navigate to the CMYK profile you use. It will come up as Black Ink - <CMYK profile>. Once set up as working gray, it also becomes selectable in Convert to Profile.

 

c.pfaffenbichler
Community Expert
Community Expert
April 18, 2021

What is the most likely print condition in your market? 

Do you ever actually work with grayscale images or spot colors?