P: Generated images violate user guidelines

[Hematita]

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

[kawaki]

Okay putting periods in sometimes helps BUT the nudity does matter.  Adobe, please address this issue of censorship.  Please continue your long standing support of open creativity.  We are artists, photographers and creaters.  Please respect that.

[daniellei4510]

As I've mentioned elsewhere, I put clothing (usually swimwear tops and bottoms) on entirely nude models to make them suitable for Facebook (talk about censorship!) and have never had problems. At least none that I couldn't find work-arounds for. If skin or nudity is the cause of any issues, it still to me is the result of a bug.

[kawaki]

No word should be "in question"

[daniellei4510]

Every legitimate AI platform has a banned word list. And always will.

[kawaki]

"legitmate"?   Really?  What is legitmate AI?  There are some very "legitimate" AI engines that allow for creativity without word censorship.  These I will be using rather than Adobe's poor attempt at a narrow market. 

[daniellei4510]

"Legitimate" as in virtually every popular AI platform available today. 

[daniellei4510]

And you are certainly welcome to do so.

[Saiyab325449548gf4]

 Nothing can solve it...😑😑

[CoryShubert]

@Saiyab325449548gf4 

Adobe has limited access to the generative fill and generative expand features to customers with a valid subscription to a plan that includes Photoshop ( Creative Cloud, Single app or Photography plan).

Potential customers can try Photoshop and the generative features by signing up for a 7 day trial here - https://www.adobe.com/downloads.html 

If you believe that you have are incorrectly receiving the above error and qualify to use the generative features, please contact technical support.

[brombres]

I got this warning pop-up for something innocuous, then it automatically disappeared before I could click on anything. Is there way for me to find that notification again so I can click Request Review? If not I suggest the warnings stay up until an action is chosen.

The new Generative AI is fantastic, BTW. Finally brought be back to Photoshop after all these years. Looking forward to seeing these small bugs get worked out!

[daniellei4510]

To the best of my knowledge, once it's gone, it's gone.

[CSI Productions]

I received an image generated with the iPhone app called MyMood Ai: Avatar Photo Editor. It generates an averaged image based on pictures uploaded. It does an excellent job and even puts the model in various clothes that compliment the subject. Suitable for corporate headshots and they're excellent. As with a lot of AI apps currently available, it screws up the hands and even (occassionally) adds a third arm which is truley bizzare.

All this being said (BTW this is a corporate headshot for my daughter). I wanted to extend the background but it said I didn't have copywrite ownership so it wouldn't allow it. I can do it the old fashioned way - which I did but Gen Fill wouldn't let me.

What I found interesting is the hand had deformed fingers and she liked the photo but the hand looked seriously bad. Gen fill "did" allow me to encircle the arm and with no prompt, replace it with the appropriate background - which it did really well.

I was curious why it wouldn't let be extend the background but it would let me fix the hand. Is this normal?

TY.

R.Cates

[Jann Lipka]

Most recent  PS Beta ( the same result from released version ) 
new level of  AI  paranoia :
Anything that looks somewhat  reddish is forbidden ....
( provided feedback couple of times but of course that doesnt help ) 
where is " prolong deadline"  button 🙂  ? 

[daniellei4510]

Could you provide the original image in its entirely? I'd like to give it a try. 

[Jann Lipka]

As expected AI is easy to manipulate - 
Moral algorithm is sensitive to all red tones . 
Workaround is to invert image ( so it becomes cyan - ish ) then use Generative Fill ( it works ) 
Invert the image again - and You are back into " forbidden tones" area. 

[kevin stohlmeyer]

@Jann Lipka what prompt were you using and what was the expected outcome? There is no "bias" for red tone images at all.

[Jann Lipka]

Zero prompt - i just wanted to remove creases in the fabrics 
You can download my file - and check - 
when red - No go - violation 
Inverted to cyan  - it works . 

[kevin stohlmeyer]

@Jann Lipka So this is not a case of "AI Paranoia" - as noted extensively in here, leaving the prompt blank can lead to false flag errors. Selecting the same area you noted and adding a prompt "Smooth fabric" worked just fine with your original image. No need to invert a reddish image.

[Jann Lipka]

OK noted and indeed it worked OTOH 
"tooltip " dialog specifically mentions NOT to 
fill any prompt when removing things just making loose selection . So thats what I did 

[daniellei4510]

I had no problem with it, either, using a period as a prompt.

[kevin stohlmeyer]

@Jann Lipka When you have specific needs, adding a prompt is best. Otherwise I compare it to throwing dirt in a windstorm with the expectation that it lands all back in your hand. Users need to be detailed and descriptive with prompts when you have specific needs or leave it all to chance.

With Generative Fill 1.0 leaving it blank can cause false violations - as stated throughout this thread.

[CSI Productions]

Just an observation - Unless I'm missing something, the two images of the wrinkled curtain which you say worked doesn't look any different than the original (at least not noticibly). What am I missing?

[daniellei4510]

Maybe I'm having better luck with generative fill more than others because I've only used it once to add something. Otherwise, I use it to remove things (with the exception of Generative Expand, and only then when I want to change the aspect ratio to expand an empty background). The only time I've used GF. to add something was to add a highway next to a hitchhiker and it required a good 20+ attempts to get something acceptable. 

[Jann Lipka]

OK so not following tooltip seems to work best . 
( "remove wrinkles " prompt works - No prompt give me violation 
Screenshot 5 minutes ago ( I thought maybe AI learned from my tries ( 10 times " providing feedback" )
- I lost probably 50 credits on this .-) 
I have most recent Beta ( OSX )

[kevin stohlmeyer]

@CSI Productions I didnt do the entire curtain - just the specific area that @Jann Lipka had selected before. Those are just two examples the second does show a smooth curtain without a wrinkle in that specific area.