Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
So far not too many issues, I am persoanlly not noticing a time lag as comapred with PS genrative fill. I would likely be using this feauture primarily for removing rather than replacing though it would perhaps be beneficial to have a subtract or add feauture as in photoshop which directs the attention of the AI more precidely. I can see an advanced feature allowing for specific replacement of objects through text prompts to be very useful here. Some glitches I've come into thus far, replacing lines (wires/telephone lines, not replacing all the wires, leaving bits of wire in the frame) replacing uniterrupted patterns (ie. fence post/barrier, replacing most of the fence post but then adding what it thinks a fence post might have like a construction sign or industrial looking object) and occassionally removing people (replacing person with an AI genrated person rather than removing the person altogether) For many of these glitches I was able to simply go over the area with the spot tool to refine the desired replacement with fairly good success but other images it feels more difficult to get the replacement to work correctly. Including images below as example where the AI genrative fill wants to replace rather than remove object and this particular example doesn't feel easy to resolve.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
If the original was cropped, then the resulting image will contain odd items. Therefore, Generative Remove must be carried out before cropping. The same applies to denosie and local AI edits.
Assuming that it's not cropped, and looking at your results, I suspect that you've been a tad precise with your selection/mask. Attached is what I achieved with a fairly rough selection/mask.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This also appears to apply to images with profile corrections that have pushed image content off the viewport.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This latest update seems to have critically injured the original, non-generative Heal and Clone tools. They are at least 4x slower to respond, and worse, they cannot be finely adjusted once used. Any relocating of the sample/target areas can only be made in large distances (I'm estimating 15px or more). Trying to align these areas along any kind of edge in an image is now impossible!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm not seeing this. Are you Mac or Windows? How are you moving them (e.g. mouse, pen, keyboard)?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I am using Windows and trying to drag sample/target areas of the heal and clone tools with a trackball mouse zoomed in 100x-300x. Prior to this update, things could be relocated to the pixel level, but now (no matter how long I click and hold) they only move in jumps of ~15px.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
As far as I used it its made its job.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Oh my goodness, I am LOVING AI in LR. It is saving me time from going between LRC and PS. THANK YOU ADOBE!!!!!!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
GGenetative remove on lightroom classic puts something else where I want to remove
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Overall it's a great Job. An improvement area I can see is related to the noise / texture of the replaced area that does not match to the neigboring and let guess the replaced area especially in concert photography where lighting is not the best. I can provide samples if needed.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
super. bravo
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi!
Just started using it, still exploring, it helps, but a bit slow and not as "spot healing from Photoshop " , But we testing 🙂 and its new feature
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
A expansão Generativa já esta bem aceita no PS, trabalho muito com fundo infinito e muitas das vezes preciso aumentar o tamanho do mesmo, falta a função para aumentar o tamanho da fotografia no LR!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Il faudrait ajouter une option nous permettant de vous envoyer des rapports avant/après pour vous signalez quand ça ne fonctionne pas du tout par exemple ici
Original
:
Ce n'est pas exploitable aujourd'hui.
Firefly in LrC
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Generally, in my LRC, Generative Remove has been very good with solid objects. But the attached instance of removing a wire against an art nouveau building had much difficulty with the building decoration. It did not seem to be able to handle a reflection of the shape of the window arch detail or similar. I included before and after screen shots for comparison. I imagine is this not trivial but there should be a generalizable rule that could be observed to at least get the shapes to be correct if not the detail. Also, at 200%, it is very obvious that the replaced content is soft and melty vs. the hard edges that appear all around it.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Un bel outil que je viens de tester et vraiment réactif. Il me tarde déjà de pouvoir l'utiliser et gagner du temps.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Good first step but needs improved feathering/transition between the filled area and the rest of the image, and better at matching noise. See attached images
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I experienced same behavior in concert photography, and also reported it
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It would be very useful to be able to mark another area of the photo to indicate the type of object to be generated.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
When i use the new feature, it dosen´t work. The progess bar comes to the end, but nothing happen or the progess bar stuck at 3/4 of the way.
The object will not be removed. As in the picture, you can wait for minutes, but nothing will happen.
I use windows, maybe its a thing on windows?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Yes, that´s the same problem I also have. I hope it can be fixed. It works on Photoship though!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I've tried the Generative remove on a couple of images with vastley differing results. One was a cow in a foggy field and the result was excellent. The cow was replaced by a perfect looking fill of grass, fog and sky. In the second I tried to remove my black cat from the grey floor. First variation replaced most of the space with a light cat, second with a black dog and the third was a grey roll of felt I think. Not sure why a remove function seems to replace on occasions, especially with just a different animal. Promising though based on my first image results.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I forgot to mention, this was using Lightroom Classic 13.3.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Poderia ser possível fazer ajustes na IA gerada, como por exemplo adicionar ruído.
Algumas fotos com ISO alto a parte gerada com IA fica muito "cremosa", deixando a foto irreal.