Exit
  • Global community
    • Language:
      • Deutsch
      • English
      • Español
      • Français
      • Português
  • 日本語コミュニティ
  • 한국 커뮤니티
1

Replace With Clip > From Source Monitor - Match Frame - not matching frame

Explorer ,
Apr 23, 2025 Apr 23, 2025

I've done some audio repair on a video clip that has already been edited into multiple sequences. I could open up each sequence 1 by 1 and select the clip, hit in point, copy the in point and paste it into the revised copy of the audio and then alt drag it or hit replace with clip, however, that would take forever with how many cuts there are from the source.
So instead, I made a sequence that has the original video with the revised audio paired to it. All settings match the original source clip, timecode most importantly. I hit the Replace With Clip > From Source Monitor - Match Frame, and to my surprise, it does not match frame. Sometimes it shoots out an error, "The source clip lacks sufficient head material to match to the desired frame." And other times it does replace the media, but totally ignoring the match frame part and just replaces it at the first frame of the video.

I've tried multiple different work arounds such as making it into a mutlicam sequence, experimenting with how many audio tracks are in the multicam sequence (which strangely enough was changing the timing of the replace clip, and did accurately replace all the clips once! but never again) Seemed like everytime I deleted another track, the timing would shift slightly.

I'm sure I could just rerender the source footage with the revised audio and replace it, but these are very large files and that would take a lot of extra rendering time that I don't have right now. Regardless of that, it should work as a nested sequence, just as a precomp would in After Effects. I have no clue why Premiere can not handle this, and it seems others have experienced this over the years with no real answer or fix.

I have been loosing my head on this one. In AE its as simple as "replace with precomp" if you want to change the source and having it update in all instances of the used clip, but in premiere there is no way and match frame replace is the closest option, but it appears to be bugged.

Bug Unresolved
TOPICS
Editing and Playback , Import and ingest , Performance or Stability , Sound , User experience or interface
433
Translate
Report
Community guidelines
Be kind and respectful, give credit to the original source of content, and search for duplicates before posting. Learn more
community guidelines
3 Comments
Community Expert ,
Apr 23, 2025 Apr 23, 2025

Is the clip in the source monitor with the source monitor's timeline indicator over the frame?

Translate
Report
Explorer ,
Apr 23, 2025 Apr 23, 2025

@RobShultz I'm not sure what you are asking.
In the source monitor I have a multicam sequence (tried normal sequence as well) that contains the original source footage paired with the revised audio.
The revised sequence in the source monitor is the same frame rate, same length, and same time code as the original source footage.

Translate
Report
Explorer ,
Apr 23, 2025 Apr 23, 2025
LATEST

to add on further, when I replace, if it does make a new in-point besides the start of the video, The amount it is off by is not consistant.
First clip:
Source clip in point: 03:43:45:22
Preview monitor match frame in point premiere assigned: 03:44:07:21

Next clip:
Source: 03:44:08:01
Replaced with: 03:44:07:21

Following clip:
Source: 03:44:12:16
Replaced: 03:44:07:21

Translate
Report