Skip to main content
Known Participant
February 17, 2025
質問

Banding on 32bit float, viewport and exports

  • February 17, 2025
  • 返信数 1.
  • 170 ビュー

So I have been trying to get my head around colour management for a long time and have read up on it quite a bit. I understand bit depth, profiles, gamma curves. I have a good monitor (Benq pd2700u) and have calibrated it.

 

I had noticed a little banding on gradients in After Effects and thought this is usual for 8bit, maybe my monitor wasn't quite up to scratch. But I thought I'd try a little experiment and so made the same gradient in Blender and what do you know it had no banding. So I tried creating a 32 bit float project in after efffects with a gradient - exported it to exr and opened it in blender - it has banding. I've attached a screen shot and AE file. Could someone please help me to understand what is going on here.

返信数 1

nishu_kush
Community Manager
Community Manager
February 18, 2025

Thanks for reaching out, Ignatz Johnson Higham.

I am on M2 MAX and tested your file on the Macbook Pro screen and on my old Dell monitor. I didn't see any banding at 16-bit or 32-bit. Could you let us know your system specifications so that I can test in a similar environment?

Looking forward to your response.


Thanks,
Nishu