P: Lightroom Classic>Edit in PS: Long Delay+Erroneous Error Message opening Ps Beta 2024 25.0

[crysania4]

I just recently updated Photoshop Beta to 2024 v25.0 on my Windows 11 machine.

Now when I try to open photos from LR 12.4 using the "edit in...", it hangs up for a time and then comes up saying "The file could not be edited because Adobe Photoshop 2024 could not be launched."

When I hit "Ok" it then opens the file in Photoshop 2024. 

This happens with every file, even if Photoshop 2024 is already up and running at the time. 

This does not happen with 2023 v24.7.

[Xnybor]

Hi there,

I'm having issues opening images in Photoshop through Lightroom. I usually do a base edit coat in Lightroom then retouch/colour grade in Photoshop. For some reason, it stopped working when I select "edit in Photoshop". I've done everything previous forums/adobe support help including un-installing Photoshop Beta. All apps are up-to-date, this issue has gone on for a week and is significantly extending my workflow time which isn't helpful when I've got client deadlines.

As a full-time photographer, it is vital this issue is fixed asap.

I use Mac which is also up-to-date. 

Thank you for looking into this 🙂 

❤️

[Xnybor]

To clarify - nothing happens when I select edit in lighroom... nothing at all. 😞 

[raymondv79432589]

i solve that problem down load a light version From lightroom Classic 12.4 to 12.2.1 that problem happen when you update your version to 12.4
Adobe need to fix that soon .


hope this information help for you !!

[jean-yvesp39872345]

Bonjour,

J’ai eu ce problème avec la version 24.7 LRC, je l’ai désinstallé pour remettre la version 24,6 et c’est Ok.

Y a un bug sur la version 24,7

Cordialement

[defaulthtpnvclh5tgh]

This happens pretty consistently with Photoshop beta, but not regular Photoshop.  I select a photo, select "Edit in", then select "Edit in Photoshop (beta)..."

Photoshop beta opens, but does not load the photo.  Nothing seems to happen.  After a minute or two, Lightroom gives one of two errors (attached), and then, only after the error, Photoshop loads the photos.  

[james22832949j3gn]

Hello all. This is my first time of posting.

I am trying to stack an image of the moon in photoshop to align and blend the layers. There are 7 images. Normally selecting all the images from the develop or library workflow, right click, edit in, open in layers in photoshop, works.  For some reason this is not the case tonight.

If photoshop is closed, the app in triggered and opens but only the 'opening screen' is open. It doesn't then switch to the 'editing side' of photshop and load the layers. If the app is already open my windows just switch to photshop and nothing else happens. I have tried with another image opened but this does not work.

I am using cc2023 and according to adobe cloud everything is up to date. I have beta installed as well. It has worked in the past with both CC23 and Beta installed. I am on a mac running Ventura 13.4.1. Photoshop 24.7.0. Lightroom release 12.4. 

Many thanks in advance

[jack cp55727805]

I have the same problem. I also tried to open in Ps Beta and it would not open. Then I ran CleanMyMac to free up RAM and disk space. It still won't open. Has anyone reached out to Adobe to find out what is going on?

[jack cp55727805]

I CAN drop the LR photo directly into PS and it works. Just the 'Edit In' does not work.

[johng37670939]

That seems to make sense

[markusnuetzi]

Hallo zusammen

Bei mir kommt seit geraumer Zeit folgende Meldung, wenn ich ein Foto aus LrC in der Beta Version von Photoshop öffnen möchte. "Die Datei konnte nicht bearbeitet werden, da Adobe Photoshop (Beta) nicht gestartet werden konnte". Es dauert jeweils 1-2 Minuten bis diese Meldung erscheint. Dies obwohl Photoshop Beta geöffnet ist. Wenn ich dann auf ok klicke bei der Fehlermeldung, wird das Bild in Photoshop Beta geöffnet.

Ich verwende einen Mac Monterey 12.6.8. Von Adobe ist alles auf dem neusten Stand.

[pascal154A]

since the last update I can no longer edit to PS from LRc, photo does not go to PS.

PS does open but no photo? I do not receive an error message?

If I select edit in -> open as smart object. Yes then it will work and the photo goes to PS. But if I then save from PS, photo will no longer automatically enter LRc but I have to sync the folder before I see it!

[sarahr16569516]

I have this same issue with the same error message. I can open a single image after clicking OK on the error message.  However, there seems to be no way to open images as layers which is fundamental to my current project.  I have rolled back to the version of Photoshop recommended and rebooted my computer, but the problem persists.  A Photography Plan is not cheap so a solution is urgently needed.  I absolutely hate that there is no way to communicate directly with Adobe on this.

[howintheworld]

I hope Adobe will communicate and let us know when the fix is ready. 

[Branko Teršek]

Xnybor! I had the same problems myself until I returned the PS program one version back to 24.6.0. Try it, because I'm on a MAC myself and everything works normally for me now.
l.p.
Branko

[Photocrea]

Depusi 2 mises à jours de ligytroom et photoshop beta 2024, lorsuqe je veux modifier une photo de lightroom à photoshop beta 2024 , c'est des erreurs sur erreur, puis au final quand on pense que cela ne fonctionnera pas eh bien la photo va sur photoshop beta 2024.....  (voir captures ci jointes)

J'ai désinstallé lightroom et photoshop beta 2024 rien y fait toujorus le même soucis, quelqu'un aurait une idée ?

[Branko Teršek]

James! Try rolling back the PS program to version 24.6.0.
Best regards,
Branko

[jean-yvesp39872345]

J’ai eu le même problème qui c’est résolu en revenant sur la version précédente de Lcr

Envoyé de mon iPhone

[GiacomoFPH]

We're in months later and at least 2 updates from about 18 pages ago when I posted, and it's still there. Wow. WTF Adobe?

[AxelMatt]

@GiacomoFPH 

The bug deceibed in this thread came with Beta version 25.0 and this was released 3 weeks ago.

In the meantime the are no new updates for the Beta version. 

This problem does not affect the normal Photoshop 2023 version.

We have to be patient until Adobe fixed the problem. 

[james22832949j3gn]

Thanks for your reply. I have tried using cc23 and not beta and it's not working. Does this mean I need to uninstall beta?

Thanks

Sent from Samsung Mobile on O2
Sent from Outlook for Android<>

[johng37670939]

I uninstalled it from my laptop and only use it on my desktop. So I do all my work betweeen LrC and PS on the laptop and special edits on the desktop. For me its the safest route.

[AxelMatt]

@james22832949j3gn  Try to uninstall the Beta and then reinstall your Photoshop 2023 version 

[jean-yvesp39872345]

Y a un bug avec la version LRC 24.7 revenir à la version 24.6.

Envoyé de mon iPhone

[wesleyg42611087]

Can not open photoshop from lightroom. Completely uninstalled PS But the BETA version stays and there is no uninstall or a way to go back to a previous version. If I goto all apps in Creative cloud desktop it doesn't even show up but if I go to updates it is there.

[KLPhotography1287495703]

I am having this same issue and have tried multiple solutions based on other forums and nothing is working and it's very frustrating