
Andrew Yoole
Community Expert
Andrew Yoole
Community Expert
Activity
‎Apr 06, 2009
04:39 PM
Once the opening furore dies down, Aaron, I'll drop a note to the Forum Boss and see if he can't rescue your name from the system if it's not otherwise being used.
... View more
‎Apr 06, 2009
08:39 AM
Yo Steve, You're quite right about the three-tone list of forum names, but I think the Forum is simply tracking your activity per-thread, not within the thread. What I meant was, the old Web Crossing Forum we've just lost would actually remember every post within each thread that the user had seen. So if, for example, I opened the "After Effects Wish List" thread and read up to post #160, the next time I viewed that thread it would automatically take me to post #160. In this new forum, its up to the user to remember what they've read and find that place, often through long lists of pages. There has been plenty of noise about this all over the Adobe Forums, so it will be interesting to see if the Jive guys can add this feature to their system.
... View more
‎Apr 06, 2009
07:40 AM
No sticky topics, at the moment, but time will tell. Glad you found the sub-forums to the side. It's kind of weird having them over there, but I'm sure we'll get used to the idea. Technically, everything in the old system should be here in the new, except FAQs (if I remember correctly). The whole thing is obviously going to evolve fairly rapidly over the next few days and weeks as demand dictates. At the moment, my biggest beef is that this new format fails to remember which posts have been read by the user - a nightmare in really long threads like "AE Wish List", for example. But I gotta say, I love being able to post pics and attachments, link to YouTube, write Scripts without corruption etc.
... View more
‎Apr 06, 2009
02:35 AM
Daijard wrote: Maybe is too short and i have to put a longer video to see it that way. Yes, that's correct. Your timeline is so short that AE can still segment it in frames. If you create a 30 second timeline and zoom out sufficiently, you'll see seconds clearly denoted.
... View more
‎Apr 06, 2009
01:13 AM
Not sure I understand, Daijard. If your composition has a very short duratio then you'll still see frames denoted in the timeline. Perhaps you could post a screen grab of the problem.
... View more
‎Apr 05, 2009
05:41 PM
Good shortcut, yenaphe, thanks!
... View more
‎Apr 05, 2009
04:00 PM
Go to File/Project Settings and choose the time format.
... View more
‎Mar 24, 2009
04:07 PM
Note Michael Coleman, AE Product Manager, has a blog called Keyframes:
http://blogs.adobe.com/keyframes/
Also Todd Kopriva, AE Documentation lead, has a blog called Region Of Interest:
http://blogs.adobe.com/toddkopriva/
... View more
‎Mar 22, 2009
06:09 PM
> What I have noticed is that there is a totally different set of aesthetic values being exhibited here between the Users of the Adobe Professional Graphic Arts applications (Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign) and the people who are almost entirely geared to AV or to web site work and the use of the formerly Macromedia products (such as Dreamweaver).
Ann, you may be correct. But if functionality is truly the most important feature of Adobe Forums, the WebX format falls dramatically short for my own applications:
WebX screws any code or script posted, generally making it unusable. For this reason, the Script and Expression areas of the After Effects forum are virtually non-existent. Users go to other places to discuss these features, because it's not practical to do so on the current forums.
A picture tells a thousand words. When new users come to the WebX forums and want to post a screen grab of their problem project, it's embarrassing to tell them they need to use an external image host to do so.
Video tells ten thousand words. The ability to easily embed YouTube and other online video content into a post is not just a great convenience, it's a way to teach, inform and demonstrate within the forum, rather than sending users somewhere else mid-discussion.
I share a number of your criticisms about the Jive Forums, but for me and the community which uses my frequented forums, the Jive system also offers features which are essential for productive use. As I suspect the new system, like the old, will evolve over time, I'm happy to embrace the positives of the change, and hope that any major problems can be resolved in time.
... View more
‎Mar 20, 2009
05:44 PM
^ What's more, it makes Threaded View functional as well.
John, a big vote from me for flex-width! :-)
... View more
‎Mar 20, 2009
05:41 PM
Eric, your fix is fantastic. Flex-width makes a terrific difference to the Jive forum - for me, at least. Thanks very much!!
... View more
‎Mar 19, 2009
05:43 PM
From Sydney Australia, Mac OS 10.5.6, Firefox 3.0.7
The Jive page takes about 7 seconds to load. The WebX page takes about 1 second.
There is certainly a speed differential from my location.
... View more
‎Mar 16, 2009
05:14 AM
The Aviator
http://www.adobe.com/motion/aviator.html
The Talented Mr Ripley
http://www.adobe.com/uk/motion/spotlights/mrripley/index.html
Van Helsing
http://www.smorgasboard.com/pages/van_helsing_movie.html
... View more
‎Mar 16, 2009
04:32 AM
>char scriptPath[] = "F:\\Documents and Settings\\akshays\\Desktop \\Active Shutter.jsx";
I'm no scripting guru, but aren't you using backward-slashes where forward-slashes should be used?
... View more
‎Mar 13, 2009
11:40 PM
Well, I think I qualify as a native. I've been a posting member here for 7 years, and a Forum Host for 4 or so. I'm an "answerer", not an "asker". I'm also an award-winning motion graphics designer who has used Adobe software since Photoshop 2.
I post on numerous other Forums, of all shapes and sizes, and I have no problem with any of them particularly. I post because I enjoy contributing and communicating with my peers, and with those who are still learning. I must say that the formatting and attachment limitations of our current system are very noticeable.
I'm really looking forward to the Forum update. There is certainly feedback from users at the After Effects forum in the negative at times - the text-only look of the current forums, and inability to easily attach photo's or embed code properly, and the tendency of WebX to improperly display code fragments by posters discussing Java-based Scripts and Expressions, are serious problems for users there.
I, for one, like avatars. I think they give Forums a bit of personality, and help you to easily identify and remember less-frequent contributors. Any bandwidth they might chew up is really not a concern to me, and I doubt it would be to the majority of users whose business is creating and manipulating digital media. I think people working in this biz with dial-up are probably few-and-far between these days.
The new search capabilities sound fantastic, and I'm eager to try them out.
My primary concerns are purely speed/reliability, for obvious reasons, and the ability to know which posts I've already viewed. So long as those parameters are met, I'm one "native" who welcomes the changes.
... View more
‎Mar 11, 2009
04:11 AM
:-)
... View more
‎Mar 10, 2009
11:17 PM
Disregarding your opinion of my analogy, I'm sure you understand my point.
The fact that this Forum attracted 210,000 contributors these past 4 months, and maybe 40 or 50 have commented in this "New Forum" section (many of whom are Forum Hosts or other recognized contributors) implies very clearly that a vast number of Forum users are not concerned enough, or informed enough, about the change to have commented.
... View more
‎Mar 10, 2009
06:37 PM
I'd suggest that the vast majority of Adobe Forum users, much like car owners, don't really care too much about the nuances of the engine driving it. So long as it gets them to their destination, the Forum has done its job. Sure, a few enthusiasts will take the time to kick the tires and check the engine-timing, but the majority of users don't want that kind of involvement - they just want to find an answer quickly and easily, so they can get on with their real work.
... View more
‎Mar 09, 2009
06:34 PM
The new forum will use Jive's Clearspace - see this thread:
http://www.adobeforums.com/webx/.59b80553/55
... View more
‎Mar 03, 2009
08:09 PM
How about Adobe Software Specialists? ;)
Andrew Yoole
ASS
... View more
‎Feb 19, 2009
04:19 PM
Please stay on topic in the User To User Forums.
If you wish to post more casually on non-software issues, may I recommend the Video Lounge in the Premiere Pro section:
http://www.adobeforums.com/webx/.1dea22a5/
Thanks! :-)
... View more
‎Feb 16, 2009
05:31 PM
I must concur. Nothing worse than navigating a 300-post thread from the start every time.
... View more
‎Feb 10, 2009
05:47 PM
Sounds like you've answered your own question...? :-)
... View more
‎Feb 01, 2009
05:00 PM
1 Upvote
Expressions are layer-based formulae/commands that manipulate the layer and its content/effects based on factors such as time, random number generation, variables, and other layers and elements within the project. An expression can only change elements of the layer parameter to which it is applied - it cannot alter any other layer or parameter within your project, although it can "see" changes in other elements and react accordingly.
AE Scripting, however, is an application-wide scripting language, which can perform almost any possible function within AE, from creating new projects, comps and layers, to reading data from external files, sending emails etc.
Both are customized adaptations of Java Script. Both were developed independently of Flash Actionscript, so while they share similarities, they are not the same.
One of the best places to learn about AE Scripts and Expressions is Dan Ebbert's fantastic site:
http://www.motionscript.com
And, of course, the AE manual. Expressions:
http://help.adobe.com/en_US/AfterEffects/9.0/WS3878526689cb91655866c1103906c6dea-7a39a.html
Scripting:
http://help.adobe.com/en_US/AfterEffects/9.0/WSD2616887-A41E-4a39-85FE-957B9D2D3843.html
... View more
‎Dec 02, 2008
11:17 PM
3 Upvotes
If they must be on separate layers, and you don't mind them being paths/shapes, the easiest way is to use Illustrator.
Create your text, convert to paths with Text/Create Outlines, then select the new layer group and choose "Release To Layers (Sequence). This will place every character into a new layer.
Import to AE as a comp and you're done.
... View more
‎Nov 26, 2008
04:18 PM
A Forum user is seeking a developer for AE plugins. Please view this thread:
http://www.adobeforums.com/webx/.59b71f51
... View more
‎Nov 16, 2008
10:36 PM
The question of Adobe's International Pricing discrepancy was also raised after the launch of CS3, and has been discussed in these forums in that context.
This message from Adobe in May last year:
___________________________________________________________________
Here are some concrete examples of factors that make costs higher in Europe compared to North America.
It costs Adobe 5 times more to manufacture and manage inventory in Europe because:
*We must maintain different skus for each language version to support different labeling requirements, support information, and sales requirements.
*We maintain smaller quantities per language, in keeping with market sizes, which increases costs for printing, inventory management, and inventory disposal.
* The costs associated with our value-added reseller channels are 25% higher.
* We maintain 2.5 times as many field marketing employees in Europe as in North America to support our creative business at a certain level of quality across local markets. However, the revenue per employee is smaller, so the overall costs per unit of revenue is 4:1 in Europe compared to North America.
* Variable marketing expenses are 46% higher.
* Development costs are approximately $2.5$3 million per language for each of the 14 languages Adobe Creative Suite supports.
We cannot provide specific numbers, but these percentages and multiples capture real differences.
Its natural to compare pricing and pricing uplift across similar companies, but in this case, the comparison can be deceptive. The value of different products to customersand the costto companies to develop, sell, and support those productscan vary significantly from product to product, and manufacturer to manufacturer. Adobe does not develop our pricing for Europe or the rest of world by simply applying an uplift to the US pricing. As stated earlier, we develop our pricing by weighing customer research and our costs of doing business. We cant comment on the methods that other companies use to set their prices for Europe and the rest of world.
Its understandable why customers would expect to be able to purchase the same product at the same price when ordering and downloading directly from the Adobe Web site at www.adobe.com. Today, however, we still sell the majority of our products through traditional retail channels, and we optimize our pricing for that way of doing business. We depend on our retail partners in local markets to help us reach as many customers as possible, and we have a policy of not undercutting them on price. In addition, the Creative Suite 3 applications are large and require significant time to download. For many customers, online downloads will not serve as a reasonable purchase option for some time. However, as bandwidth increases and customer expectations change, well need to investigate ways to optimize our pricing for this approach.
Lastly, some higher regional costs will remain regardless of the method of purchase. For example, customers will still read about our products through local press to whom we reach out; they will meet local Adobe sales people who conduct seminars, participate in user groups, and visit large customers; and they will rely on support resources that Adobe makes available in these markets. All of these efforts impact the business costs of securing the sale, whether that sale is delivered online or in a box.
Customer service agents do not really have time to browse external websites, but I hope this deals with the questions you asked.
Should you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Yours Sincerely,
Joel Williams
Adobe Customer Service
... View more
‎Oct 09, 2008
07:05 PM
^ I really like that idea! The ability to "time-lock" keyframes to a layer, a layer handle, or overall comp position, would be really handy.
So, for example, right clicking selected keyframe(s) and choosing "Lock Keyframe" opens a dialog box with checkbox options:
Lock keyframe(s) relative to:
Layer start handle
Layer end handle
Layer source timecode
Composition timecode
As a workaround in the meantime, however, you might want to try the "Fade In+Out" animation presets, which uses expressions to automate opacity fades at the start and end of a layer.
... View more
‎Sep 26, 2008
03:21 AM
^Previous attempts at a Forum update have not been overly successful, but a new combined format for ALL Adobe forums is in the works.
... View more
‎Aug 06, 2008
03:55 PM
Well, Todd, I think After Effects Help is anything BUT horrific.
(I would have underlined that, but it's not an option in this Forum, either.) :-)
... View more
- « Previous
- Next »