Scene Edit Detection not working

[Jeff Bugbee]

Anyone gotten Scene Edit Detection working? On my PC, I've tried a variety of media and scene edit detection simply does it's Analyzing, then nothing. No cuts, no edits.

On Windows 10, Premiere v14.4.0 (Build 38)

[matthewb37678304]

Sorry, short on info. Intel iMac i9. Latest version of Premiere. Mac OS 13.2.1

Premiere 22 always worked like a dream, but since the update it's very flaky. I have tried it on MP4 as well as APple ProRes. No difference.

[Michael Grenadier]

no reason why you can't keep premiere 22 on your system and use that for scene detection and then bring the scene detected sequence into 2023 via xml.  The ability to have more than one version of premiere on the same system  is one of the great features available in Premiere.

[matthewb37678304]

Very true Michael, that hadn't occurred to me. It'd be nice if it work as designed, though.

[Michael Grenadier]

been doing this a very long time, starting on avid, then fcp 1-7 and now Premiere (and using resolve for difficult color correction jobs).  They've all had issues after some updates....   so for me, it's about getting the job done as quickly as possible often with the client sitting looking over my shoulder.    These are extremely complex programs and adding a feature or fixing a bug can cause  unexpected problems seemingly unrelated to the fix and with the vast variations in hardware it's unrealistic to expect adobe to test every possible variable...  I rarely use automatic scene  detection so I haven't had to try it in Premiere 2023 yet.    And gotta say, I tried it a number of times with DaVinci Resolve a few years ago and the interface was to say the least unintuitive and the results sucked...  although it might have been partly due to operator error...  

[joshuaw73079328]

I am having the same problem with the new update. I have had to role back to the previous version to keep the Scene Edit Detection function.

[hidekifernando]

I've tried to use the scene edit detection tool several times in different ways, and it's still not working.

Transcoded to Apple ProRes HQ a file that was 37GB turned into a 170GB file. Updated to the 22.6.4 Version of Premiere, updated the 23.3 version. Nesting, trying different files... Nothing.

MacBook Pro M1 32GB RAM

MacOS Ventura

Premiere Pro 2023

[Michael Grenadier]

do you want to send me a short clip and I'll see if I can get it to work?  I'm working on a new macstudio with premiere 23.2.  You can send me a direct message by clicking on my username at the top of my post.

[pablo mu88542410]

Same problem. I have tried all of those things. Has someone found a fix?

[Kevin-Monahan]

Hello @sarah21957859dzoj - Hi @pablo mu88542410,

I tested this issue out on macOS and PC and I could not replicate the issue. Can you please send me a test file that I can pass along to developers for further testing? Feel free to send me a PM with the link. I hope I can assist.

Thanks,
Kevin

[pablo mu88542410]

I don't know what you mean with test file or PM.

Thanks

[sarah21957859dzoj]

I also have this problem on windows 10. I run scene edit detection , it spends a few minutes analysing and when it's done nothing happens 

[Alex299770515rxh]

looks like there is barely any solutions even solutions are being posted. I'm playing around and if I find anything, I'll hit you up.

[tomswain2009]

Still not working for me. Have tried many times, many of the suggestions here. It loads and then nothing gets cut. 

[defaultns6k8v289np7]

Same here. Not tryng to pile on with unhelpful stories, but I've been trying all of these solutions and still the same issue. It will analyse, and then do nothing.

[Thomas3335695303l0]

my scene edit detection wont work at all, it keeps saying it failed and usuaaly makes me force quit the app. I also dont know what transcodes are

[irfan289661728xbt]

iit doesnt work too for my case. nothing happen when i tried many round to apply secen edit detection even after i shut it down and open it back. 

[빵빵띠끼야]

not working after update ver.24
and broken in ver 23.6 to

but It work in ver 23.0

- m1 ultra mac studio / sonoma OS -

- m2 max macbook pro / sonoma OS - same issue but can't lunch 23.0 OTL

[the_wise_bunny]

If anyone is still having trouble with this, I found that having the audio, and ensuring audio and video is linked, got detection working for me. No idea why!

[Michael Grenadier]

no idea either, but thanks for posting your workaround.  

[Nick Varley]

Every time I use it, I get no cuts the first time, but then I close Premiere Pro, open it again and immediately run Scene Edit Detection again and it works.  Not a huge pain to do this but it's definitely a bug and it would be nice if it just worked the first time.

Premiere Pro 24.1

M2 Pro Mac mini

Ventura 13.6.3

[Filmorus]

You need to understand, the task is not to improve something with updates, but to convince investors that everything is going on as it should. There are many muddy firms that produce for money what could have become part of the product for a long time, but never became and never become ... lol

[PeterPolillo]

Also not working with me, I just use DaVinci's "Detect scene cuts" then just export xml file for Premiere. way more faster.

[Brock Allen]

Yeah I just wanted to add my experience here as I got it to work.

If you don't have audio on that clip it won't add cuts, for whatever reason I'm not sure but this still seems to be a persistent problem to this day.