Skip to main content
Participant
June 30, 2019
解決済み

Mirror tool malfunctions

  • June 30, 2019
  • 返信数 2.
  • 708 ビュー

Hi nice photoshop intelligent people.   I wonder if you can assist.

Ive been playing for a while now with the photoshop mirror/mandala type tool and I kinda like it, its made me discover art that I am actually capable of art. However, it does something I dont understand, well I sort of do, but not enough.

so, lets setup a document, new and shiny, stick on the mirroring tool on radial setting, and .. pick a 1 pt pencil and draw some stuff, now go back to outline it in 2pt pencil.. if you concentrate working on the same segment, look around after doing the outline, often the outline leaves gaps on other segments.. why does it do this??

part of me knows the answer is rounding errors, but, it seems they are recalculated for each segment, rather than actually duplicated around the circle..

it leads to making a mess

Its a shame, that its also limited in  number of repetitions to 10, where as krita does 60 only annoyance with krita is that it doesnt do a pencil like tool that doesnt feather out the colour

このトピックへの返信は締め切られました。
解決に役立った回答 davescm

Hi

Brush symmetry will calculate by segment but the problem with using it on the pencil tool is that the pencil tool works in single whole pixels without any anti-aliasing. As soon as a horizontal line is turned into a sloping line then the drawn slope, using whole pixels, can only approximate the actual diagonal required and Photoshop therefore has to draw a series of steps using the nearest whole pixels. That will vary by the slope in each segment.
If you use the brush tool instead, you will find the anti-aliasing, which is there to smooth out those steps, takes care of the issue.

If you want to put in a feature request to enhance the tool you can do so here:

Photoshop Family Customer Community

Dave

返信数 2

davescm
Community Expert
davescmCommunity Expert解決!
Community Expert
June 30, 2019

Hi

Brush symmetry will calculate by segment but the problem with using it on the pencil tool is that the pencil tool works in single whole pixels without any anti-aliasing. As soon as a horizontal line is turned into a sloping line then the drawn slope, using whole pixels, can only approximate the actual diagonal required and Photoshop therefore has to draw a series of steps using the nearest whole pixels. That will vary by the slope in each segment.
If you use the brush tool instead, you will find the anti-aliasing, which is there to smooth out those steps, takes care of the issue.

If you want to put in a feature request to enhance the tool you can do so here:

Photoshop Family Customer Community

Dave

jane-e
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 30, 2019

Tagging davescm​ to answer this.