P: No photos in selected folder (Mac)

[julief57036690]

I have over 60,000 images on an external hard drive.  Today when I opened Lightroom and tried to navigate to a recent image using the Navigator Panel, the folders and subfolders are all showing the numbers of photos inside the folder, but when I click on a subfolder it says "No photos in the selected Folder".  When I check the Finder they are there.  If I go to the highest level of parent folder on that external drive all 60,000 images are showing at that level and I can scroll through them.  But when I drill down to any lower level that the very highest, they are not there.  I have not done any moving of files or folders in the last several months and up until today everything was working fine.  I have not installed any new plugins or done anything out of the ordinary with Lightroom recently.  Any idea why this is happening and more importantly how I can fix it?  I've included a couple of screenshots to show what I'm talking about.

[Abigail28583633n332]

Thanks, Sean. I will try this tomorrow when my brain is more in gear.


Sent from my iPad
Abigail Gossage
abigail@abigailgossage.ca

[sophiet75370090]

Hi!

Glad I'm not alone on my island! I have the same problem. 50,000 picts, "No pictures in the selected folder." I recently updated to LR 12.2 and Ventura on my Macbook. Is there a major conflict? I got help to rebuild a catalog on my IMac with all my pictures, but it is not working. LR won't load my pictures and organize them like before. Question: do you use Topaz Sharpen? I noticed all the extensions of my picts are now S instead of LR. Could it mix up Lightroom? What a mess! 

[johnrellis]

@sophiet75370090, try rolling back to LR 12.1 and let us know if the problem goes away.

[JohanElzenga]

MacOS can have two external drives with the same name, because internally it uses a special unique disk identifier. Lightroom uses a simple path to the images however, that starts with the disk name to identify the drive. That means that you should never use Lightroom with two drives with the same name, because that is asking for problems. If you want to move your images to a new drive you can make use of this, by giving the new drive the exact same name as the old drive, but then you must disconnect the old drive or rename it.

[DavePinMinn]

She doesn't think she copied the photos from the old drive to the new one.  And in Lightroom, the old drive has 62,000 images, the new one has 8000, and they don't APPEAR to have images in the same months on both drives.

It doesn't LOOK to me like she copied images.

She doesn't THINK she's EVER had both drives connected at the same time, BUT I suspect she did at SOME point.  Then disconnected the old drive.

• In LrC, the Folders panel shows two volumes named "Gdrive for Photos"

Yes, there are 2 Gdrive for Photos "drives", BUT only the new one is connected.

• One column shows some photos the other none

Both Gdrives show data, but only the new one has had images imported to is since plugging in.  The new drive doesn't appear to have images from the old drive

The ONLY place that could actually SEE images was "Volumes" - it sees all 70,000 images.

There were a couple thousand images with "!" marks - metadata conflicts or mismatches.  I updated all those before creating the new catalog.

NOBODY had/has a question mark - Lightroom doesn't think ANYTHING is missing.

[DavePinMinn]

That's what it looks like she did.  She says the two drives weren't connected at the same time, and they may or may not have been.  What's confusing is she INSISTS things worked normally until she updated Lightroom.

BUT, it SOUNDS like it was a really bad idea to give the two drives the same name and something in Lightroom eventually got confused and quit working...

[QLeif]

Hab das gleiche Problem aber auf MacOS 13.2.1. Betrifft übrigens nur die Fotos auf einer externen HD. Lokale oder Fotos auf Netzlaufwerken sind nicht betroffen.

Für alle Importe nach Update auf LR 12.2 wurden die Bilder nicht mehr unter "/ -> Volumes -> extHD" in die Bibliothek geschrieben sondern direkt unter "extHD" ohne übergeordneten Ordner. Dadurch sind in der Bibliothek einige Ordner nun doppelt, allerdings beide mit nur jeweils einem Teil der Fotos.

Direkt auf der extHD über den Finder ist alles normal. 

Nach Rollback von LR 12.2 auf 12.1 wurden die Fotos in den Ordnern wieder angezeigt. Aber die aufgeteilten Ordner bleiben und lassen sich auch nicht zusammenführen.

[johnrellis]

"After rolling back from LR 12.2 to 12.1, the photos in the folders were displayed again. But the split folders remain and cannot be merged either."

Others have solved that problem using these steps:

https://www.lightroomqueen.com/capitalization-catalog-error/

[JohanElzenga]

"The ONLY place that could actually SEE images was "Volumes" - it sees all 70,000 images."

'Volumes' is actually a folder that Lightroom should not show, because it is the mountpoint for the drives.  Normally I would suggest to right-click on it and choose 'Hide This Parent', but without having seen a screenshot of the folder panel I am hesitant to suggest anything.

[GoldingD]

So, can you connect the old drive, perhaps disconnect the new drive, then look in LrC for the photos.

This before doing anything else.

[johnrellis]

[This post contains formatting and embedded images that don't appear in email. View the post in your Web browser.]

It sounds like a problem many other Mac users are experiencing with the LR 12.2 upgrade. When you select a particular folder, do you see "No photos in selected folder", even though there's a count next to the folder name in the Folders panel?  A screenshot would be worth many more than 1K words, but does it look like this:

with the external drives listed in the Folders panel under Macintosh HD / Volumes?

If not, then please post a full-resolution screenshot showing the entire LR window with the Folders panel open and a folder selected.

If so, then others have reported that rolling back to LR 12.1 avoids the problem.  Adobe has acknowledged this bug:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-bugs/p-catalog-will-open-in-12-1-but-not-12-2-folde... 

Moderators, please don't merge this thread until @DavePinMinn verifies it's the same issue.

[JohanElzenga]

I thought about that too, but I dismissed it because the OP said:

"The ONLY place that could actually SEE images was "Volumes" - it sees all 70,000 images."

[johnrellis]

Many Mac users have reported this problem with LR 12.2, and rolling back to LR 12.1 appears to avoid the issue.

[johnrellis]

Moderators, @Rikk Flohr: Photography, please merge with the existing bug:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-bugs/p-catalog-will-open-in-12-1-but-not-12-2-folde...

[johnrellis]

'I thought about that too, but I dismissed it because the OP said:

"The ONLY place that could actually SEE images was "Volumes" - it sees all 70,000 images."'

That's consistent with what others have reported -- clicking on the folder representing the entire drive displays all the photos on that drive.

[andrel46615190]

Thank you for your suggestion. Can you help me ? I don't know how to merge my thread...

[johnrellis]

The moderators will merge the thread.

[Erzebeth]

I have the same problem as julief57036690.

It al started after updating to 12.2

[JohanElzenga]

Ah, OK. Volumes isn't a drive but the mountpoint, but I guess that may work too. The fact that the OP has two drives with the same name complicates the story, but this could be a coincidence.

[DavePinMinn]

Yes, that's essentially what she's seeing.  I don't know what the title of the topic where this is being discussed is, but it wasn't something I found when searching - likely because my search wasn't using the correct terms.

Has that OTHER discussion provided a solution that doesn't require creating a new catalog?

[Sean McCormack]

It's the link @johnrellis posted if you can check it: 

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-bugs/p-catalog-will-open-in-12-1-but-not-12-2-folde...

[Abigail28583633n332]

I have spent a good part of today trying to ge my folders back together. Updating folder location did not work. Suggestions?

Sent from my iPad
Abigail Gossage
abigail@abigailgossage.ca

[Abigail28583633n332]

Unfortunately this did not work for me.

Sent from my iPad
Abigail Gossage
abigail@abigailgossage.ca

[Erzebeth]

I did a roll back to 12.1 and it worked! I can open all my folders again!

[johnrellis]

@Abigail28583633n332 wrote, "Unfortunately this did not work for me."

What didn't work for you?  (Unfortunately, the mediocre forum platform doesn't indicate which post you're replying to.)

Many people have reported here that rolling back to LR 12.1 works around the problem. Does that work for you?