Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm coming from Vegas Pro 13, and in vegas when you move the playback head, the video doesn't pause. Is there any way to replicate this in Premiere? I find it really hard to get used to it pausing all the time.
This doesn't exist in Premiere yet, unfortunately. Submit a feature request, and hopefully it'll show up soon. It's a basic and much needed feature.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This doesn't exist in Premiere yet, unfortunately. Submit a feature request, and hopefully it'll show up soon. It's a basic and much needed feature.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Premiere Pro does not assume anything, which is good. It will do only what you tell it to do, so if you want to continue playing, you need to tell PP to do so by hitting the spacebar again.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I think the issue is that it is assuming that you want to pause when you haven't told it to pause.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It's not assuming anything. You moved the playhead to a new frame. It correctly stays there until you move it again, in this case with the Play command.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Sure it is. Why would it (or you) assume I want to stop at that new frame?
Continuing playback is a handy way of previewing cuts. I'd prefer it if Premiere built in an option for this.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It's not an assumption. You stopped playback by moving the playhead to a new frame. You did that. The editor, the user. PP does what you tell it to. So if you put the playhead on a frame, it properly stays there until you tell it otherwise.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm still not sure why you're convinced that moving the playhead is an instruction to stop playback. It isn't for me, and it isn't for the person who started this topic, and I know for a fact that we are not alone in this expectation.
There are already 2 explicit instructions for Premiere to stop playback - Spacebar and K. Moving the playhead is not an instruction to stop playback. It is, as should be obvious, an instruction to move the playhead. Doing anything more is an (unwanted for some) assumption on the part of the software. If Premiere was really doing what I was telling it to do, it would stop playback when I tell it to stop playback, by pressing the keys explicitly assigned to stopping playback, and not assuming otherwise.
You seem almost passionately opposed to having a feature that would allow for a quicker way to preview cuts and loops, and again, I'm not sure why that is.
As an option that toggles this behaviour it will only allow Premiere to become a more robust editing application. Surely we can agree on this at least?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
No. Premiere stopped playback when clicking the timeline. Premiere is programmed to stop there where you click. It doesn't assume anything, it does care for you at all. Your way of thinking the software is constructed is not quite robotic enough to be correct. It's a shame it cannot be configured to work this way. But then a lot of users really don't mind the added layer of action to make something happen. Some programs really seem to enjoy extra clicks or corners that need to be made in order to get something done.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Can some one explain to me how this works
when you move the playback head, the video doesn't pause.
How is the playhead moved..by what action?
In which screen / panel are we talking about? Monitors, sequence, bin previews?
How does Vegas know when you actually want to stop on a frame so you can edit it, set an edit point, make a cut, apply a transition?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
So far I've only attempted to move the playback head in the timeline and preview windows.
In Vegas if you move the head while it's playing it keeps playing at the new location. If you move it while it's not playing it doesn't move at the new location.
It's occasionally annoying if I forget to pause it before trying to move it to a specific location but it also allows me to quickly click around the video looking at things without pressing space every time
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Also I'm talking about moving it by clicking where you want it, not dragging it.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
How is the playhead moved..by what action?
In which screen / panel are we talking about? Monitors, sequence, bin previews?
How does Vegas know when you actually want to stop on a frame so you can edit it, set an edit point, make a cut, apply a transition?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
shooternz wrote
How is the playhead moved..by what action?
By clicking on the time ruler, or making a time jump via keyboard with the arrow keys.
shooternz wrote
How does Vegas know when you actually want to stop on a frame so you can edit it, set an edit point, make a cut, apply a transition?
When you press Stop.
Also, just so there's (hopefully) no confusion, the feature request is to not interrupt playback when you move the playhead. If video is not currently playing, you can move the playhead exactly like you would in Premiere without activating playback.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Megaman1571 wrote
I'm coming from Vegas Pro 13, and in vegas when you move the playback head, the video doesn't pause. Is there any way to replicate this in Premiere? I find it really hard to get used to it pausing all the time.
As a longtime Premiere user this would drive me crazy.
I dont like this in FCPx either.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I also really want this feature. So, here is my feature request, I think it outlines the preferred behavior. But, I would also like other thoughts on each of the use cases. And without a forum post, there really is no room for discussing features anywhere....
I am posting to this thread because it was the first google return.
--------
How would you like the feature to work?
--
This feature should be implemented as an OPTION, not a forced change for all users. A checkbox/mark labeled: Continue playback after seek. (or something of that nature)
In any of APP's timelines: If the video or audio is currently playing, and the playhead is moved independently of realtime playback, playing should continue as expected.
Use cases (all while in 'play' state):
1.No interaction: playing continues until end, or out point. Identical to current behavior.
2.Using keyboard 'back 1 frame': This moves the playhead back 1 frame when the signal is received. So, the actual result will depend on keyboard type (ps2/usb), repeated key rate (OS setting), and playback framerate. i.e. if playing @ 60fps and key repeat rate is only 30 times per second, would have the effect of halving playback speed.
3.Using keyboard 'forward 1 frame': This moves the playhead forward 1 frame when the signal is received. Effectively increasing playback speed for the duration of the key press.
4.Using mouse to drag playhead: this would behave similarly to how mouse behaves now. Except, if we were in a play-state onDragStart, then re-enter play-state onRelease.
5.Using UI buttons: Clicking buttons for 'In', 'Out', previous, or next frames, should jump the playhead to any of those positions, exactly as it does now. Except, if we were in a play-state onButtonDown, re-enter play-state on enterFrame.
Why is this feature important to you?
--
It saves time and an innumerable amount of repetitive user actions (hitting space bar over and over and over). Ideally, I would be able to enter a play-state, that would allow me to quickly make playhead adjustments, and set in/out points without have to hit another button or key to go back to what I was already doing, playing through a video.
--------
Hopefully is describes what others are looking for. But, unless people actually request the feature, it will never be implemented.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Cheers and thank you! I'd like to revive this feature request- would be extrememly useful as an option for me when nearing the completion of an edit and just doing last-minute fine tuning and adjustment for the 'flow' of a piece.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Absolutely agree, a really annoying thing that this is not an option. In Cubase this is precisely an option that can be toggled.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Why do we want to keep audio playing when you move the playhead in Premiere? If you're arranging the tracks for a YT music playlist and you have 30 or 40 tracks to go through, it makes a huge difference if the audio keeps playing so you can zip quickly from track to track instead of having to restart every single time. Premiere, please add this as an option!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Good point but we are at adobe premire 14.2 and we still dont have this basic feature yet.. Every other video editor does it...
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Use this autohotkey script. Will only work when you right click the grey area on time line, so you could left click when you don't want to play after repositioning. Credits to Taran from LinusTechTips for this script, I just added L key to it after repositioning.
#SingleInstance force ; only 1 instance of this script may run at a time.
#InstallMouseHook
#InstallKeybdHook
CoordMode, Mouse, screen
CoordMode, Pixel, screen
Menu, Tray, Icon, imageres.dll, 90
;THIS IS A GREAT FIRST SCRIPT FOR AHK NOOBS! IT WORKS WITH VERY LITTLE SETUP. JUST READ THE STUFF BELOW! YAY!
;VIDEO EXPLANATION: https://youtu.be/O6ERELse_QY?t=23m40s
; +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
; NOTE THAT YOU MUST ASSIGN \ (backslash) to "Move playhead to cursor" in Premiere's keyboard shortcuts panel!
; YOU SHOULD ALSO ASSIGN CTRL ALT D to "DESELECT ALL"
; +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
;NOTE: I use the right mouse button for this because my current mouse does not have macro keys on it. I could use the middle mouse button, but it requires too much pressure to push down so often, and you have to be careful not to accidentally scroll it.
;But if you want to use a button other than the right mouse button, the script becomes a lot simpler. Scroll down to the bottom for that script.
;NOTE: This does not, and cannot work on the timeline where there are no tracks visible.
;Explanation: https://twitter.com/boxrNathan/status/927371468371103745
;That is color 0x212121, and last I checked, it shows up in many other places in premiere, not just that part of the timeline.
;The easy solution is to just fill up your timeline with tracks; have no blank space.
;---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
;First, we define all the timeline's DEFAULT possible colors.
;(Note that your colors will be different if you changed the UI brightness inside preferences > appearance > brightness.)
;I used Window Spy (it comes with AHK) to detect the exact colors onscreen.
timeline1 = 0x414141 ;timeline color inside the in/out points ON a targeted track
timeline2 = 0x313131 ;timeline color of the separating LINES between targeted AND non targeted tracks inside the in/out points
timeline3 = 0x1b1b1b ;the timeline color inside in/out points on a NON targeted track
timeline4 = 0x202020 ;the color of the bare timeline NOT inside the in out points
timeline5 = 0xDFDFDF ;the color of a SELECTED blank space on the timeline, NOT in the in/out points
timeline6 = 0xE4E4E4 ;the color of a SELECTED blank space on the timeline, IN the in/out points, on a TARGETED track
timeline7 = 0xBEBEBE ;the color of a SELECTED blank space on the timeline, IN the in/out points, on an UNTARGETED track
#IfWinActive ahk_exe Adobe Premiere Pro.exe ;exact name was gotten from windowspy
;--------EVERYTHING BELOW THIS LINE WILL ONLY WORK INSIDE PREMIERE PRO!----------
Rbutton::
MouseGetPos X, Y
PixelGetColor colorr, %X%, %Y%, RGB
if (colorr = timeline5 || colorr = timeline6 || colorr = timeline7) ;these are the timeline colors of a selected clip or blank space, in or outside of in/out points.
send {ESC} ;in Premiere 13.0, ESCAPE will now deselect clips on the timeline, in addition to its other uses. i think it is good ot use here, now. But you can swap this out with CTRL SHIFT D if you like.
;send ^!d ;in Premiere, set CTRL ALT D to "DESELECT ALL"
if (colorr = timeline1 || colorr = timeline2 || colorr = timeline3 || colorr = timeline4 || colorr = timeline5 || colorr = timeline6 || colorr = timeline7) ;alternatively, i think I can use "if in" for this kind of thing..
{
;BREAKTHROUGH -- it looks like a middle mouse click will BRING FOCUS TO a panel without doing ANYTHING ELSE like selecting or going through tabs or anything. Unfortunately, i still can't know with AHK which panel is already in focus.
click middle ;sends the middle mouse button to BRING FOCUS TO the timeline, WITHOUT selecting any clips or empty spaces between clips. very nice!
; tooltip, % GetKeyState("Rbutton", "P") ;<----this was essential for me to figure out EXACTLY how AHK wanted this query to be phrased. Why should i need the quotation marks?? Why does it return a 1 and 0, but for the other method, it returns U and D? Who the hell knows...
; if GetKeyState("$Rbutton") = D ;<--- see, this line did not work AT ALL.
if GetKeyState("Rbutton", "P") = 1 ;<----THIS is the only way to phrase this query.
{
;tooltip, we are inside the IF now
;sleep 1000
;tooltip,
loop
{
Send \ ;in premiere, this must be set to "move playhead to cursor."
Send l ;
Tooltip, Right click playhead mod! ;you can remove this line if you don't like the tooltip. You don't need it!
sleep 16 ;this loop will repeat every 16 milliseconds.
if GetKeyState("Rbutton", "P") = 0
{
;msgbox,,,time to break,1 ;I use message boxes when debugging, and then just comment the out rather than deleting them. It's just like disabling a clip in Premiere.
tooltip,
goto theEnd
break
}
}
}
;tooltip,
Send {escape} ;in case you end up inside the "delete" right click menu from the timeline
;MouseClick, left ;notice how this is commented out. I deemed it inferior to using ESCAPE.
}
else
sendinput {Rbutton} ;this is to make up for the lack of a ~ in front of Rbutton. ... ~Rbutton. It allows the command to pass through, but only if the above conditions were NOT met.
theEnd:
Return
;If you don't want to use Rbutton (the right mouse button), then you don't need to check for colors and things. This simplifies the script siginificantly.
;In the following script, You can change "Mbutton" to anything else. like "Xbutton1", or even "F12" if you wanted.
;So, assuming you've mapped "move playhead to cursor" to the \ key, the problem is that it fires once, waits 1 second, and only then does it continue to fire.
;that's why I use a loop - to send constant keypresses, for a smooth experience.
;SCRIPT HAS NOT YET BEEN TESTED BY ME.
;;;;;Mbutton::\ ;<----this would be the STUPID way of doing this. BAD BAD BAD! do not want!
; Mbutton::
; if GetKeyState("Mbutton", "P") = 1
; {
; loop
; {
; Send \ ;in premiere, this must be set to "move playhead to cursor."
; Tooltip, Middle click playhead mod!
; sleep 16 ;this loop will repeat every 16 milliseconds.
; if GetKeyState("Mbutton", "P") = 0
; {
; ;msgbox,,,time to break,1
; tooltip,
; goto theEnd2
; break
; }
; }
; }
; theEnd2:
; Return
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The upper part of the script doesn't do anything for me in Premiere Pro CC 2018.
The lower part you put behind ; doesn't keep the video playing while moving the scrub marker, but at least it does allow for dragging the marker from anywhere within that timeline area, not just the top part.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Actually, the bottom part of the script isn't that useful for me, either, because I bound it to leftclick, which intereferes with everything else you do with leftclick while in Premiere Pro.
Find more inspiration, events, and resources on the new Adobe Community
Explore Now