So what you want is the Numbered list to define the first tab position in a paragraph style. In my example, notice how the left, first, and tab position are defined:
Then, in Tabs section of the paragraph style, notice the second defined tab that makes the underscore:
This second tab has underscore characters defined in it. There are no other tabs defined in the paragraph style.
It is true that the Tabs panel is small and too fussy to aim your mouse at. Ever since PageMaker 1.2 it has been too small and fussy. And yes, the left indent (which you can shift-drag, btw) must equal the tab position, it cannot be ahead of the tab, or else it nullifies the tab. This is not a bug. To delete an existing tab, drag it downwards. I avoid using the Tabs panel by defining a paragraph style, and defining distances in the paragraph style options dialog box.
... View more