Skip to main content
Known Participant
August 19, 2022
Question

Export performance new GPU gear research

  • August 19, 2022
  • 4 replies
  • 1678 views

I work as a Sports photographer and have to export 10.000 plus images every weekend. When I exporting in the new Lightroom I see it's using only the Ram memory of my GPU (fully using) and it's ok but if I want to speed up my workflow what should I look for in a new GPU?

1 - RTX 3070 TI with 8GB and Faster Clocks?

2 - RTX 3060 with 12GB More memory? (12gb)

 

I have a ryzen 5900x and a RTX 2060 with 6Gb only...

 

As I see Lightroom is only using the ram memory i think the cheaper RTX 3060 would be a better choice for speed up my export time?

This topic has been closed for replies.

4 replies

YBfotografija
Participating Frequently
March 28, 2023

Good morning,

I am facing the next issue - when I am opening 30 Mpix file in Photoshop > Camera Raw, my dedicated GPU memory is getting fully loaded, straight away, with only ONE SINGLE file!

I have just biulded brand new PC:

* Intel i7 13700KF

* Gigabyte Aorus Z690

* 32Gb DDR5 6000Mhz

* Samsung 980 Pro SSD

* Nvidia RTX 3060 Ti

- Windows 11 22H2 (all updates are installed)

- Photoshop 2023 (24.2.1)

- Camera Raw 15.2

- latest Nvidia Studio driver 531.41

 

My question is - what kind of graphic card do I need to process my single files from Canon EOS R (30 Mpix)? Is RTX 3060Ti 8Gb not enough for Adobe Photoshop?

I also tried to install older versions of Camera Raw (14.5, 13.1 and so), tried to instal Photoshop 2022, 2021, but nothing works - my dedicated GPU memory is getting fully loaded.

Furthermore, after couple of times using Camera Raw the window popping up "your GPU running out of memory", and all windows are getting crashed.

My previous old PC from 2017 (i7 7700K, 32Gb DDR4, AMD Firepro W7000) was working fine and smooth, no issues at all! I was hoping to get better performance with my new build, but have got only headache. Instead of processing my RAW files, I am struggling with PC third day in a row, and have no clue what do do...

What kind of graphic card do I need to smoothly run Camera Raw 15.2?

Thank you!

Brainiac
August 20, 2022

I was using an RTX 1060 6GB card that a friend lent to me after he upgraded to an RTX 3070 6GB card (not at Ti). I had all the GPU options checked manually in Preferences.

 

I recently purchased my own RTX 3060 12GB card (ASUS Phoenix Geforce RTX 3060 12GB V2) and saw a noticeable improvement.

 

My friend also uses LrC and we compared his RTX 3070 to my RTX 3060 for Super Resolution. Surprisingly, we found his was fractionally slower, but not enough to be significant. There could be other factors at play in this simple test.

 

I did a test on my PC and exported 97 NEF files. It took 58 sec to complete the operation.

 

If you enable the 'Use GPU for Export' option using the Custom (manual) setting in Preferences and do a similar test with your RTX 2060 6GB card, which should give you some information to compare with.

 

The RTX 3060 seems to be very good value for cost vs performance. The performance benefit of the RTX 3070 Ti for use with LrC may be small and not worth the extra cost. For gamers, the RTX 3070 Ti might give a performance edge, but maybe not so much for LrC/Ps.

 

I'm very pleased with my RTX 3060 and when idling, its temperature stays at around 24C, whilst the RTX 1060 idled at around 48C.

GoldingD
Brainiac
August 19, 2022
I meant only using GPU VRam and not GPU Full acceleration in first post.

Unless the preferences option for using that GPU is enabled, AND that extra option to use it for eports is enabled, then more VRAM will not matter one bit. LrC does not use any VRAM unless those options are on.

(DdeGannes, am I off on that statement?)

Known Participant
August 20, 2022

LOL not everyone is very dumb. i know those things

GoldingD
Brainiac
August 19, 2022

See:

https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-classic/kb/lightroom-gpu-faq.html

In that link, look at "How do I determine if Lightroom Classic is accessing the graphics card"

Note the box "Use GPU for Export"

 

Sounds like that box is not checked. (not sure if unchecked is default)

 

 

Known Participant
August 19, 2022

this is not even related to what I asked for...

GoldingD
Brainiac
August 19, 2022

You clearly stated

 

"As I see Lightroom is only using the ram memory i think the cheaper RTX 3060 would be a better choice for speed up my export time?"

 

So why is LrC not using the VRAM in export? How is not checking preferences not related? Did you look at that preference setting?

 

A RTX 2060 with 6Gb is more than enough. The 6Gb of VRAM is not the issue, LrC should take advantage with as little as 2Gb (but not less than that). But if you want a new GPU, start with the maximum VRAM over other considerations, If replacing, I would not go with less than 8Gb. And keep other Develop module process in mind, not just export. (not to mention PS GPU usage if you use PS)