P: Lightroom Classic>Edit in PS: Long Delay+Erroneous Error Message opening Ps Beta 2024 25.0

[crysania4]

I just recently updated Photoshop Beta to 2024 v25.0 on my Windows 11 machine.

Now when I try to open photos from LR 12.4 using the "edit in...", it hangs up for a time and then comes up saying "The file could not be edited because Adobe Photoshop 2024 could not be launched."

When I hit "Ok" it then opens the file in Photoshop 2024. 

This happens with every file, even if Photoshop 2024 is already up and running at the time. 

This does not happen with 2023 v24.7.

[KW Phua]

I faced the same problem on Mac. After update the Beta.

[Aldenhoven]

When you go back to PS Beta 24.7 does the generative fill still work?

[hugh.letheren]

Yes!

[AxelMatt]

@Aldenhoven  Yes, but only until August 14th. 

Please see here: Upgrade your copy of Photoshop (beta) to version 2... - Adobe Support Community - 13986957

[Robert5EC3]

Last week I updated to Lightroom Classic V12.4. I also updated to the latest Photoshop Beta version.

Since doing these updates I can no longer open my photos from Lightroom directly in Photoshop. I am running these programs on a HP laptop with Windows 11. I previously had no issue with either application.

Since my photos will no longer open in Photoshop from Ligthroom I've lost the ability to close the file in Photoshop and have it reopen in Lightroom. 

I have uninstalled and reinstalled Lightroom Classic and this did nothing to solve the issue. 

In my preferences in Lightroom Classic it only gives me the choice of opening photos in Photoshop 2023 or Photoshop 2024, no mention of Photoshop Beta. However, I found that selecting the Photoshop 2024 option, this is the one that opens Photoshop Beta.

When I select a photo or group of phots to open in Photoshop it starts to open the photos but then stops and does nothing else. 

This issue needs to be corrected as soon as possible.

[hugh.letheren]

Well noted - let's hope Adobe sort out the Lightroom image transfer issue before 143 Augyust. . .

[josep49279892]

Is anyone else having issues opening lightroom files in Photoshop on Mac OSX Ventura? seems to not be working with release build of photoshop or beta as well.

[kglad]

<moved from cc desktop bugs >

[primitivart]

Good evening
I have a problem with LGT release 12.4 ( imac 21 M1)
from lightroom I try to edit in photoshop, before it opened photoshop with the photo to edit, now it opens photoshop but not the photo to edit. what has changed? what should I do ?
before it interacted perfectly and when the work was completed it imported the modified photo as a Tiff copy (preferences) in the LGT catalog

{Moved from Lightroom Cloud to Lightroom Classic Forum and thread title edited by Moderator} 

[Lavie274773185gyy]

Je confirme ce bug sur la version 24.7.0

Obligé de revenir en 24.6.0 pour pouvoir avoir une photo qui s'ouvre en utilisant la commande Modifier dans Photoshop

[Says_Shari]

Having same issue.  Cannot open in Ps 24.7 (not using Beta) from Lr 12.4 using MacOS Ventura 13.2.1.

[Daniel Cilia]

Terry White from Adobe (as always) found a way around the bug!
https://www.youtube.com/live/9zhpDd-reVg?feature=share
and go to minute 15.35. 

[Daniel Cilia]

Terry White from Adobe (as always) found a way around the bug!

https://www.youtube.com/live/9zhpDd-reVg?feature=share
and go to minute 15.35. 

[jeasolar]

Yes it does.

[Nature Light]

This is a reply to Daniel Cilia.  Thanks for the tip and it's very interesting but it does not address my original note that started this humungus thread.  Simply, on a Windows machine, once you install PS Beta, it takes over the "edit in Photoshop" and will not allow one to list both versions of PS in the external editing preferences.  That's all I was looking for and all these other issues are, well, other issues!  It seems with Mac this does not happen but it does with Windows so if anybody has a fix for this, and this only, problem, I'll keep wading through all the other posts hoping to see it.

[Daniel Cilia]

Yes it does happen on a Mac, exactly in hte same way you describe.
Terry White just shows a way around to continue using the last Photoshop versions using the Lightroom edits without having to wait for ages for the file to open up in Photoshop.

[Nature Light]

Daniel, must be another bug because a Colin Smith youtube video using Mac showed him able to switch between Beta and "regular" PS in external editing.  So he has a machine where it works and most other folks it seems do not.  But that's beta!  Thanks.

[jean-christophed18922905]

Same problem for me.

[MárcioMSCruz]

Waiting the bug fixing by Adobe I'm back to version 2023 24.6 wich works fine under MAC Ventura.

[Daniel31521804y3e7]

since the last update of photoshop, if I now choose edit from lightroom --> 
it says photoshop 2024, when I click on it opens photoshop beta, 
but the photo is not loaded. I stay at the welcome screen of photoshop. Anyone have a solution for this?

[jeffreym]

Thanks. I see why it was moved, now.

[danieleg57402106]

Good evening everyone
I can no longer export the files from Lightroom to Photoshop Beta, I am an error that Photosgop cannot open the file. Until a few days ago everything worked correctly. Do you have solutions?
Thank you

[jeffrey.b]

LR > Edit in PS beta > response can't open PS

Quit PS beta and then try again - works sometimes

Tries to load a sequence to LR as layers - nothing happens

[Silko-Ra]

PS 24.7 hängt sich auf wenn RAW / CR2 oder CR3 Datei mit STRG + E  oder über Menü "Bearbeiten in Photoshop von LRc Vers, 12.4 übertragen wird, Gleiches passiert bei Nutzung Beta Vers. 25.6.  Das ganze begann nachdem die PS Vers 24.7 automatisch installiert wurde (Photoshop 2024 ) Es erschein "Willkommen bei Photoshop, Günther" Fenster mit zuletzt geöffneten Fotos..     Wenn ich "Datei Öffnen" nutze und eine RAW Fotodatei öffne geht Camera RAW  auf, nach "Öffnen" Fenster wegen Dokumenten farbe klicke ich OK dann erscheint Warnfenster "der Vorgang konnte nicht ausgeführt werden weil ein Programmfehler aufgetreten ist, Danach kann ich PS nur noch über Taskmanager schließen.   Windows 10,      PS 24.7 deinstalliert, Beta deinstalliert LRc deinstalliert  Neustart PC, PS 24.6 installiert, LRc installiert. Übergabe von LRc nach PS funktioniert nicht, BETA 25.6 installiert Fehler immernoch.  Hier muss dringend nen BUG-Fix her. Muss 200 Fotos mit PS bearbeiten, Zeitdruck   gerne auch Tel. 0049015158765662. Deutsch und Englisch fehlen mir vermutlich einige Vocabeln bzgl Adobe, Conversation fließend. VG Günther Pfalzgarf

[martinl78027992]

Terry White has a workaround that does work.

https://www.youtube.com/live/9zhpDd-reVg?feature=share

When you have finished your lightroom edits the metadata must be saved first so lightroom edits are preserved (ctrl s) Open the version of photoshop you want to edit the file in. Using windows explorer drag the file (with its xmp file if one is present) onto photoshop. After your edits in photoshop are finished and you save the file you will need to synchronize that folder in lightroom for the photo to appear. Lots of extra work, but it does work