InDesign Column Break and Keep Issues

I'm really under a time crunch and I can't seem to figure out what the issue is.... I have set the keep on the paragraphs to "Keep All Lines in Paragraph Together" but lines are still breaking. The text is supposed to keep flowing in the same left column, but I really don't know know what's going on. I have other files using the same paragraph styles, so I've imported them and replaced all the styles in this file. It still won't go away and it's just this file with the issue... Does someone know what might be going on? How can i fix this?

Overall view with settings...

When I show my conditional text... you see the breaks where they shouldn't be even though I have set it to keep all the lines together...

I don't know why it moves my text into the next column like I have a column break. I suspect it might have something to do with the 'keep all lines together'. But it doesn't do that with my other files...