Addressing Limits on Proxy Workflow - "Modify" clip command

[Remote Index]

The Adobe Premiere Pro "Workflow Guide for Long Form and Episodic Post Production” (dated 2022) states on page 55:

"If your workflow relies on modifying the source clips using any of the following commands [Modify Audio Channels, Interpret Footage, Modify Timecode, Modify Captions], do not use proxies in Premiere Pro. Doing so will result in unexpected behavior."

First, I will note that this warning is not included in the online user guide under the various appropriate sections on these commands.

Modify - Audio Channels (I've written about this poor documentation here )

Modify - Interpret Footage 

Modify - Timecode 

Modify - Captions (no documentation exists?)

If there are limitations on a function, it should be noted in the documentation, directly where users are looking to understand how a command or function works and how to use it.

Second, can Adobe provide an update on these limitations to its Proxy workflow? Have the problems / unexpected behaviours been addressed? Can we expect Proxy workflow to be less limited in future?

R.

[Kevin-Monahan]

Hi, Remote Index,

Thanks again for the message. I will pass along the issue to the docs team. I agree that documentation needs to be consistent across various platforms, including exceptional cases like this guide. If not, that's a problem as you pointed out.

Thanks,
Kevin

[R Neil Haugen]

You're right the User Guide pdf they have doesn't get into use cases and potential issues. Which is a great pain.

I can give some information on part of the question you have. Interpret Footage when used for speed changes. Which for some cases is the wrong tool. The other tool, Speed/Duration, does work with proxies.

From talking with the devs at NAB, Intepret Footage for time changes, was apparently meant and built for 'cadence' changes ... going from say 23.976 to 29.97 or something like that. Where "pull-down" and such things are involved I would guess.

Many users use "Interpret Footage" for other types of time changes ... such as doing slo-mo with high framerate media.

If you need to change the time for slo-mo work, or doing a quickie speed-up, they say to use Speed/Duration instead. You need to know the percentage change, but then I've been told by a number of users that's easily found in an online search if you don't want to do the math.

And Speed/Duration changes do work with proxies, always have, without issue.

Neil

[Remote Index]

R Neil Haugen, thanks for your thoughts.

"Intepret Footage for time changes, was apparently meant and built for 'cadence' changes ... going from say 23.976 to 29.97 or something like that. Where "pull-down" and such things are involved I would guess."

This is a lateral idea you've presented, but nothing in the interperet footage function addresses cadences (since cadences are only important in something like 23.976 in 29.97 media where one frequency has to be represented inside another).

Interpret footage changes the way the "native framerate" of the footage is understood by PPro and will not introduce cadences if, for example, 23.976 footage is placed in a 29.97 timeline.

If I'm wrong about any of that, please correct me.

"If you need to change the time for slo-mo work, or doing a quickie speed-up, they say to use Speed/Duration instead."

Who is "they"? Where do they say it?

Adobe says this: Scroll to the bottom ... 

(Spoiler: nothing about favoured, depricated, or discouraged use cases.)

R.

[R Neil Haugen]

"Who is 'they'? Who says it?"

The devs. And it's also covered in the docs I link below as well. And several times a dev has been on the forum here explaining the difference between Interpret Footage and Speed/Duration.

I'm not a code warrior, ain't no way I can explain it. But you can use Speed/Duration and proxies without any troubles.

It's just ... as noted ... one of numerous use-case things that isn't spelled out in details in the main user pdf. Unfortunately.

Neil

Adobe Long-form and Episodic Best Practices Guide 

Jarle’s blog expansion of the pdf Multicam section: Premiere Pro Multicam

[Remote Index]

R Neil Haugen,

Thanks for the follow up. The references you've posted do not offer any insight or elaboration of the differences between Interpret Footage and Speed effects.

"Adobe Long-form and Episodic Best Practices Guide [Adobe]"

I've been going through this document - the only reference to "Interpret Footage" in the entire 140 page document is the one I've quoted above, which began this thread.

"Jarle’s blog expansion of the pdf Multicam section: Premiere Pro Multi-Cam [PremierePro.net]"

A search of this article for "speed" and/or "interpret" returns zero hits. It appears to be about multi-cam workflows.

"And several times a dev has been on the forum here explaining the difference between Interpret Footage and Speed/Duration. ... one of numerous use-case things that isn't spelled out in details in the main user pdf. Unfortunately."

I don't doubt you, I just prefer documentation to hearsay (for all the usual reasons).

R.

[R Neil Haugen]

Devs comments here and at NAB would not be normally considered "hearsay" ... my bad about those links, I thought it was also covered there ... here's a section from their Best Practices doc ... the chapter on Proxies use, including full descriptions of making them, some limitations & etc ... this bit covers your specific question though.

Additional Considerations When Using Proxies in Premiere Pro

Modifying Clips (Audio Channels, Interpret Footage, etc�)

If your workflow relies on modifying the source clips using any of the following commands, do not use proxies in Premiere Pro. Doing so will result in unexpected behavior:

• Modify > Audio Channels
• Modify > Interpret Footages
• Modify > Timecode
• Modify > Captions

[Remote Index]

R Neil Haugen, thanks again.

I think most people would consider unspecified comments by unspecified people as hearsay. But we can agree to disagree about that.

You've quoted the same thing that I started this thread with.

R.

[R Neil Haugen]

What, dealing with Adobe documentation gets circular at times?   😉

My bad ... but remember, I'm just trying to help understand how the blame things actually function as another user. I've been pushing for better documentations ... for ever ...

[Remote Index]

Your frustration and intention are appreciated. R.