P: Export As does not support Actions or scripting

[Leonavr]

There is no way to record an action so that I can automate Export As dialogue box. What I want to do is to record an action which will save one image in three formats via the Export As dialogue box and the action should remember the settings i input for each dimension. Previously Save for Web did this, but now you are calling it legacy so i expect Export As to be accessible same way via actions as Save for Web was. Thank you.

[megaflowgraphics]

Hi. From the research I've done this morning it seems that there is no way to use Export As in an Action.

Is this correct?

And if so does Adobe have any plans to fix it? Seems like a pretty big hole in functionality.

Thanks,

-Patrick

[Bojan Živković]

It is not possible to record step with Export As. Use legacy Save for Web instead. You can add your voice here Photoshop CC 2015: Export As does not support Actions and does not react to them | Photoshop Family ...

[macpawel]

You can also use Save as copy command and Image size to prepare some different sizes

[megaflowgraphics]

Thanks for the confirmation and the tips, folks! What a very strange thing for them to leave out of Actions for several years. And yes, I had to use Save for Web, which works, though it would be good to be able to use the more current feature.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Still want this fixed please Adobe 🙂

[TOJWind2020]

Hello

I am trying to create an action to open an EPS and then save the file in PNG format.  I press record and the OPEN action records then ...

• I go to File >Export >Quick Export as PNG .....  and when the file is saved no action is recorded?
• If I go to File>Save As> select JPG ....  this action gets recorded.
• If I go to File>Export As> (I fill in everything that I want...) and select Export...  No action is recorded.  
• If I go to File > Export > Save for Web > Fill in what I want...  this action gets recorded.

When I run and specify the source and destination folders the files are opened and closed but nothing is saved????   Help  🙂

[Stephen_A_Marsh]

As you have discovered, Adobe does not yet support the "new" Export options within actions (or scripts), so you need to stick with using Save As or Export > Save for Web (Legacy).

[Klaas vT]

The solution is to use Save As -> Jpeg. You get all the same options and they all record into the action.

Of course it would be better for Adobe to add recording of the Export As fuction, utterly dumb that it does not work.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

It is a TERRIBLE problem that Export As is not Actionable. Please prioritize and fix. 

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

I add my loud voice to getting this fixed and implemented. 

Now, I have to do this the manual, tedious and stupid way -- without Actions. 

[Klaas vT]

You can add a "save as" to your action, it works the same as long as you convert the image to 8 bit first (both those commands can be recorded into your action.

[nutmix5]

I have to change and save hundreds of images, so I have made an action to do everything except it wont record the final step - to export as a low res jpeg.  What is the point of actions if there is no way to save your work?

Is there some sort of work around for this major missing feature?  I.e. any way to automate the final saving of the modified file as a jpeg with 70% quality and 250x250 res etc?

[Stephen_A_Marsh]

I don't see this as a fault of actions, they are have been around since Photoshop v4. I see it as a design issue with the "new" Export As/Quick Export options that were introduced as a modern alternative to the legacy Export Save for Web engine that is based on the old ImageReady engine. Export As/Quick Export are also unavailable to scripting. The "new" export settings don't support animated GIF files and are missing many other features as found in the old Save for Web. The "new" export engine is great with Generator and Image Assets though... Horses for courses!

You have to either use Save As or Save for Web... Or use a script such as Image Processor or Image Processor Pro which handles the file format options and saving while using the action.

[getho]

I was just reading how export as gave better results than save for web, so thought I'd update my 10 year old export actions to find that not only does is not work but that it hasn't for 5 years.  

[Earth Oliver]

Jeff, it's now 5 years later and we still can't put Export As in an action... /sadface.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Is there any update on if or when this will be added to Photoshop? I have just tried to export my layers to 1000x1000 canvas size using Export As and create and action but noticed it doesn't work!

I also read through these comments and many people suggested using Image Processor Pro but that doesn't allow me to resize the images to a 1:1 ratio.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Same problem. My experience of Export is that it is never saved in the action list (like everything else is and should be), just ignored while other actions are progressively added to the list when recording. Save as is not an alternative option to use, as it creates a lot of dialog boxes that freeze everything while playing the action, ruining the whole automation process.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

Removing this ability was an obvious error on Adobe's part, but also obvious after 5 years is that they have no intention of fixing their error. 

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

The "Default Actions" are the only set available by default (duh) and they are almost useless, to me at least.

[bartonlew]

I am having two problems:

1.  I wanted to wite an Action using Export As.  It is not being recorded in the Action.. The Action is:

a.  Flatten Image

b.  Fit Image 

c. Export As 

d.  Close without saving.

As shown in the screenshot below, the last Action in the list (selected) shows the "Export As" step I recorded does not show up, and the file is not saved in the destination folder.  

2.  As a workaround I tried to export the image using Save for Web (Legacy), but first without writing an Action.  I find that this is resulting in an image which is always 8192 px wide for any image I choose, despite resizing the image using Fit Image with different values.  See 2nd screenshot.  Why is this happening?  Thanks for your help in advance. 

[Bojan Živković]

I can not reproduce this problem with latest Photoshop on Win 10. Can you try with Preference reset? Save any unsaved action and preset before reseting prefs.

Update: it seems @D Fosse is right. On your screenshot original image dimensions are 12401 x 8700px what is large for Save for Web. Try value below 8000px in Fit Image and test again. Do you always use huge images when testing with Fit Image? If your intend is print then use Save a Copy because all web based exports in Photoshop are limited to certain number of pixels. If you are trying to use 12000px on web then think one more time.

[D Fosse]

Use Save As, or Save A Copy.

8192 pixels is the size limit in Save for Web. Export and Save for Web are intended for making small simple images for web/screen/mobile devices. They are not designed to handle these big file sizes.

The inability to action Export is a real problem, however, and one that has been raised many times. It is my understanding that the whole Export module is currently rewritten and expanded, so hopefully this and other shortcomings are soon history.

[Kukurykus]

You can record 'Quick export' if you previously tick 'Export files to an assets folder next to the current document' of 'Quick Export Location' and 'Use legacy "Export as"' of 'Options' in 'Export' 'Preferences'.

[J453]

Export As doesn't support actions, yet. Add your vote here: Export As does not support Actions or scripting

[bartonlew]

Good to know about this option, thanks.  However, it appears that it saves a file to its own folder.  If you are writing an Action to perform on many files and want them all in one folder, I don't think it works.  Please correct me if I'm wrong, but I didn't see a workaround.