Dynamic Link breaks EVERY TIME with After Effects into Premiere

[j_mro]

This is one of the most frustrating things I've encountered from Adobe Premiere. The Dynamic Link breaks every time I save a project in After Effects. I will save my "linked" After Effects project, go back to Premiere and it breaks the link EVERY TIME. This has been going on so long I just re-link it every time and say "Im switching to Da Vinci". I have the most up to date Premiere and After Effects. 

This doesn't happen just once, or right after I open the program. No names are changed, no locations of projects or files change, just every time I hit save....boom, Premiere blows up.

This is unacceptable from a company like Adobe and I can't believe this hasn't been fixed. 

See link. Screen on the right in AE and then left is PP. You can watch it happen over and over and over again, just like I do!

[Moderator note: moved to Bug section of forum posts.]

[R Neil Haugen]

I can't replicate ... it just works here, whether on my desktop or laptop. Typically with this issue there are some things that can be changed on the offending system to get going properly.

The forum that would probably give you the best advice on this is actually the AfterEffects forum, because naturally most of the users there work linking back to Premiere constantly. They've a lot more troubleshooting experience between the two apps than most Premiere Pro users have.

Neil

AfterEffects user-to-user forum

[j_mro]

This never used to happen to me either, just when I went to 2020 I believe.

I had a friend working at my company try it and it happened to him every time as well. 

[Ali Jaber]

I can't replicate that too. Does it happen with all AE projects or this specific one?

[j_mro]

All AE files.

[RobShultz]

Are you saving in AE  before switching back to Premiere?

[j_mro]

Yes, I make any change and quickly hit Save, then go back to Premiere. 

This didn't happen awhile ago. I think Premiere Pro 2019 it still works fine, but it crashes too much to use. I chose the lesser of two evils. 

[jyunh48645654]

I have the exact same thing happen in After Effects when I save in Premiere.  And sometimes when I reload the Dynamic Link, it errors so I have to delete and re-import.

[Visual Vibration]

I am experiencing this problem! Very frustrating as I have multiple linked compositions under the same AE file, and I have to re-render every clip every single time I make an edit. 

Maybe just maybe - it is to do with having multiple linked compositions under one linked AE project? Can anyone confirm?

[R Neil Haugen]

I think the best place to ask this sort of question is actually the Ae forum. Have you been over there yet?

Neil

[Ford5FB2]

Same thing happens to me. It appears that dynamic link only works with one composition per file. I opened my After Effects file by right clicking a composition in Premiere and choosing "Edit Original." That one worked fine when I saved it. But I had two other compositions in that same After Effects file, and they broke in Premiere.

I wish I didn't have to make a new After Effects file for each dynamic link to work.

[MyerPj]

It does seem to fight you when you want to keep more than one comp in an DL-AE file. I too would prefer to put more than one in an AE project.

[R Neil Haugen]

Whatever we might like to have for behavior with AfterEffects comps on a Premiere timeline ... for me, the practical solution is always simply to finish the comp in Ae, export a file from Ae, and then replace the comp in Premiere's sequence.

Better playback. And ... it just works. Again, totally as a practical thing.

[MyerPj]

I see that happening on your system. Bummer. As others have noted, mine is working fine. PP 14.7, AE 17.5, Win 2004.

I've never had that problem. In fact I think it works well. Mostly I do titles in AE, and I see the changes in PP before I even save.

FWIW: Two things I think you can check is your file naming. Make sure it's simple, no special characters like ( or !@3), etc. And even eliminate spaces in the file names and path when possible.

I've read before deleting the 'DynamicLinkMediaServer' folder located here:  %UserName%\Documents\Adobe

sometimes helps. I usually just rename it with an 'x' in front and if I want to go back to it I can, meanwhile PP will create a new folder for you.

[Michael Grenadier]

well here's a workaround.  make sure your naming convention for your ae project is clearly related to the ae comp in premiere.  Render out your comp in AE as a high quality file and place that file directly on top of the ae comp in premiere (I actually prefer doing this as it keeps the rendering issues in premiere to a minimum).  If you need to go back and make changes, just open the AE project make changes and repeat the render in AE and replace the previous render in Premiere.  No it's not ideal, but at least you can keep working. 

[louisen88632622]

Did you ever report this to Adobe? I have the exact same problem, but they say others are not reporting this issue so it is not a bug. It must be a corrupt comp according to Adobe. Or many many many corrupt comps appartently, since it happens all the time.

[MyerPj]

https://adobe-video.uservoice.com/forums/911233-premiere-pro
User Voice is where the Adobe engineers look for bug reports, enhancement requests, etc. The urgency for bug reports or new features can be judged by how many of us users upvote the requests. You can search for similar requests using the search feature at the lower right. It's best to upvote a request that has some traction (votes) already, and you can upvote and reply to that thread. If you don't find one the matches your request, then enter a new one. Regardless, post a link back here so those seeing this thread can upvote also.

[louisen88632622]

There is a bug report for this started. Please vote so this issue can get fixed!

https://adobe-video.uservoice.com/forums/911233-premiere-pro/suggestions/43087128-after-effects-dyna...

[Enchanting_magic15C3]

having the same issues in both 2021 and in beta. 

[jmro]

This is still happening to me. I've updated to Premiere Pro 2022 v 22.0.0 and After Effects. How is this still an issue? Its been going on for over a year!

[Taylor23579675mcil]

Ever get it fixed? My thoughts were the exact same: switch to Davinci. Absolute joke.

[R Neil Haugen]

Understand your frustrations there! This is simply a killer when you need the tools of Ae. No question.

And it's very frustrating for those of us trying to sort the troubles out for others, because it is so freaking hit & miss. What fixes DL issues for one user, has no help for another. Most of us are doing fine, and some of us are hammered.

Yea, this is just a load of pain. I would hope they can get a more solid Pr/Ae link somehow.

Neil

[CreativeSpill_23]

I have the exact same issue. Anyone have any luck so far?

[R Neil Haugen]

Check over on the Ae forum, as the Ae power users are all over there. And they typically have more direct Ae/Pr workflow knowledge.

That said ... for some users, getting the task done in Ae, exporting a clip, and replacing a comp with the actual clip is "what works now" ... not ideal, but ... it works.

Neil

[David Hoare]

This had just started happening to me too. All was fine with DL up until the latest updates Premiere 23.0.0 😞