Help with understanding the reason or qality rejection

[Vladislav_Aleksejev-N9091]

Asking community for help to understand the quality issues of some of the rejected photos. Thank you in advance!

[Abambo]

...299: 

1) artefacts

2) noise

3) get rid of those reflections

4) blown out - try to shield high reflective surfaces. 

In addition I think that you have clipping in the blues. 

[Vladislav_Aleksejev-N9091]

Hmm, thanks.
Interesting that similar photo like this were accepted: 

 

[Abambo]

Sure, maybe a different moderator, maybe less reflection on the tube, maybe no clipping of the colour, maybe less noise, maybe no artefacts.

I would have edited out or weakened the reflection on the colour (but most probably: I would have made the effort to shield the colour from the light source by using a reflector or similar. 

[Vladislav_Aleksejev-N9091]

Clear, thank you!
Do you think it is worth to resubmit the photo, or it will be automatically rejected by stock anyway?

[Abambo]

This is definitely a quality issue: 

[Jill_C]

DOF is too shallow. Little, if anything is in focus.