Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi everyone,
What's going on with Illustrator that adds so many anchor points when you expand/outline a path? This is the result I used to get before and then how it behaves now. Why does it need so many ancho points for a simple circle?
It does it with all the shapes regardless of how simple they are, like 6 for a triangle now?
that's weird indeed, but I did notice your shape is rather large, so digging a little I was finally able to replicate your problem
expanding a 425 pt diameter circle = 4 points
expanding a 426 pt diameter circle = a few more points
expanding larger circles = more points
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi @Piter1288, that's really weird! I'm not able to reproduce that though (MacOS AI v26.0.2).
Are you working with a simple appearance? For testing purposes, please press D for default appearance and choose Object > Path > Outline stroke. Does that give too many points also?
- Mark
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Well, that's even worse:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Weird, but why is the circle red? When I press D it sets fill to White and Stroke to Black. Is your default different?
- Mark
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I did change the color before creating the circle so the anchor points will highlight better, I posted a little video about what I did.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
that's weird indeed, but I did notice your shape is rather large, so digging a little I was finally able to replicate your problem
expanding a 425 pt diameter circle = 4 points
expanding a 426 pt diameter circle = a few more points
expanding larger circles = more points
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Good detective work Carlos! I can confirm the same on my system. I wonder what the reason is. I did notice there is a 1.5pt difference in the shape of the curve when comparing a 10,000pt expanded circle with a 10pt expanded circle scaled up to 10,000pt (it keeps the normal 4 points). So very minor. Interesting.
- Mark
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
>>I wonder what the reason is.
It did the same on my second test on a 4K video profile. I suspect it is to maintain the integrity of the shape.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
And we have a winner! Yes, that reason, I checked that it does this if the circle is higher than 300 x 300 px. Here's a comparison between a 100 px vs a 500 px:
Now it surprises that the handlers cannot reach higher and it needs to add up to 30 anchor points to keep the shape.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi Mark, I did notice scaling a small circle up doesn't add more anchor points. I have no idea what's going on.
About size difference, there's another related thread. A user reported that rotating a circle changed its dimensions. The issue could be related to the "circles not being real circles but Bezier approximations" discussion.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Now, regardless of the size, if your circle is in rotation you will end up with extra points as well. These are less than 100 px circles:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm getting the same results as Mark. I'm on Windows 11.
can you describe what you're doing exactly to try to replicate it?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Here's a video of the the proceeding for both expand and outline stroke:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm at a loss. Anything unusual show up in the appearance panel? Running a beta version of Illustrator? Done a restart? Sorry.
- Mark
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is my appearance panel:
I'm not on any beta version, yes, I did restart my computer, plus I don't use any type of extension that could be messing things up.
Does AI have any clear cache function? It's the only thing that I can think of. What I'm 100% sure is that it didn't happen before, cause it would've caught my attention for sure.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
What keyboard command are you doing to display the anchor points? I don't see you switching tools and want to confirm your method.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi David! I use Windows, so just hit on the Ctrl key to display them.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
What keyboard command are you doing to display the anchor points? I don't see you switching tools and want to confirm your method.
By @Creamer Training
David, maybe this setting is on