P: Lightroom Classic>Edit in PS: Long Delay+Erroneous Error Message opening Ps Beta 2024 25.0

[crysania4]

I just recently updated Photoshop Beta to 2024 v25.0 on my Windows 11 machine.

Now when I try to open photos from LR 12.4 using the "edit in...", it hangs up for a time and then comes up saying "The file could not be edited because Adobe Photoshop 2024 could not be launched."

When I hit "Ok" it then opens the file in Photoshop 2024. 

This happens with every file, even if Photoshop 2024 is already up and running at the time. 

This does not happen with 2023 v24.7.

[dbrigleb]

I forgot to mention that LRC reports that it can't launch PS beta and after clicking through the alert screen, it loads the image into PS.

[fotografiamoreno]

Can't believe this is still yet in the "reporting to the beta team" stage after a week.  I am not an guru tech but this was very basic from the start and yet the beta went out.  No an alpha test first?  Sorry, blowing some steam.  

[annek1992]

I use a Macbook Pro  OS Ventura Version 13.2.1 I use Lightroom Classic to organize and do minor edits and open photos through Lightroom into Photoshop to do major edits. 

For the last two days anytime I have selected - Edit in Photoshop within Lightroom Classic (version 12.4) it will open Photoshop (version 24.7.0) but it won't "transfer" the picture into it to edit it. I have tried closing the apps and even turned my computer off and rebooted. It's still doing it. Is anyone else having this problem or just me? Any solutions would be much appreciated. 

[lindam25606643]

I have Lightroom Classic working on images and doing fine tuning in photoshop Beta. Going from Lightroom Classic to Photoshop beta is very slow. 

[DdeGannes]

Try updating your macOS to version 13.4.1.

[daniellaj79171508]

Hello, 

I keep getting this error when I try opening my RAW imagse from Lightroom to edit in PS Beta. Lightroom lags, then does the following. 

1. First error: The files cannont be edited because Adobe Photoshop beta could not be launched. 

2. Once i hit ok, it then will either open or have the second error box stating "AgStoreProviderSession:getEntityByID: id must be a number or string."

3. Then the image will either open fine in PS or it looses data like the image attached. 

I am operating on a:

MacBook Pro (14-inch, 2021)

Apple M1 Max

Memory 64 GB 

MAC OS Montery Version 12.21.1

My light room and PS Beta are up to date.

Can anyone help? 

[TxRanger]

When I attempt to export file from LRC it only recognizes PS2023 although Beta is open.  Then gives a message that could not export and could not launch PS2023.  I hit OK and it then opens the file in PS beta.

I  don't have the same issue on my i-7 machine.

[pianoman481973]

really furstrating that the most basic integration between LR and PS is not working and still this version has been released ...

[brianw79828710]

You could try setting the retail PS as the second Edit-In option in Lightroom. Navigate to its folder and select photoshop.exe

 For the past week I simply transferred the image to Beta manually but have now downgraded to the previous beta version and all is well and I don't seem to be missing out on any features.

You can't install Beta without the retail PS installed, but I wonder if you then disabled [by renaming it's exe file] or even deleted the original PS would that solve the issue? 

Another idea is to create a shortcut to the beta photoshop.exe and point LR to that for the alternative editor?

[JohanElzenga]

Did you install Photoshop beta as well? This is a known bug. The work-around for now is to uninstall both versions of Photoshop and then reinstall Photoshop 24.7. If you want to use Photoshop beta as well, then install the previous version, not the latest version.

[Niobium007]

Problème de blocage, transfert ne s'effectue que de façon tout à fait aléatoire. C'est souvent impossible

[Simon222133136wpo]

Same problem here only im on windows, trying to open layers in photoshop, photoshop opens then stops only for light room to proudly announce it cant lauch photoshop!

[Holger31507093ivjw]

Hallo zusammen

Ich habe das folgende Problem: wenn ich ein Bild von Lightrom zum Photoshop schicken will - über "in Adobe Photoshop 2023 öffnen" öffnet sich Photoshop - bleibt allerdings beim Startbildschirm hängen. Das selbe Problem taucht auf, wenn ich mehrere Bilder von Lightroom zum Photoshop über "in Photoshop als Ebene öffnen" schicken möchte. Das hat früher problemlos funktioniert.

Mac Ventura 13.2

Lightroom Version 12.4

Photoshop Version 24.7.0

Besten Dank für eine Hilfe

[Ian Lyons]

Which version of Photoshop are you having a problem with?

If it's the Photoshop beta or you've installed but not using the beta, then the below linked thread identifies the issue and workaround. 

https://community.adobe.com/t5/photoshop-beta-bugs/p-lightroom-classic-gt-edit-in-ps-long-delay-erro...

[brianw79828710]

I discovered that selecting Edit Original in LR works with the latest Beta PS.

So clearly it is something to do with the creation of the intermediate file containing the LR edits that is the problem.

[Eric269890627poe]

i'm very surprised that this problem last so long, the only solution for all users of LRC+PS or PS Beta, is to downgrade to a version with no "generative fill" tool, what if this was done on purpose by Adobe, because there "generative fill " tool have so much success that it needs a tremendous broadband to transmit data??? because from LRC we still modify in Capture 1, ON1 etc but not the latest version of PS...

[DdeGannes]

@Eric269890627poe , the latest released versions of LrC and PS are LrC 12.4 and PS 24.7.

Photoshop “Beta” is not a released version.

When you use LrC edit in ON1, or another third party application a tiff file is created by LrC and opened in the other application.

[dbrigleb]

It is now the next morning and I have found a PS beta update in the CC updates section.(:  After doing the update and restarting my computer I find that nothing has changed. 😞 The issue is exactly the same.

Could the issue being within LR? Partially or fully?

[AxelMatt]

Please Consider including the following in your question:

• Adobe product and version number
• Operating system and version number
• The full text of any error message (s)
• What you were doing when the problem occurred
• Screenshots of the problem
• Computer hardware, such as CPU; GPU; the amount of RAM; etc

Thanks. The above info will help to solve your problem.

[laurab21876735]

j'ai le même soucis et c'est fatigant, impossible de traiter correctement les reportages 😕

[defaultfdix8mc44qlp]

After installing photoshop beta, I can no longer open an image from lightroom into photoshop. In the preferences in lightroom, there was only 2024 as an option version while I also have v24.7 installed. It would open photoshop but then not open the image. I removed the beta version of photoshop and now it wont let me choose which photoshop version to open in from lighroom. Ive unistalled and reinstalled both without any fixes. 

[scorpion1948]

Leider kann ich nur berichten, dass ich dasselbe Problem habe. In den Voreinstellungen kann ich nauch Deinstallation der Beta-Version 25.0.0 überhaupt keine Verbindung mehr einstellen, also auch nicht zum "normalen" Photoshop 2023. Des Weiteren sind sämtliche Bearbeitungsmöglichkeiten "in Photoshop als Panoramabild..." oder in "Photoshop als Ebenen" öffen nicht mehr möglich, seit dem Beta 25.0.0 installiert ist und auch nach Deinstallation bleiben die Felder grau.

[kglad]

roll back your beta version to the previous 24.6

<moved from cc desktop bugs>

[defaultsxu8kxm5bfgw]

Thank you, works fine for me now with the version 24.6

[default2vk703grce02]

The recent Photoshop update seems to work now, but i'm too chicken to reinstall Beta.
How do I stop getting emails about the hundereds of people having this problem?