I do see the advantage of virtual albums or cataloges, but also the disadvantage: If the program crashes or if I am not happy with prices or poor developments in future, I loose all my information put in the cataloge when I move to another program. Not if you 'write metadata to files'. The second problem is: If I have a folder with all pictures and a subfolder with the nice ones and a subfolder with the ones with trees etc., how do I get this Information into the Organizer? The answer is in the way you can assign keywords (tags) to all files in a folder or simply in selected files in a single step. You can also use albums ('collections' in older Elements versions or Lightroom). The second problem is: If I have a folder with all pictures and a subfolder with the nice ones and a subfolder with the ones with trees etc., how do I get this Information into the Organizer? It would be great to have the option to import them, automatically recognize duplicates and assist in removing from disk, but preserving the information (like in tags, ratings, etc.). In the organizer, just like in Lightroom, 'import' may be confusing: it is not a synonym of 'download'. When you 'get' pictures, they may be downloaded from a camera or card reader (implies downloading, copying) or you may simply register, index the information, location of the file and exif data, tags, ratings, captions, notes... You can include a given physical files in several 'albums' for several purposes. That does not duplicate the file on the drive. That keeps the latest state of info available for each use of the file, which is not the case when you duplicate (copy) physical files. Remember that you are free to also 'write metadata to files', which is used to make the information available to other softwares or simply as a redundant safety. I fear, Adobe lost me as a customer ;-(. That' your choice, you can choose a browser instead of a catalog organizing software. For instance Adobe Bridge ... (yes you dont need to subscribe to the Cloud for that). I am not sure you have considered my previous answers: If you really want to fool the organizer to create duplicates, export the copies elsewhere using a different jpeg compression. They won't be recognized as duplicates since their size will different. That will keep the metadata if 'you write metadata...' You can import folder by folder (each imported folder with its children subfolders).
... View more