P: Lightroom Classic>Edit in PS: Long Delay+Erroneous Error Message opening Ps Beta 2024 25.0

[crysania4]

I just recently updated Photoshop Beta to 2024 v25.0 on my Windows 11 machine.

Now when I try to open photos from LR 12.4 using the "edit in...", it hangs up for a time and then comes up saying "The file could not be edited because Adobe Photoshop 2024 could not be launched."

When I hit "Ok" it then opens the file in Photoshop 2024. 

This happens with every file, even if Photoshop 2024 is already up and running at the time. 

This does not happen with 2023 v24.7.

[Swizzy]

Install the previous version of PS in Adobe Cloud.

[jeasolar]

In the beta forum I learned to revert back one version to 24.7 and then it works to open a photo from lightroom in PS Beta. This will probably get fixed in a more recent update of v25. 

[Estudio31589177ob28]

Cuando trato de editar una fotografia en photoshop beta se tarda mas de 4 a 5 minutos en abrir aparece una ventana de error y al dar clic abre la imagen en photoshop despues de 30 segundos adicionales, todo esto sucedio dedes la ultima actualizacion

[Lo22107488mfi9]

Thanks!

[jeasolar]

I was told to revert Photoshop Beta back a step to v24.7 and that fixed the problem for me. I suppose a newer v25.xyz will probably work someday.

[Ged_Traynor]

@SHAUN D try reporting your issue on the Photoshop (Beta) forum

[garyu64965964]

I had the same problem, I was told by tech support to go back to photoshop beta 24.7.0, this resolved the issue.

Sent from my iPhone

[thoaknek]

The usual Command E prompt to open and image from Lightroom develop module doesnt work. After a delay the program opens the image into Camera Raw instead where pre edits can be completedd before opening into photoshop.

• I cannot opperate the Remove Tool from Photoshop Beta 
• I cannot opperate masking brushes once inside select and mask module. All I get is an Arrow
• Some of the same issues are happiing in Photoshop 2023. Depending if I open photoshop via Lightroom by pressing Command E for an image or whether I open Photoshop 2023 by clicking on the icon from Menu Bar. Either or photoshops when opened in which ever manner will result with the Remove Tool not working or working. Also I do not get my usual plugin apps if I open Photoshop by Command E method (in Lightroom) 

Can you imaging the amount of workarounds this creates for me and the whole day spent on one image. I have never known photoshiop to be so erratic however its never been so full of high tech adjustnents.

Also I will have to cancel trhe pixemperfect addon because it wont acknowledge my subscription on one or more photoshops, the app seems to be glitchy and asks me to deactivate the plug in in My Pi for this computer - Its the only cpmputer I have registered it on. 

Thank you - please fix things asap 

Ken

[Misoqo]

Hello Community.

After making adjustments in Lightroom, I often open my photos in Photoshop. For this I use the "Edit in..." Function by right click on the appropriate picture etc..
Normally, before opening, a selection appears again, whether I want to open the image in the original or a copy and in each case whether with or without Lightroom adjustments.

Since short, however, this way no longer works.

The selection window does not appear anymore. Photoshop opens or the active window changes to Photoshop. Then nothing happens at first. After what feels like a minute, a warning message appears in Lightroom, saying ". The photo cannot be edited in Photoshop because the file xyz cannot be opened".

If I click away this message, the desired file opens in Photoshop.

Meanwhile I found out that this is only the case with RAW formats. In my case ARW and CR2. Tiff can be opened without any problems.

Now I have already uninstalled and reinstalled Lightroom (desktop version) Photoshop Beta and also 2023. Also the RAW extension.

I have searched the internet for solutions, but have not found a real one.

Does anyone have any ideas?

Thanks

--------------

Nach den Anpassungen in Lightroom öffne ich oft meine Fotos in Photoshop. Dazu nutze ich die "Bearbeiten in..." Funktion durch rechts click auf das entsprechende Bild etc.

Normalerweise erscheint nochmal vor dem öffnen eine Auswahl, ob ich das Bild im Original oder eine Kopie öffnen will und jeweils ob mit oder ohne Lightroom Anpassungen.

Seit kurzen funktioniert dieser Weg allerdings nicht mehr. 

Das Auswahl Fenster erscheint nicht mehr. Photoshop öffnet sich bzw das aktive Fenster wechselt zu Photoshop. Dann passiert erstmal nichts weiter. Nach einer gefühlten Minute kommt bei Lightroom ein Warnhinweis, sinngemäß ". Das Foto kann in Photoshop nicht bearbeitet werden da die Datei xyz nicht geöffnet werden kann." 

Klicke ich diese Meldung weg, öffnet sich in Photoshop dann doch die gewünschte Datei.

Mittlerweile habe ich herausgefunden, das dies nur bei RAW Formaten der Fall ist. In meinem Fall ARW und CR2. Tiff lässt sich problemlos öffnen.

Nun habe ich schon Lightroom (Desktop Version) Photoshop Beta und auch 2023 deinstalliert und neu installiert. Auch die RAW Erweiterung. 

Im Internet habe ich nach Lösungen gesucht, allerdings keine echte gefunden.

Hat jemand eine Idee?

Danke

[michael d]

I have the latest updates in Lightroom/Lightroom Classic and Photoshop and Photoshop Beta.

Since the last  updates I seem to have lost the ability to move between L/room and P/shop.

I bring up Edit/Edit in Photoshop but the image does not appear. Photoshop interface comes up but minus the image..This is the same in both Lightroom and Lightroom Classic and Photoshop and Photoshop Beta. Prior to the latest updates it worked fine. I am working with Windows PC 

[JohanElzenga]

There is a known bug with Edit in Photoshop that causes this problem if you also have the Photoshop beta installed.

Please note: the dialog with 'Edit with Lightroom adjustments' etc. never comes up if you send a raw file to Photoshop. That dialog only shows if you send a TIFF/PSD/JPEG from Lightroom to Photoshop, so not getting this dialog for raw files is as designed and has nothing to do with this bug.

[Swizzy]

Go to your Photoshop apps in the Creative Cloud and install one older version of both PS apps by clicking on the 3 little dots.

[dmiller62]

I suddenly started having this problem yesterday, and it continues today, after doing a full restart and also applying this morning's Camera RAW update. Camera RAW is now 15.5 (yesterday it was 15.4.1), Lightroom Classic 12.4, Photoshop 24.7 (Updated 13 days ago), Photoshop Beta 25.0 (Updated 5 days ago)

My strong guess is that the most recent updates to Photoshop broke this. (earlier in the summer, prior to that, I'd been using Edit In without issues on this system). My last "Edit in Photoshop" was done "Last Month" according to the Home view (but no more granularity than that, so I can't tell for sure that this preceded the Photoshop 24.7 update). Typically I'll do this only when printing (I prefer to print from PS vs LRC) so it would have been the last time I printed, which would have preceded the 24.7 update.

Nothing seems to solve it now. It's definitely an issue with RAW files only, because I can Edit In... with other 3rd party apps that require a TIFF intermediary and it generates and then opens the TIFF intermediary without any issues. I was hopeful that the Camera RAW update this morning would fix it (and I also did a full restart) but: no difference.

I'm running my LRC catalog from an external SSD, but there shouldn't be any permissions problems. (I'm running MacOS 12.6.8 on an M1Max, and the SSD mounts on the desktop with "Ignore Ownership" checked. (If "Ignore Ownership" is not checked, LRC has its own problems with the drive and stumbles over generating previews once the catalog initially opens. So it's not "that"). Permissions aren't a problem.

I'm reporting this as a bug; strongly suspect that only the next updates to PS and PSB are going to fix this. I'm an expert and don't see any way to fix this.

Weird and frustrating.

[dmiller62]

Downgrading to PS 24.6 fixed it. (Didn't bother with PSB as it's installed but just for experimenting with Generative Fill).

Sounds like this is a known issue, and that the next updates to both of these will resolve it. (in any case, problem solved well enough for now).

[Branko Teršek]

Hello, I had a problem when I partially process a photo in Laitrum, click on Edit in adobe photo shop 2023, otherwise it opens PS but does not display the photo. Can someone help me fix the problem.
welcome
Branko Teršek

[kglad]

roll back your ps version.

============================

in the future, to find the best place to post your message, use the list here, https://community.adobe.com/

p.s. i don't think the adobe website, and forums in particular, are easy to navigate, so don't spend a lot of time searching that forum list. do your best and we'll move the post if it helps you get responses.

<"moved from using the community">

[Branko Teršek]

Sorry, but I don't fully understand your answer. I am wondering if anyone can help me and where according to you I should look for an answer.

[Harrie_Vugs]

Lightroom Classic-versie: 12.4 [ 202306052221-b70c0975 ]

Windows 10 - Business Edition 10.0.22621

Menu develop, go to Photo, Edit in, Edit in Photoshop 2024

Photoshop isn't recognized

If you want to edit Lightroom photos as layers in Photoshop, same problem

[mikelarremore]

When can we expect a fix for this to be rolled out?

[Murilo Moser]

Hello team, please I need help,

  I use Lightroom Classic to edit my work photos. And when necessary, I open them in Photoshop Beta, through the Lightroom menu itself. Until recently, everything was working normally, the photo opened quickly in PS Beta, the edits were made, file saved and that's it, everything fine, with an edited copy in Lightroom. But recently, it's taking a long time to the photo open in PS Beta. After right clicking on the photo in Lighroom, select edit in > edit in Adobe Photoshop Beta, the PS Beta opens after the request, but the photo does not. After about 2 minutes, an alert message appears on LR. And when I click ok, even the error message saying that the PS could not be launched (and it's there opened), the photo finally opens in the Photoshop Beta.

  This whole situation is really hampering my workflow. I already uninstalled the programs and preferences, reinstalled, however it did not solve. Does anyone have a light?

I'm using the programs on a Macbook Air M1 with Mac OS Ventura 13.4.1(c)

LR Classic version 12.4 Release Camera RAW 15.4
PS Beta version 25.0.0

Thank you very much in advance

[rodrigohudson]

Estava com o PS 23 e PS Beta 24 instalados, e o LrC só abria as edições no Beta, removi o Beta e agora o LrC não "encontra" o PS 23 para editar as fotos.

Como solucionar?

[robertr99848958]

I now have to figure out why I have to Close Photoshop Beta to open a new image from Lightroom Classic every time and why I cannot open two images from Lightroom Classic in Photoshop Beta

iMac Intel 3.7GHz.6 Core i5 Radeon Pro 580x 8 GB Ventura 13.4 128 GB memory 

[Peter28891188d2v5]

When I try to send a file from Lightroom to Photoshop by way of the drop down "edit in" Photoshop opens wiith a review page not the file I sent. After about 2 minutes of not doing anything I get an error message in Lightroom that says the file can't be edited because Photoshop didn't open. When I click the ok button on the error message the file opens in Photoshop (Beta). 

[AxelMatt]

@rodrigohudson  Use the Adobe Creative Cloud Application to uninstall Photoshop 2023. When asked, keep preferences! After this reinstall Photoshop again.

If this doesn't help the nest step is to reinstall both apps Lightroom and Photoshop. Please folloe the steps below:

1. Open the Adobe Creative Cloud Desktop Client and uninstall both Photoshop and Lightroom Classic. When asked, keep preferences! 

2. Install Photoshop first and then Lightroom Classic. The right order is very important here!

[Paul229640190s2u]

Photo/edit in/edit in PS.

PS will open but no photo.