I wholeheartedly agree with you that Captivate Classic is more robust and full featured for creating the kind of e-learning that most developers and their clients want. There simply hasn't been the kind of demand for responsive design that Adobe expected to see when they designed the new Captivate's functionality set. And as a result of that, Captivate has now lost a significant amount of market share to competitors that stuck to just delivering what developers wanted in their tool.
Having said that, the problem that Captivate Classic faces is that it is eventually going to be unsupported by Adobe (supposedly before 2027 or even earlier). This means that companies that have opted to be reliant on it as a tool for e-learning will one day find it will simply stop working for them. That could happen because Adobe pulls the plug on it. But most likely it will happen because Apple or Microsoft one day release an OS update that causes Captivate to stop working overnite. This has happened many times in Captivate's history. In fact it seems to happen every single time Apple does a Max OS update and Mac users dive in to get the latest. Adobe usually releases a fix, but that takes weeks or months, if it comes at all.
So, why should you use the new Captivate? Good question. One possible reason to migrate to the New Captivate is that there IS actually supposed to be new functionality to be released soon (if not already) that will allow older CPTX files to be upgraded to Cp format. That still won't fix the other glaring issues you mentioned about missing functionality, but at least it might provide a way forward for companies that have significant numbers of older courses developed in CPTX that they want to keep. I have not seen any of Adobe's competitors advertising similar functionality to convert CTPX into their own formats.
... View more