Possible bug with InPoint and OuPoint functions combination

Forum|Forum|1 year ago
February 6, 2024
1 reply
561 views

Depending on wether the value of In is superior or inferior to the value of Out, you can have a bug or a feature.

The experiments I did were in ticks, I don't know if they are valid in seconds.

1) Experiment 1:

If the value of In is inferior to the value of Out, but the difference between them is inferior to One frame, the project item will be inserted with FULL DURATION (ignores all ins and outs, even if they were set to a specific values before), this actually resets the values of in and out it seems.

2) Experiment2:

If the value of In is superior to Out, without any focus on the difference between of the 2 (it can be whatever), the same happens, FULL Duration of items.

I consider experiment 1 to be a bug because it should round up to 1 frame in such case.

I consider experiment2 to be a feature because it informs you that you "reversed" the order of in and out.

SDK

This topic has been closed for replies.

Bruce Bullis

Community Manager

ExtendScript that demonstrates Experiment 1, please?

Bed30321077z973Author

Inspiring

Yes, inside a sequence that has 25 frames:

Item is an audio:

Item.setOutPoint("15000000000", 4);
Item.setInPoint("10200000000", 4);
$.writeln("outpoint: ");
$.writeln(Item.getOutPoint().seconds); // result full duration (in my case: 2.784 seconds)
$.writeln(Item.getOutPoint().ticks); // result: full duration of an audio (for my case: 707180544000)

Interestingly enough, if I try a very simple example like

Item.setOutPoint("1", 4);
Item.setInPoint("0", 4);

There is not problem it is rounded up to one frame,

But with the numbers I provided the problem appears (cf, result of the prints)

Strange isn't it?

Bruce Bullis

Community Manager

>> that the projectItem behind this trackItem is audio

Yes this one!

But first time I encountered this problem was with a video actually, so I don't think it matters. I used an audio when I was testing again to understand what was happening.

The "Item" is from the "children" of the project aka project items. No need to interact with the tracks actually, just using the getter for outpoint will show that the values have turned to "original out point" of the item => max duration of item.

>But first time I encountered this problem was with a video actually, so I don't think it matters.

>The "Item" is from the "children" of the project aka project items

If it's a projectItem, not a trackItem, you've just completely changed the scope of the problem report.

In order to pursue your issue report further, we would need all available specifics about the project, sequence and media in use, as well as a complete ExtendScript script that reproduces the problem (not just the snippet above). Upload space available upon request.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded