Skip to main content
eric escobar
Community Manager
Community Manager
February 17, 2023

Overview of automatic log video detection, interpretation, and timeline tone mapping workflow

  • February 17, 2023
  • 17 replies
  • 64306 views

Adobe Premiere Pro v23.2 has a new auto detect, interpretation and time line tone mapping workflow for log space video clips. We support Sony S-Log, Panasonic V-Log, and Canon Log video, as well as iPhone HLG and other HLG/ PQ video.

 

The following video shows how to enable and work with this new workflow.

 

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    17 replies

    AndrewTheGreat
    Known Participant
    November 24, 2023

    Hi, guys, and where am I to look up the log type Premiere Pro has detected? Is there any way to view it in Premiere pro in the Project bin somehow? I could not find an appropriate checkbox in the list of the Metadata View tab. Or is there some other piece of software that shows the exact video footage log type? Mediainfo does not.

    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    November 24, 2023

    Good question ... as someone who works for/with/teach pro colorists, this is something they struggle with quite frequently. And has a large part in getting appropriate color management and correction, especially vis a vis the other media types in your project.

     

    I know that the Premiere Properties panel can show what specific clips are. I wonder if there's some field if you check through the Metadata workspace options ... hmmm. 

    Everyone's mileage always varies ...
    AndrewTheGreat
    Known Participant
    November 24, 2023

    Hi, Neil, it has nothing of interest. Or it might have a different name...

     

    Known Participant
    October 17, 2023

    I really wish Adobe would publicly state their intention and end goal of this product. 

    I HAVE NO DESIRE TO SHOOT ON A MOBILE PHONE. IF YOU WANT TO MAKE A PRODUCT THAT SUPPORTS MOBILE PHONE FOOTAGE EDITORS, MAKE A SEPERATE PRODUCT. PLEASE. 

     

    it's October 17, 2023 and the last two updates to PP have resulted in HOURS of work completely RUINED. AFTER completely adjusting my workflow to "workaround" the problems from the LAST UPDATE. 

     

    These "automated tone mapping" features are changed in these "updates" and completely ruin everything I had done before. IDK if it's because now, I no longer need to "work around" these inconsistent "features" -or what, but it's getting absolutely RIDICULOUS. 

     

     

    Fergus H
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    October 17, 2023

    @Johnny29957850d8g6 More information about exactly what you are experiencing would be useful. The features that are described in this post are all optional and they default to being off

     

    I'd be happy to get on a call with you to discuss what you are seeing. Please send me a DM if you are interested. 

     

    Regards,

    Fergus

    Known Participant
    July 24, 2023

    Just downloaded 23.5 and now Premiere is designating my A7Siii Slog-3 S-Gaumut3.Cine footage as Rec 709 even though it isn't, so Auto Detect Log isn't working properly on my footage. Does anyone know why this might be happening?

    woffmann
    Participant
    May 14, 2023

    I recently tried out the new auto tone mapping feature in Premiere Pro 23.4.0 with some S-log3 footage. While I found that the feature works great for properly exposed log footage, I encountered some issues when working in a Rec709 sequence with log footage that was pushed or pulled in camera (under or overexposed as some may call it). It seems that the log footage on the Rec709 sequence lost a lot of its dynamic range as I cannot pull or push them back with the Exposure slider under Lumetri Color. So I guess the auto tone mapping happens right away once a log footage hits a sequence?

     

    This feels like the exact same issue with having the Input LUT drop-down menu as the very first thing in Lumetri Color. And at that point, it's really no different than baking in a Rec709 LUT in camera when shooting log.

     

    I think this new feature could greatly help with interpreting iPhone HLG footage though (which I can't wait to try). But as someone who shoots in S-log3 and delivers in SDR, and has waited for the log support/features to be ironed out for the past 1.5 years, I may have to continue to put my log to 709 conversion LUT under the Creative tab in Lumetri for now. 

    January 1, 2024

    Has there been a solution for this? I just tried "auto log detect" on the Sony FX3 as well. Its detected correctly as SLog3/S-Gamut3.Cine. But when I compare it to the footage interpreted as rec709, hightlights are blown out when I pull it down. Below a comparison of the highlights of the same frame. Does this interpretation REALLY apply BEFORE any color correction?

    January 1, 2024

    There definitely is a difference. Heres a blown out window - with automatic log detection and with the default sony Slog3Gamut3cine LUT. 

    Participant
    April 12, 2023

    Ive got some client footage that was shot Canon log3, but transcoded by the client to Prores to reduce file size.

    It isnt recognized by auto log detection. Is there a setting in AME that would preserve that function, when they transcode?

    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    April 12, 2023

    I doubt it ... as you'd have to have the file keep all the header information, which I don't think a t-code to anything else does.

     

    From what I've been around, I don't think Premiere could be recognizing log type from the image data, it needs the file header data to indicate the nature of the file. A staffer would need to give a definite yes/no, but from my experience Resolve can't do this kind of reverse sorting either.

     

    And I think a ProRes file would simply say it's a ProRes file of X bps, Y framsize, Z color space, and Q fps. With the audio channel data also.

     

    I work over at MixingLight, with my 'beat' primarily teaching colorists based in Resolve or Baselight, as to what Premiere can and/or does do in color and color management. I've seen your problem raised there, and also both on the LGG colorist's forum and the BlackMagic forum for Resolve users.

     

    It's common & it's a right royal pain. Just think of getting a couple huge drives, with 35TB of files between them. With a few thousand files, some used, some not. And ... some of the files are the camera originals, some are like your situation, t-coded and ... intriguing.

     

    Because they probably aren't really 'normalized' perfectly within typically the Rec.709 dynamic range or color space. So for someone who does CM controls to properly place everything in their chosen working color space in Resolve as their first step ... what the HAY do you do with these files that are ... Heaven only knows what?

     

    And at times the client can tell you enough to at least help, or give the original files. But a lot of the time, it's just simply trying different processes to see what gets at least a better result.

     

    And if you can apply a change to a batch of files in a bin & get all or most of them pretty darn close, great ... move on to the next group. Perfection probably ain't a reasonable goal. And deadlines are just that ... deadlines.

     

    Very frustrating work but ... survivable.

     

    Neil

    Everyone's mileage always varies ...
    Community Expert
    April 12, 2023

    great post Neil as usual...   

    Participant
    April 11, 2023

    I have a big problem with my S-log footage (both mxf and mp4). Premiere is inconsistent, maybe half the clips I bring in - it doesn't recognise the colour space at all. For these clips, the right click interpret footage window has the colour space option greyed out, and an auto generated lut/tone is burned in. I have unselected auto detect log video colour space in preferences. 2 mxf clips, filmed on the same camera, recorded right after one another, read differently. In the clip data, you can see that premiere doesn't recognise the s-log colour space in one of them (pic attached). These exact clips had no issues whatsoever in Premiere Pro 2021. All 2022 versions, and 2023 versions however have the same issue. 

    Pics attached for reference.

    Running Macbook Pro M2 - Ventura OS. 

     

    The program is unusable as it is. I can't download Premiere 2021 on CC either. 

     

    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    April 11, 2023

    I cannot figure out why they have to make the color management controls unusable at times. Such as in your example. And I've seen the same with BRAW and with some regular mov files, where one file of the group had a grayed-out CM control section.

     

    Like your example, I couldn't find anything different, I shot the files on the same cam, same day, and the MediaInfo header and file information on both was identical except for the name.

     

    I've had a number of files sent me by users here & elsewhere, and most of the time on my PC I could get the CM controls to work. But some, same thing as this ... it's grayed out.

     

    Same thing in the new Settings tab of the Lumetri panel in the public Beta. That's where apparently is the CM section of the current Interpret Footage dialog seem headed there.

     

    Subsections for Input, Working Space, Clip, and Display. But the clip section was always grayed out. On posting back, well ... you have to have the clip selected in the Project panel for the clip section to be available.

     

    ?

     

    And even then, for several whole projects, not one clip would give an active Clip section. I got one yesterday though. But no clue why ... and the others were still grayed out.

     

    I've got more experience than most with Lumetri, and Premiere's CM. And I can't figure that out.

     

    Neil

    Everyone's mileage always varies ...
    Participant
    April 2, 2023

    Hi Eric Escobar,

     

    Thank you for sharing this information about the new auto detect, interpretation, and timeline tone mapping workflow for log space video clips in Adobe Premiere Pro v23.2.

     

     

    The video you shared is also a great resource for learning how to enable and work with this new workflow. I appreciate you sharing this update with us and look forward to trying out this new feature in Adobe Premiere Pro!

    [Best Regards]

    Olivia devid

     
    max.zirkelbach@auto1.com
    Participant
    March 24, 2023

    Lovely Feature!

    Unfortunately, doesn't work with my Sony FX3 Footage (shooting in S-log3 / S-Gamut.Cine) so far. Can't wait!

    Cheers Max

    Fergus H
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    March 24, 2023

    Hi Max, 

     

    Footage from your camera should definitely work with this feature. Can you tell me more about what you're trying to do and what's not working? A screen recording might be the best way to show this. 

     

    Regards,

    Fergus

    Fergus H
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    July 28, 2023

    I turned on the metadata tag, but it did not fix the issue. Sequence settings and general preferences are still prompted to enable....


    @Elements Headshots Would it be possible to send me a sample of the media that is not being recognized? We have, well, pretty much every Canon camera that shots log in our testing lab and have confirmed that their files work with the auto detect log feature. 

     

    @R Neil Haugen FYI, auto tone mapping and auto detect log color space a related but entirely separate features. The former being checked (or unchecked) would affect the latter. Happy to jump on a call to chat about this if you'd like more detail. 

    Inspiring
    March 21, 2023

    This new feature seems not to be working for me. I watched the video tutorial several times and I am sure all my settings are correct: I certainly have "Auto Detect Log Video Color Space” selected in preferences. And in clip sequences "Auto tone map media" is also checked. I am wondering if my equipment simply isn't supported?

     

    I am working on an M1 Mac mini with macOS 12.6.3 installed. My footage is from an iPhone 12 MaxPro shot using the FilmicPro (v6) app set to 10bit HLG. I have also tried shooting with FilmicPro's Log V3.  Neither work. When checking Interpret Footage neither HLG nor Log V3 is registered but continues to show Rec 709.

     

    This is not really much of an issue as the LUTS for those profiles downloaded from the FilmicPro website work perfectly when loaded into the Interpret Footage section.

     

    Still, just wondering if I am doing something wrong or the files produced by FilmicPro simply aren't supported with this new Premier Pro auto detect feature.

    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    March 21, 2023

    As far as I know and can test ... and I've put weeks into testing this ... (though @Fergus H is certainly welcome to jump in!)

     

    Auto-Log only works with the media it recognizes specifically. To see which are included, the Override-To list of log media types is what is 'recognized' at any one time. If your media isn't listed by name there specifically, the Auto-Log doesn't work.

     

    They don't have a specific recognition ... "profile"? ... set for that Filmic variant, so the auto-log isn't being applied to it.

     

    For log media that isn't 'recognized', you can either use the preferred input LUT of your choice in Intepret Footage, or .. .set the Override-To option to the color space to be used with it. Then do your modifications to the image in Lumetri as needed.

     

    Neil

    Everyone's mileage always varies ...
    Jorge Jaramillo Hdz
    Known Participant
    March 21, 2023

    Hi, I'm trying this feature, in general works great, but when there are intensive lights it's not working good.

    (Lumix S5 footage, V-Log)

    I'm attaching three pictures:

     

    01:The footage as it is. 

     

    02: Aplying this new auto detect in the project and also the option in the sequence.

     

     

    Preset. Aplying my custom preset to gradding the Log. (No auto detect)

     

    As you can see, the blue colors in the Auto Detect are blow out.

     

    What could be the problem?


    Thanks in advance. 

     

     

     

     

    Adobe Employee
    April 18, 2023

    Hi Jorge Jaramillo Hdz,

    Thanks for writing to us. 

    The 2nd footage that you shared is the sequence or from the source monitor?

    If its from sequence then you can try by toggling the tone map checkbox for sequence. If its from soruce monitor please try by removing the input LUT if any applied under Interpret Footage for source media.

     

    Regards,

    Davinder Kaur