Skip to main content
Inspiring
August 1, 2021

P: Metadata issues with video files on M1 Macs

  • August 1, 2021
  • 31 replies
  • 8743 views

Today I noticed Lightroom Classic was displaying incorrect metadata for recent imported videos (taken with iPhone X). My older videos have correct metadata, so what changed? Appears to be an issue specific to M1 Macs.

 

Here is what I found...

 

On M1 Mac Mini:

1. Get info in Finder for MOV files shows the expected metadata. Created date/time is correct, and other details such as latitude longitude are displayed.

2. When I import these files into Lightroom, the metadata for capture date/time is incorrect. Lightroom displays the date/time the video was imported into Lightroom for capture date/time, which is clearly not when the video was captured. The GPS box is blank and no camera info is displayed.

 

On Intel Mac:

My Lightroom catalog and masters are on an external drive, so I connected to an Intel MacBook. I imported the exact same MOV file. This time, Lightroom displays the correct capture date/time (matches the created date/time as seen in Finder). The GPS box pulls in correct location coordinates and camera model displays iPhone X.

 

Adobe, can you please address this in your next Lightroom Classic release?

 

 

This topic has been closed for replies.

31 replies

johnrellis
Legend
July 9, 2022

Providing a couple of sample videos would go a long way towards ensuring a bug report with a recipe that Adobe can easily reproduce.  Upload them to Dropbox, Google Drive, or similar and post the sharing link here.  

 

Also, by "importing directly from iPhone on M1 Pro Mac", do you mean you've attached the phone to the Mac with a USB cable?

scaredbyninjas
Participant
July 9, 2022

I took the time to jump through all the support hoops with Adobe's support team. They google my issue, point to this thread and say a fix was released. I tell them there are still issues. Of course they doubt me. After multiple days of troubleshooting, they finally are able to verify the issue with the engineering team. At some point the bug might get fixed, though they closed my support ticket so clearly I won't hear about it. @Rikk Flohr: Photography , would love your assistance or comments for those of us following this thread.

scaredbyninjas
Participant
May 28, 2022

BTW: I was the original poster who reported this issue back in Aug 2021. The community migration unlinked the post from my user account. I have seen slight metadata improvements in subsequent releases, but the bulk of the issue remains.

 

When importing directly from iPhone on M1 Pro Mac...

 

Standard Videos display the following:

Date Time Original: [blank]

Date Time Digitized: Correct date/time displayed

Date Time: Date the file was imported into Lightroom

GPS: Correct coordinates displayed

Model: Correct model displayed

 

Videos from Live Photos display the following:

Date Time Original: [blank]

Date Time Digitized: Date/time appears to be off by the amount of my UTC offset

Date Time: Displays the date the file was imported into Lightroom

GPS: [blank]

Model: [blank]

 

With the new version of Lightroom CC, importing via an Intel Mac is no longer a reliable workaround. On some files it imports correct metadata and others it now exhibits the same issues as the M1 Mac described above. I will gladly provide annotated screen shots or anything else that will help to resolve this issue.

 

scaredbyninjas
Participant
May 28, 2022

Hi @Rikk Flohr: Photography  Even with the latest version of Lightroom Classic I am still experiencing issues with metadata for videos imported on M1 Macs. What information can I provide to help your team troubleshoot?

johnrellis
Legend
February 23, 2022

"Here's a screenshot of the time difference with .mp4 files coming from a Osmo Action. ... So, for a video i just tested with at 11:15am, ... Classic shows 7:15pm."

 

This sounds like the longstanding issue with capture dates in Quicktime video:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-bugs/p-video-capture-time-shifted-by-time-zone-offset/idc-p/12258901#M3088 

 

Are you in time zone UTC - 8 (PST)?  Attach a short sample .mp4 here and I can verify.

Earth Oliver
Legend
February 23, 2022

@Rikk Flohr: Photography Here's a screenshot of the time difference with .mp4 files coming from a Osmo Action. Classic is +5 hours off.
And to make this even more confusing, it appears that MacOS 12.2 is off by +3 hours as well. So, for a video i just tested with at 11:15am, the Finder shows 2:15 pm and Classic shows 7:15pm. And yes, the time is set correctly in the camera.

Earth Oliver
Legend
February 14, 2022

It also appears now that Classic is unable to sort correctly by Capture Time if file types are not the same. I have a folder of heic, mov, and jpg and when i sort by Capture, the images are not in the correct order, with the jpgs being out of order.

Earth Oliver
Legend
February 14, 2022

Thanks for the info, @Rikk Flohr: Photography but the issue is still present in v11.2.
Imported video files show an incorrect capture time when compared in the Finder. Previously it was the time when imported into Lr, and now it's just random variations depending on file type. 
And i need to test, but it looks as if Classic may even be re-writting the capture time metadata on imported .heic files. Even though the .heic files are showing the correct time in Lr, the Finder is displaying the time when imported to Classic.

This is a massive mess right now.

Participant
February 8, 2022

Worked for me as well.

thanks a lot!

Andi

Participating Frequently
February 8, 2022

Hi @Rikk Flohr: Photography , 
Thank you so much for releasing the fix. It worked!!
I need to remove and reload video files to LR to see Exif data, but it's much better than nothing.
Thanks,
Satoshi