Skip to main content
Inspiring
October 29, 2020
Answered

Are you serious?? Adobe Premiere doesn't have the capability to add a Stroke?????

  • October 29, 2020
  • 5 replies
  • 1648 views

How lazy are these developers??  A basic feature that people have been requesting for years, and these developers still can't get around to it??  

Correct answer Kevin-Monahan

Chris,

I apologize that this long standing request has still not been addressed. l upvoted this feature request. Hope we can get others seeing this thread to do the same. I was hoping there would be some easy way to pull this off in Essential Graphics. There is not. I'll mention it to the team, as well. 

 

Thanks,
Kevin

5 replies

Kevin-Monahan
Community Manager
Kevin-MonahanCommunity ManagerCorrect answer
Community Manager
November 10, 2020

Chris,

I apologize that this long standing request has still not been addressed. l upvoted this feature request. Hope we can get others seeing this thread to do the same. I was hoping there would be some easy way to pull this off in Essential Graphics. There is not. I'll mention it to the team, as well. 

 

Thanks,
Kevin

Kevin Monahan - Sr. Community and Engagement Strategist – Adobe Pro Video and Audio
Community Expert
April 15, 2021

Here's an easy way to add a stroke to a mask:

https://youtu.be/t4Ui9JX2iPQ

R Neil Haugen
Legend
October 30, 2020

Yep, there's been a few. The first one has 35 posts since 2011, and included several methods.

 

Tthe second is a single post that had no answers.

 

The third one was one question on how with two answers on how to do it.

 

Doing a little math, that's under 40 posts over a decade. Yea, there may be a few more similar threads. But there are several ways to accomplish the job.

 

As I noted above, please file a UserVoice request ... or go there, search, and upvote one already existing. Post back there with a link, asking other users to upvote it. I'll happily go vote for it myself.

 

And ... it ain't my program. Like all other ACPs, I'm just a volunteer user like yourself, who takes time from my day on my own to help other users.

 

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
R Neil Haugen
Legend
October 30, 2020

Your first post and heading are rather cryptic, and as nearly all uses of strokes I've ever seen have been for text, I wasn't expecting anything else. If you don't explain yourself clearly, you can't expect people to guess, especially when you are using something normally used for X and applying it to Y.

 

I've been on this forum daily since oh, mid-CS6 era. I don't recall once having someone ask about putting a stroke on a cropped video layer here. That would tend to indicate it's not been a huge request item across the user base.

 

That doesn't mean it wouldn't be good, helpful, and useful for some users. So asking for it would be most welcome. As always, there are many things very useful to some niche of the user base that are very worth the effort to add them to the program. But don't make the assumption that most of the user base is pining for it.

 

Graeme's comments to me are spot on. You can accomplish the effect in several ways already.

 

And also respectfully ask for the ability to create one in a new way for this program. We peer users tend to be first practical: if there's a current way, give the help on how to get stuff out the door now. And past that, advise on how to get something added or changed in the future. But current work doesn't wait for the future, it has to get to the client.

 

This is of course their user-to-user peer support forum.

 

To appeal to the engineers and the upper managers who decide budgets and features and other changes ... post a request and/or upvote preset requests over on their UserVoice system. Every post there is read & logged by at least one engineer as it gets added into their system. And all posts there are collated and sent to their upper managers.

 

Neil

 

 

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Chris5CBEAuthor
Inspiring
October 30, 2020
R Neil Haugen
Legend
October 30, 2020

Um ... your comments are cryptic ... but yes, Premiere specifically allows multiple strokes available on text, and drop shadows, and changeable background blocks behind them.

 

So I have no clue what your "not for text" refers to at all.

 

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Chris5CBEAuthor
Inspiring
October 30, 2020

Seriously?  You're confused about the meaning of "Not for Text"?  It means I'm not trying to put a stroke on text.  "For a cropped layer" means I'm trying to put a stroke on a cropped video layer.  You should be able to put a stroke on a cropped video layer, you can do it in Photoshop, you can do it in After Effects, and you can do it in FCP, and the fact that you can't in Premiere even though people havbe been asking for it for years is a complete joke.

Graeme Bull
Community Expert
Community Expert
October 30, 2020

Drop shadow works just fine on a video. You're correct there isn't a stroke feature available but you can always wing it if you really had to and make a rectangle (upper menu, graphics, new layer, rectangle). Remove the fill and create whatever stroke you want and place it in the same spot and size as your video. Or do as you say and make it in photoshop or AE and bring it back into premiere if the first option isn't quite what you're looking for (although I think it is). No need to be mean or angry. You get more bees with honey than vinegar 🙂 Cheer up, things could be worse. Premiere could crash all the time or suck at rendering h264 4k footage etc... oh wait....

R Neil Haugen
Legend
October 29, 2020

How many strokes do you want? It's easy ... just keep adding them.

 

It's in the Essential Graphics panel ... add text to the program monitor, go to the Graphics workspace/EGP, edit tab, and look down below in the formatting options. I've got two in the image below.

 

Neil

 

 

 

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Chris5CBEAuthor
Inspiring
October 29, 2020

Not for Text.  For a cropped layer.  Drop shadow won't work either.